I am a TNA fan and have been since it's start. I love competition because that makes a better product for us, the fans. But unfortunately, I do not believe Jeff Jarrett is being completely truthful.
The original ECW was making it as a small major promotion or a large independent promotion and the financial problems really started when Heyman disappeared to the west coast in an attempt to take ECW to the next level. I was very happy at the attempt because that meant television shows, video games, and merchandising. But unfortunately, it was a risk that did not pay out and we know how that story ended.
As far as live shows go, I attended TNA events at the old Nashville Fairgrounds (Asylum). I paid $20 to sit within the first two rows. Economically speaking for me, that was awesome. $10 got you a little further back and if you wanted a chance to see the show free, you had to wait in a second line on a first come first serve basis. This was at the time of their Wednesday weekly PPV's (remember those days?) Outside, the arena looked like a farm warehouse. Inside (where it mattered), it was decorated nicely and all the logos and lights made you feel excited. In those days, I high-fived over half of the talent during the show. The wrestler that was the most friendly to the fans at the time was Ron Killings (a.k.a The Truth). I respect him to this day for that. The Asylum did not hold many people and you felt a cult feeling like the original ECW with many of the local southern gals screaming for Chris Sabin. It felt a little hokey when Jeremy Borash would pump up the crowd by promising us a chance to meet the talent after the show if we were extremely loud and excited. I was very loud & excited, but never met the talent. I do watch myself on some DVD's and laugh at how I acted, but it was a chance I had to take to try to meet some, like Traci Brooks who I liked for a little while.
I know, I know. You say that was then and this is now and they are in Orlando, Florida.
They now perform weekly in The Impact Zone, which is a sound stage studio. Last time I checked, admission was free. Remember, this is TNA's home base like The ECW Arena was to ECW. They should be able to charge something, but they are hard up each week to put butts in seats, which is the opposite of "I really want to see a show, I hope I can get in" which is what every promotion aspires to be. Jarrett mentioned that when they travel, they are a lean & mean touring machine. I can believe that part. Less lights & pyro, the ring, and a few TNA banners / signs, if you have seen a house show, which is OK because the performers are why to come out to see them, right?
Now let's get more positive.
TNA does something that WWE does not and that is let their wrestler's do independent bookings for extra money. I remember when Velvet Skye asked for a raise in TNA from $300 a show to $600. I thought to myself, $300 x 52 weeks a year = $15,600. Damn, TNA has a reasonable payroll. The Motor City Machine Guns are excellent performers, they supplement their income with independent bookings very well, and in my opinion, they are extremely important to TNA's success and TNA needs to keep them happy.
The thing that makes TNA wrestlers happy is that they use the television deal to tell their wrestlers. "You can work independent shows at a higher rate of pay because you are a nationally and sometimes internationally recognized superstar, but we cannot afford to pay you WWE type salaries. We encourage independent bookings so that you can earn a living".
The bonus: You don't have to go city to city being whipped by the slavedriver (WWE) You work as much or as little or as comfortable a schedule as you want, but just be back for the weekly tapings and PPV's.
In my opinion, TNA makes money via merchandising (Don West), PPV buyrates (pretty OK), DVD sales (somewhat OK). and a little bit on house shows. I do believe that they expected to do a lot better with Hulk Hogan than they actually are and Hogan's personal problems are not helping matters. I love Hulk Hogan (favorite wrestler of all time) but I hope Dixie can find the courage & strength to tell him, "You are only worth $X amount of dollars to me, take it or leave it, because my ratings did not go up proportionately to your salary, as you and Eric Bischoff promised". Sting was working for $1,000,000 a year on a year to year basis just to give you an idea of what TNA pays some and some wrestlers (Angle, Jeff Hardy, Flair, Hogan) are making more than that.
No way they are turning profit. Don't believe me? Why are they employing tricks like having those two hot blonds week after week in the front row on TV like WCW did in it's dying days? Jarrett was simply talking really positive as all business men do. It's our job to see through that.
I am really happy that all who have worked for TNA (Hogan, Christian, Flair, etc.) have tried to help contribute to TNA's success, but if I was in charge, the really expensive guys like Hogan, Flair, and Bischoff (I am a Bischoff fan too, but...) would not have their contracts renewed. I would love to see the return of Christopher Daniels, Petey Williams, and Awesome Kong and a return to the old days of great matches. And I would love to see both TNA and Ring of Honor give WWE some competition for our sake, the fans.