I created this thread a little over a year and a half ago but times change, people progress, QB's add to their accomplishments and so forth. A new star is born, and old stars fall off the charts. Whether they are plagued by injuries like Palmer, or their career just fell off the face of the earth like Vince Young or even Matt Leinart. I come to you with a list of several "young" QB's who are under the age of thirty, and you are to determine who is the best. You can either vote on the poll or choose the "other" option. Just list who and tell me why. Well, here is the list...
Ben Roethlisberger - He is a two time superbowl champion. He is a one time pro bowler and he is an all around winner. In 2004 Ben Roethlisberger was the Offensive rookie of the year and was the Diet Pepsi rookie of the year. Big Ben has a career 51-20 record in the regular season and he is just as good in the post season with an 8 and 2 record. Ben is known for taking over the 2004 Steelers and leading them to a 15-1 record. Ben was 13-0 as a starter that year until his playoff collapse against New England.
Tony Romo - If I remember correctly he won this poll in like 2007. Romo has a 27-12 record in the regular season, but he has yet to win a playoff game.
Romo is a two time pro bowler.
Matt Ryan - In 2008 Matt Ryan took over the lonely Falcons team and turned them into a playoff caliber team. Ryan finished his rookie season with an 11-5 record. Even though he made an early exit in the playoffs, he still had a rookie campaign worth bragging about.
Joe Flacco - In 2008 Flacco took over a team who was in need of a QB. Not only was he a game manager he was a hell of a QB. Flacco took Baltimore to an 11-5 record. I believe he was the first rookie QB to ever win two games in the playoffs. He was one game away from the SB before getting eliminated by the Steelers.
Matt Casse l- in Cassels first year as a starter, he took the Patriots to a 10-5 record. In my opinion he benefited from having a great offense, but at times he showed he had it.
Eli Manning - Manning came into the NFL the same year as Ben Roethlisberger. He has a 42-29 career record. He also holds a winning record in the post season posting a 4 and 3 record. He is the only other QB on this list to have a SB ring.
Phillips Rivers - Who is regarded as the best young QB in football. Rivers has a 33-15 career record. He also holds a 3-3 record in the playoffs. Rivers is a one time pro bowler.
Jay Cutler - One time pro bowler. Has rocket arm, 17 and 20 career record and has yet to make the playoffs. But did carry a shitty Bronco's team to an 8 and 8 record in 2008-2009.
By now, you should know my pick, and I am not going to defend it just yet. I let off some big name quarterbacks like Palmer and Rodgers. But you can still vote for them. Anyways, here we go, and lets hope this is as successful as the old one....
Ben Roethlisberger - He is a two time superbowl champion. He is a one time pro bowler and he is an all around winner. In 2004 Ben Roethlisberger was the Offensive rookie of the year and was the Diet Pepsi rookie of the year. Big Ben has a career 51-20 record in the regular season and he is just as good in the post season with an 8 and 2 record. Ben is known for taking over the 2004 Steelers and leading them to a 15-1 record. Ben was 13-0 as a starter that year until his playoff collapse against New England.
Tony Romo - If I remember correctly he won this poll in like 2007. Romo has a 27-12 record in the regular season, but he has yet to win a playoff game.
Romo is a two time pro bowler.
Matt Ryan - In 2008 Matt Ryan took over the lonely Falcons team and turned them into a playoff caliber team. Ryan finished his rookie season with an 11-5 record. Even though he made an early exit in the playoffs, he still had a rookie campaign worth bragging about.
Joe Flacco - In 2008 Flacco took over a team who was in need of a QB. Not only was he a game manager he was a hell of a QB. Flacco took Baltimore to an 11-5 record. I believe he was the first rookie QB to ever win two games in the playoffs. He was one game away from the SB before getting eliminated by the Steelers.
Matt Casse l- in Cassels first year as a starter, he took the Patriots to a 10-5 record. In my opinion he benefited from having a great offense, but at times he showed he had it.
Eli Manning - Manning came into the NFL the same year as Ben Roethlisberger. He has a 42-29 career record. He also holds a winning record in the post season posting a 4 and 3 record. He is the only other QB on this list to have a SB ring.
Phillips Rivers - Who is regarded as the best young QB in football. Rivers has a 33-15 career record. He also holds a 3-3 record in the playoffs. Rivers is a one time pro bowler.
Jay Cutler - One time pro bowler. Has rocket arm, 17 and 20 career record and has yet to make the playoffs. But did carry a shitty Bronco's team to an 8 and 8 record in 2008-2009.
By now, you should know my pick, and I am not going to defend it just yet. I let off some big name quarterbacks like Palmer and Rodgers. But you can still vote for them. Anyways, here we go, and lets hope this is as successful as the old one....