This isn't the best "Movie Game" tourny, this is the best Video Game thread, and if I wanted to, I could play Heavy Rain simply by watching it on youtube.
...Yeah, if you wanted to rob yourself of the experience of having complete control of your character, listening to their thoughts, controlling the actions you wanted to control, and witnessing your own failures unfold before your very eyes.
The "interactive movie" claim is absolute bullshit. Just because a game is cinematic doesn't mean it's an "interactive movie". Are RPGs "interactive books"? You could get the same story if it were novelized, right?
Let's look at the Wikipedia definition of a video game:
Wikipedia said:
A video game is an electronic game that involves interaction with a user interface to generate visual feedback on a video device. ... The electronic systems used to play video games are known as platforms; examples of these are personal computers and video game consoles. ... The input device used to manipulate video games is called a game controller, and varies across platforms. ... Video games typically also use other ways of providing interaction and information to the player. ... Audio is almost universal, using sound reproduction devices, such as speakers and headphones. Other feedback may come via haptic peripherals, such as vibration or force feedback, with vibration sometimes used to simulate force feedback.
So why don't we go through it point-by-point?
"
...interaction with a user interface to generate visual feedback on a video device."
Well, yeah, Heavy Rain is for PS3, which connects to a TV. You use the controller to make your character walk around, explore areas, and interact with the enviroment. You press a button and stuff happens on your television.
When you watch a movie you have no control over what any character does, and can only examine what the characters examine. You are a
passive observer, whereas in Heavy Rain you are extremely
active.
Video Game - 1. Movie - 0.
"
The electronic systems used to play video games are known as platforms; examples of these are personal computers and video game consoles."
Heavy Rain is available on disc for the Playstation 3. The Playstation 3 is a video game console. It will not work anywhere but on your PS3. Heavy Rain is for the PS3 platform. Any questions?
Video Game - 2. Movie - 0.
"
The input device used to manipulate video games is called a game controller, and varies across platforms."
Again, PS3. PS3 controller. You interact with Heavy Rain by pushing buttons to make things happen on the screen. It's a game.
Video Game - 3. Movie - 0.
"
Video games typically also use other ways of providing interaction and information to the player. ... Audio ... vibration or force feedback, with vibration sometimes used to simulate force feedback."
Heavy Rain used both music and vibration to enhance gameplay, with a brilliantly moody soundtrack performed by the London Philharmonic Orchestra, and full compatibility with the DualShock 3. Vibrations occurred at tense moments, such as when you are trying to crawl through a live field of electrical wires, or forced to cut off a section of your finger, or during any of the many, many heart-stopping scenarios the game throws at you.
Video Game - 4. Movie - 0.
Heavy Rain fulfills all the requirements to be considered a video game and it does it with aplomb. Anyone considering it an interactive movie probably hasn't experienced it the way it was intended.
To wrap things up, I'm just going to ask a simple question: Why do people play wrestling games when they could just watch wrestling on TV?
Think about it.