Those arguing that Davey Boy was more popular, entertaining, charismatic, etc are really working against their own interests here. Let's assume that's all true (I don't agree, but for the sake of discussion let's): That means Lex Luger accomplished far more in his career (spanning over a decade and a half; not like he was a blip on the radar) with far, far less going for him. When you all extol Davey's virtues, all I'm seeing is further proof that Luger is a huge success story. Vote Luger. If you need further proof that Davey is a big doofus who earned his "midcarder for life" position, feel free to check out the section in Bret's book about how Davey was a guy who needed to be dragged kicking-and-screaming to a good match.