Brining back the Cruiserweight Title is a terrible idea. Terrible. It is an idea motivated, I am willing to assume, by an enthusiasm not for the WWE's Cruiser / Lightheavyweight title history, but for the work WCW did to get smaller wrestlers on the map. Am I to assume that the thread starter recently watched a PPV match involving some conbination of the names: Malenko, Misterio, Psicosis, Guerrero, Jericho, and Guerrera recently?
So what if the idea was encouraged by someone watching old cruiserweight matches on W.C.W.? That doesn't mean the W.W.E. doesn't, or couldn't, randomly fill the same type of division with equally great Superstars.
Raw: Rey Mysterio, Jamie Noble, JTG, Cody Rhodes, Dolph Ziggler and possibly C.M. Punk & Kofi Kingston.
Smackdown: Carlito, Primo, Zack Ryder, Curt Hawkins, Chavo Guerrero, D.H. Smith, Hurricane Helms, Jimmy Yang, Jesse, Kung-Fu Naki, THE Brian Kendrick, and possibly Scotty Goldman & Ryan Braddock.
E.C.W.: The Miz, D.J. Gabriel, Evan Bourne & Ricky Ortiz.
All of those names could easily fit into a cruiserweight division, that would suddenly be very watchable. And well over half of those individuals aren't currently involved in anything meaningful.
So would you rather they be in a division, for a cruiserweight title they deserve.. or the Intercontinental/United States division, in which the same half that aren't involved in anything, definately DON'T need to be considered challengers for those titles?
No, there are so many more approproate opportunites. And a few people have already mentioned - why bring a title back when others are being neglected as it is?
I agree that the other Championships are being neglected, but that doesn't suddenly mean by bringing back a Championship that better fits a decent amount of Superstars is a bad idea.
Before any titles are ressurected, the Tag Team Titles need to be unified on Raw, and the Women's titles need to be unified on Smackdown. Or vice versa, I don't care. All the tag teams should be on a brand, and all the wrestling women should be on one brand.
Once again, I agree with this, but unfortunately this action has ZERO to do with the actual Cruiserweight title, or it's possible division.
The company's Tag division is failing because they haven't tried to
make any new or decent Tag Teams. And the ones they have, aren't getting over enough for anyone to care. Meanwhile, the Women's and Diva's divisions are always going to be lackluster because the majority of people who watch W.W.E. are watching the female's, mainly for T&A.
Then - and ONLY then - do you consider bringing a title back, and it's not the Cruiserweight title. It's the Hardcore Title. Not this 24/7 bullshit either. The Hardcore Title would be the secondary belt on ECW, which (God forbid) would allow the show to maintain some small semblance of the roots to its name.
This is actually an even worse idea. Especially for the Hardcore title to be on E.C.W. Why? Because this is just
asking for more people to bitch and moan that the new E.C.W. isn't like the old one.
And the Hardcore Championship was almost always a complete joke. For sakes, Irish, the fucking title was made out of the trashed out Winged Eagle Heavyweight Championship. They cared so less about this entire division, that they didn't even bother trying to give it it's own Championship, but instead dug something, almost literally, out of the trash.
And your grand idea of something better, is to up-hold shit, over a once great division that literally carried a company. Nice. Why not bring back the Brawl for All concept, too.
But the Cruiserweight Title? Pssshhhh. WWE is trying to DRAW MONEY...and with few notable exceptions, the Cruisers don't do that.
While I agree that the cruiserweights don't draw as much money as the Heavyweights, the fact remains they're
STILL on the roster. So wouldn't you think it'd be better to find something possibly useful for them.. instead of randomly tossing them into Heavyweight Main Events? I'd certainly hope so.