There's no accounting for taste. You aren't an idiot if you don't like Kofi; likewise, you aren't sheep for liking Kofi. He's a light weight dude, with lots of jumpy kicky type attacks, and he's got room for improvement on his promos and his physical composure in and out of the ring (like how he holds himself, how he sells, etc.). I don't see how that means he doesn't deserve his spot or a push.
Good to know I'm not the only person who isn't a fan of Kofi. I haven't used this word yet, but I'm gonna throw it out there: Lazy. Everything about his in-ring performance, at least to me, seems lazy. He doesn't sell shit, he has too many botches, and everything he does seems to be half-assed and/or sloppy.
There's plenty of honest criticism that can be said of Kofi, but lazy for sure is not one of them. Lazy gets you sent back to FCW (or will get you a spot somewhere
never on camera in SD). Lazy does not get you a multi PPV angle with the biggest heel in the company. His finishers are fine; no different than what you might see RVD do (referring to Trouble in Paradise).
And I have to question your standards for what a "botch" is.
My understanding of the Orton incident is that there hasn't been any angry tweets about it, or any official mention of it or of any punishment to Kofi, so while the visual evidence is convincing, it's still just an unconfirmed rumor.
And, even assuming it's true and Orton flipped out about missing the Punt cue, the comparison between this situation and the one with Orton and Kennedy is invalid. Kennedy not only *supposedly*
dropped Orton, but he also had been in or around enough other problems in his career that when Orton and Cena went and whined to McMahon it couldn't be passed off as just one of those things (regardless of whether it was or wasn't just Orton being whiney). Kofi didn't drop Orton wrong, he missed a cue. Maybe.
Note that Kofi doesn't have a list of past problems, like being reckless as a worker, or of being injury prone. So moments like his match with Batista isn't cause of unjustified concern, as he's hardly the first guy to get someone to bleed the hard way in a match.
I like Kofi Kingston because he gave me a reason to give a damn about the US Championship last year, because he was able to hold his own in the angle with Orton that they tried (and failed) to give MVP earlier in the year, and because I feel that they have only just now scratched the surface of what and who Kofi Kingston is. He's a much better speaker out of the Jamaican gimmick, he did a lot of work for Wrestlemania this year and he did a great job of it. Let them find a way to get more of that natural feeling into his promos (because heaven forbid you let the guys write their own stuff!). I'm not saying I think the guy is a guaranteed main event draw of the future, but that I think the material is there to be that in time.
On that note, I'd suggest a move to Smackdown, as until draft day, the Raw roster is pretty damn loaded (with the four biggest stars in the company among others). With less time spent on guest hosts, there's more time to invest in Kofi on SD. There's also less worries about hurting one of the top guys by putting Kofi over them (the big four again: Cena, Batista, HHH, and Orton). They seem to be stalling a J Mo push, McIntyre's push is schizophrenic (if they're gonna do it, then do it already), and they seem to want to continue on with the Punk/Mysterio and Edge/Jericho programs. In fact, now that I think about it, let McIntyre and Kofi go at it. Even book it to have McIntyre win! Just make it good and take time with it; it'll do wonders for both.