They should go just to get Batista & Orton in the HOF because neither one should make it alone. When I think of Hall Of Fame... we're talking guys who drive the car. Not Goldberg, but DDP & Sting... Not Brock Lesnar, but well see below
Wrestlers who deserve Hall Of Fame Rings
Undertaker
Triple H
The Rock
Chris Jericho
Well, to quote the current WWE Champion, "It doesn't matter what you think." Regardless of how you feel about who should be in the Hall of Fame, the fact remains that the WWE Hall of Fame has inducted the likes of Koko B. Ware, George Steele, Jim Duggan, Greg Valentine, the Junk Yard Dog and Bob Orton. Clearly, the WWE is a bit more open as to who "deserves a Hall of Fame Ring."
Now, if you can look at that list, and tell me that Batista and Randy Orton - two guys who won a combined 16 World Titles between them - won't get in on their own, then you're crazy. The only thing that could possibly keep them out is their relationship with the McMahon family (Vince, Stephanie, Triple H).
And that's why I say absolutely NO to Evolution. Inducting Evolution would make Flair a three-time inductee ... Triple H a three-time inductee (solo, DX, Evolution) ... and Orton and Batista two-time inductees. At a point, it's overkill.
And that's not even mentioning the fact that I think Evolution is a grossly overrated stable that is remembered for being more than they were. They weren't the Four Horsemen. They weren't the NWO. Hell, they weren't even DX. If the WWE is going to go the route of inducting stables - then those are the ONLY three North American stables that should even be given consideration for the Hall of Fame (and I only include DX in that group due to their impact on ratings during the Monday Night Wars.)
Sometimes, I read threads about Evolution and I feel like I'm going crazy. How does everyone else remember the stable as something more than I remember it - a group that struggled to gain any traction during its first year, and then failed in its primary objective (keeping the title on Triple H) during its second year.
Evolution - as a foursome - started in February 2005. Soon after it was formed, Batista AND Orton were both injured, and the group wasn't "reformed" until Batista returned in late October. Even then, the faction was still barely a faction as Batista was an after thought, and Orton was competing in a 5-on-5 S.S. team that consisted of no other Evolution members. It wasn't until December when the faction finally started gaining any steam (10 months after it was "formed").
I'll agree with the board when I say that Evolution was one of - if not THE - strongest booked stables in history for a very brief time when they held the World Title, IC Title and Tag Titles simultaneously. But that dominance really ended at 'Mania when Triple H lost his World Title to Chris Benoit. And while Orton kept the IC Title through July, the stable - as a foursome - dissolved a month later when Orton took the title from Benoit and Triple H turned on him. So pretty much - while most people remember this stable as lasting a long time - the Evolution that people remember was really around for less than 9 months.
I get it when people discuss how the group consisted of four former or future World Champions. But to me, that's not enough to warrant them being inducted as a group. Hell, the Corporation had seven future or former World Champs (Triple H, Rock, Big Show, Shawn Michaels, Kane, Sgt Slaughter and Vince) - the Corporate Ministry had five (Taker, Triple H, JBL, Faarooq, Vince) - and I don't think either of those groups should ever be considered for the Hall of Fame. (For fun, The Dungeon of Doom had three ... Big Show, Vader, Luger)
All that said - I'm sure Evolution will be inducted as a stable some day. The group was the brainchild of Triple H, and he'll be making the HOF decisions before too long. And again, I'll point to the list I posted above ... if Koko B. Ware can be inducted into the Hall of Fame once, then there's no reason Triple H won't put himself in three times.