This is like that old report about The Miz being blamed for the Survivor Series buyrate...the report was that sources said some in the WWE believed upper management were blaming The Miz. Who were the sources? Don't know. Who were the people that believed this and why did they believe it? No idea. Who were the people in upper management that were supposedly blaming The Miz? Not a clue. But, sure enough, the IWC ran with it as if Vince McMahon himself had sent out a vine where he personally put all the blame on The Miz.
This is only slightly more credible. Meltzer is claiming that a source told him a big star believes it's 100%. So it's 3rd hand information instead of 4th hand information. But what it has in credibility is lost in motive. Obviously, it greatly benefits the WWE if people think Punk is coming back. That means more people will watch. It MIGHT mean the crowd is somewhat less rabid, if they believe he's coming out eventually.(although, admittedly, it won't help much, if at all.)
I wouldn't be surprised if he came back, and I wouldn't be surprised if he didn't. My guess is he does come back, this whole thing has felt fishy from the very beginning, but who knows. The nice thing is, we will know for sure by the end of a Raw if he's done with the WWE or not. If he's coming back at all, this will be when it happens.
If he does come back, what does he do? I'd assume he picks up his feud with Kane and Triple H, since that was clearly the plan before he left. Why abandon it now? Yes, they're hinting at Triple H vs. Daniel Bryan...but let's be honest here. We all know Randy Orton vs. Batista isn't going to be the main event. We all know Daniel Bryan is going to be put in that match one way or another and he's going to win the title. Is he really going to wrestle two matches at Mania? Maybe. I could see it...he has to beat Triple H to get in the title match, then wins the title at the end of the show. I guess that could work. And if Punk's not coming back, that's what they'll have to do. But Triple H-Punk and Orton-Batista-Bryan still works just fine, if Punk does come back.
This is only slightly more credible. Meltzer is claiming that a source told him a big star believes it's 100%. So it's 3rd hand information instead of 4th hand information. But what it has in credibility is lost in motive. Obviously, it greatly benefits the WWE if people think Punk is coming back. That means more people will watch. It MIGHT mean the crowd is somewhat less rabid, if they believe he's coming out eventually.(although, admittedly, it won't help much, if at all.)
I wouldn't be surprised if he came back, and I wouldn't be surprised if he didn't. My guess is he does come back, this whole thing has felt fishy from the very beginning, but who knows. The nice thing is, we will know for sure by the end of a Raw if he's done with the WWE or not. If he's coming back at all, this will be when it happens.
If he does come back, what does he do? I'd assume he picks up his feud with Kane and Triple H, since that was clearly the plan before he left. Why abandon it now? Yes, they're hinting at Triple H vs. Daniel Bryan...but let's be honest here. We all know Randy Orton vs. Batista isn't going to be the main event. We all know Daniel Bryan is going to be put in that match one way or another and he's going to win the title. Is he really going to wrestle two matches at Mania? Maybe. I could see it...he has to beat Triple H to get in the title match, then wins the title at the end of the show. I guess that could work. And if Punk's not coming back, that's what they'll have to do. But Triple H-Punk and Orton-Batista-Bryan still works just fine, if Punk does come back.