Which show would benefit more from

[ronbot09]

This trade (before I put it up this is my disclaimer type thing if this thread has already been posted I was not aware so don't get pissy with me lol) It's seems the flow of things for a while when it comes to the draft is all these superstars move back and forth but two always seem to stay put and those two are Taker and HBK so if they were to switch shows just out of the blue or lets say they switched last draft which show would benefit more in terms of fueds and things like that Raw or Smackdown these are the only two that move everyone else stays put..Thoughts? I think more people would watch SD! but Raw would benefit I know I'd like to see HHH and Taker fued again or Taker and Orton one more time that'd be just what the doctor ordered IMO for both shows

 

[The Pope CTC MEM]

i think raw would benifit more from taker moving there so he can put over some midcarders like Swagger, the Miz, Masters and Carlito. Smackdown are already doing this by pushing morrison and ziggler

 

[SSJPhenom]

IMO, I think that both shows would benifit greatly from this trade. You would get fresh feuds out of both and you would have the opprotunity for both Veterans to put over the fresh young talent on both shows. You really couldn't go wrong with this trade, sad fact is, however, both have said that they want to remain where they are at, so I don't think that we will ever see this, but one can hope.

 

[tLight]

There was just a trade two months ago, and a trade 3 months before that.

There is no need what so ever for there to be another trade until the Draft after WM26 Next year.

Raw has way more star power currently than Smackdown, so moving their biggest star in the Undertaker to Raw would not do the brand any good. Yes it would shake things up, and HBK would work out well on Smackdown because their are a lot of smaller wrestlers, it wont fucking happen, because of Smackdowns schedule and HBK's family and church life.

 

[BananaHeel]

Everytime I watch or go to WWE.com they switch around their talent. It's starting to make the Draft Lottery look obsolete. Years ago, I wanted HBK and Taker to swap brands, just to see how it would look. But now I don't want that to happen EVER. They really are the only ones who have never been traded, and it should remain that way. They are a special icon to their respective shows because of this. Cena, Jericho, and Edge play the proverbial tennis game and it still looks decent, but I grow tired of flippin through wrestling channels just to hear about how a certain superstar is now with RAW or now with SMACKDOWN, then a month later it changes

 

[dvayne]

Everyone would benefit greatly. Smackdown doesn't have the star power that Raw does and HBK would put on good feuds with Ziggler, Morrison, Punk and possibly rekindle the Hart feud with Dynasty and put on great matches with Kane, Mysterio and Jericho

Undertaker could give a rub to Swagger, The Miz, Masters and rekindle feuds with Orton, HHH, Batista, and Cena

The only problem is with HBK's church obligations and Undertaker being the face of Smackdown they just move everyone else around to feud with them. (Kennedy went to Raw to feud with HBK and Big Show went to Smackdown to feud with Undertaker last year)

With both of them set to retire in the next year or two they will keep them on their flagship shows and continue to feed future stars to them to try and get them over

 

[HBK-aholic]

If I see just one more post saying HBK must go to Smackdown I might just snap and ban you all. Seriously, it's older than Ric Flair. Shawn has personal commitments which means he cannot work on the day Smackdown is taped. McMahon is fine with this, why can't everyone else get the fuck over it? He's having some great matches and promos on Raw, and s currently helping to put over Legacy - yet there are still "He's not doing anything, there's nothing more for him to do" complaints.

The Undertaker on Smackdown is also fine. There are plenty of huge established stars on Raw - and not as many on Smackdown. While him moving to Raw is more feasible than a Shawn Michaels move, it's not necessary and, unless it's part of a huge Shake up in the Raw ME talent, not going to happen.

 

[SaveUs_Y2J]

Say the shows were the exact same apart from Undertaker and HBK traded.
Undertaker pros:
He could help make other superstars look great like hes did so many times he could help people like the Miz get took a little more serious give Kofi and MVP there push, also Swagger.
He could push Cena out of the picture.
HHH vs Undertaker would be great also another Randy Orton vs Undertaker would be worth while
Cons:
No DX
No BOD return
CM Punk would be stuck with Batista
HBK PROS:
His fued with batitsta was quite good so it ould be okay
CM Punk vs HBK or Matt Hardy vs HBK
JEricho vs HBK
Cons:
He doesnt want a title shot late in his career so it would be a pointless move for him he need DX,WWE needs DX right now because if theyre not there we will have HHHvsCENAvsORTON all over again
Also if he doesnt want a title shot he will be left hanging basically