Am I the only one that would truly love to see this match? It is a brilliant match up just on Paper it looks like a good fun match. The Nugget wins this one, poll wise easily, virtual reality wise it would be a nice 15 minute match but it would be a fun match to see in any circumstances.
If you could get both of these guys in their primes, then yes, this would be an awesome match-up (in other words, I totally agree).
I'm a little bit torn here. We are supposed to look at these guys in their primes, and, in his prime, Super Crazy would have been a formidable opponent. On the other hand, I'm not so sure about Owen. As IrishCanadian25 already mentioned, Owen had a great year in 1994, but his prime, in my opinion, was between 1996 and 1999, when he was playing second fiddle to his brother in The Hart Foundation, being the "white sheep" in The Nation of Domination, and doing slapstick routines with Jeff Jarrett.
If anything, this would be an extremely close match. And, as far as this not being in ECW but in WWE, I don't think the argument really works here. Super Crazy was a high-risk high flier, not La Parka; unlike some of his lucha libre brethren, he didn't rely on foreign objects to win matches.
So, even though Owen has the home town advantage, I'm going with my heart and saying Super Crazy. If this was a match between The Blue Blazer circa 1989 and Super Crazy, I might be inclined to change my mind. But, I assume that Owen is going unmasked in this one.