I went with Judgement Day just because of the what the fuck moments for booking on here. Here is the card and the how they were won with times.
Ric Flair defeated Carlito (15:35)
Flair forced Carlito to submit with the Figure-Four Leglock.
This would have been better if they worked the match tobe at mania than Carlito would have given a crap. Flair winning doesn't sound right unless it is with dirty tricks these days as it is a shot to Carlitos credibility which is not a good thing if you want to hve a potentil main Eventer out of Carlito.
Bobby Lashley defeated ECW World Champion Vince McMahon, Shane McMahon and Umaga in a Handicap match (1:14)
Lashley pinned Shane after a Dominator powerslam.
The match had been for the ECW World Championship, but after the match Vince declared that the title wouldn't change hands since he had not been pinned.
Way to play up the handicap factor by having Lashley win in under two minutes. Especially on Shane, The man who gives his all in the ring and would probably kill himself doing a huge bump gets pinned in under 2 minutes WTF, WTF..
CM Punk defeated Elijah Burke (16:51)
Punk pinned Burke after a GTS (Go To Sleep).
Ok fine for a match to continue the feud. it had a good length to it didn't result in anything major happening other than to help along the feud that these two were having.
Randy Orton defeated Shawn Michaels (4:31)
Orton won when the referee stopped the match after Michaels collapsed.
A sub-5 minute match on PPV not good. I can undersand it with HBKs knee going out on him in the match but even so it is disappointing. from here is the start of the WTF booking.
The Hardys (Matt and Jeff) defeated Lance Cade and Trevor Murdoch to retain the World Tag Team Championship (15:03)
Jeff pinned Cade after a Twist of Fate from Matt and a Swanton Bomb from Jeff.
So we have a Tag match, decent length for the match since they were going to change over at some stage I would have given the titles to Cade and Murdoch here. But going into ONS I can understand them keeping the Hardys so they could have a Ladder match.
Edge defeated Batista to retain the World Heavyweight Championship (10:38)
Edge pinned Batista with a school boy.
a Good booking decision for the win and the time on the match. But its postioning on the Card is stupid, it is supposed to be for the top title on Smackdown so why is it before the Second tier Title match?
Montel Vontavious Porter defeated Chris Benoit in a 2 out of 3 Falls match to win the WWE United States Championship
MVP pinned Benoit after a Playmaker (8:13).
MVP pinned Benoit with an Inside Cradle (14:10)
A major Booking F-Up Two falls to the same person in a Two out of three falls is the name of the game but not two in a row. While MVP had improved I doubt he had improved enough to be able to beat Chris Benoit in two falls without the third fall being in effect. This match should have been extended even further to cover for the HBK/Orton match being shortened.
John Cena defeated The Great Khali to retain the WWE Championship (8:16)
Cena forced Khali to submit with the STFU, Khali's foot was under the rope but the referee didn't see it.
The Biggest What the Fuck moment on this card. Khali tapping out to the WTF-U. Why would someone that is 7 foot 3 going to tap out to a sleeper? A stupid booking move. Khali is supposed to be a giant they could have gone longer than sub 10 minutes they went on, this and have Khali DQ himself, it is more believable than having Cena come out and win with the WTF-U.