Hollywood Naitch
The current reigning and defending
No offense to the awesome people that put this tournament together, but I feel that there should have been a disclaimer of some sorts to clarify whether or not this match was between Mick Foley and all his different persona's or just the character Mick Foley.
The man [not the character] Mick Foley was an enigma because he wrestled with 4 distinctly different characters throughout his career. First you have Dude Love, a character that never rose past the midcard, then there's Cactus Jack, the Hardcore Legend who was as nasty a character as they came but was still a career midcarder. After this you have Mankind, easily Foley's most successul and iconic character. Mankind was a bonofide main eventer and the character most used to represent the man's career. Lastly you have Mick Foley the character; an over-the-hill veteren who strives to use his image to put others over the best he can.
Agreed, if this was Mankind or Cactus Jack...then Foley would win
Dude Love would probably lose to Barrett, as he wasn't really a serious character, just a way of letting Foley's body heal and let him live his childhood dream of playing that character on TV.
But MICK FOLEY was always about putting over talent, and making stars. Randy Orton is a prime example of where working with Foley can boost your career immensely. So, if we are looking at Foley himself vs Barrett, I believe Wade would be given the victory. He has huge potential to become a superstar in the WWE, the size/look/mic skills and his in-ring work is improving all the time.
I think Barrett with a surprise win here, and a big career boost. Tough match though, both men took a beating but a Wasteland ends it. (Wade needs a new finisher urgently!)