Well...this is somewhat of a no-brainer, but I would say Sting.
When the Warrior was in Texas (called the Dingo Warrior), he was phenominal.....I don't know if he ever won the Heavyweight Title (after all, he wasn't a Von Erich), and moved to the WWE, ---his repitoire consisted of sticking out his arms, blowing his cheeks like a cheap hooker, and then that's it. The one thing that sticks in my crawl ---and yes, the Warrior DVD was all mostly bashing by WWE people, but I think this is a legit bitch----but the time that Lawler was to take a picture, or gold record, or whatever, and hit him over the head with it.....the Warrior wore a baseball cap! It's explained a little more detailed as to why he wore it (when he's never been seen with it at any other time), but something to do with the fact that he didn't wanna take the bump, or sell it, or whatever. My whole point of that little trip down memory lane is that at the very LEAST--Sting isn't afraid of a beatdown, to job, to take his lumps for the sake of the storyline and the company (which is the most important). RVSisTNA even states that "he even beat Hulk Hogan"

and I would say that beating Hulk is no big deal. GETTING Hulk to job for you is.....and so on a scale of 1-10, Warrior scores a .5 for that accomplishment. No offense RVDisTNA.
Sting.....well....not now, but back then, was very believable in his stories, acting ability, etc....and c'mon...when he went up against Flair on the first Clash of Champions for 45 minutes...you really think Warrior could last that long? Not to mention, do more than three moves? Hardly. Sting will be--at least for awhile---the Pete Rose of wrestling. Worthy of the honor----but not in it because of Vinnie Mac.