Well my "entrance" into the world of pro wrestling was spawned by something somewhat unusual I guess, as I haven't heard of anyone else getting into pro wrestling the same way I did. I was drawn in through the action figures.
Let's go back to 1990. I was 5-6 years old at the time. Hasbro had just become the new toy company to make WWF toys (I didn't know that at the time, I'm just relating that to everyone here). LJN had done the WWF toys throughout the 1980's; which were the big 8-9 inch rubbery figures (very good collectables nowadays). The Hasbro figures were about 4-5 inch plastic figures.
So anyways, I was sitting at home one day watching TV. At the time, the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles were the big thing for me. I watched the cartoon religiously. Collected all of the toys. Then one day a commercial came on the TV advertising these new WWF action figures. I didn't know what wrestling was at the time. I just remember seeing Jesse Ventura and Randy Savage yelling at the screen showing off these action figures being played with in a toy ring and convincing the viewer to go out and get them. The toys were so flashy and cool looking. Jesse and Randy were so loud and over the top. I was amazed and drawn in instantly. Then I saw Brutus Beefcake yelling at the screen cutting the screen with his scissors. After the commerical, I was like, "I have to get those!" Soon afterwards, I was at a department store called Phar-Mor (I don't think they're in business anymore, at least they haven't been in Indiana for years). I bought a figure of the Million Dollar Man, which was my first every wrestling figure. And though it was cool to have him, I needed someone for him to fight with. Luckily my birthday wasn't far off, and my parents got me a Hulk Hogan and Ultimate Warrior figure. Now I was set. I used my dad's comic book boxes to have my three figures fight on. And that's how it all started.
Right after that I started renting Survivor Series 90 at my video store all the time. I loved the Survivor Series format so I kept wanting to watch it. That was the first wrestling I remember watching. Then after some friends of the family told us about Wrestlemania VII and how awesome it was, I asked my parents if we could start watching wrestling on TV (because I didn't yet know how to get it on TV or what channels it was on), and we found Superstars and Wrestling Challenge, and then we were off and running. So after Wrestlemania VII, I became a total fan. We bought the toys. We watched in on TV every week. I kept going to the video store and renting all of the old ppvs. I went to my first house show/live event in June of 1991 (the main event was the Undertaker and the Ultimate Warrior in a bodybag match). The first ppv to happen after I was a fan was Summerslam 91. Unfortunately we didn't have ppv (I wouldn't get ppv ironically until 1996; 5 years after I became a fan of wrestling), but my mom's friend did, and she ordered it for us and taped it so we could watch it. Again I didn't have ppv for another 5 years (ppv wasn't near as common and easy to come by in the early 1990's as it is today), so for the ppv events throughout the next 5 years, we either found someone to order them for us, or we would just wait until they came out on video. But I watched Superstars, Wrestling Challenge, Prime Time Wrestling, All American Wrestling, and Saturday's Night Main Event (although only 3 more episodes were made after I became a fan (one in April of 1991, February of 1992 (when Sid turned on Hogan), and October of 1992 (when Shawn Michaels won the I-C title for the 1st time))) every week. About a year after I became a fan, I attended my 2nd live show, 1st ppv event, and to this day my first and only Wrestlemania event, Wrestlemania VIII which was at the Hoosier Dome (which was tore down a few years ago to make way for Lucas Oil Stadium) in April of 1992.
So that's pretty much the run down of my first year or so as a wrestling fan.
So while the action figures are ultimately what drew me into wrestling, what exactly was it that kept me watching and made me become a hardcore fan? (which I remained as such until about 4-5 years ago, whereas now I'd say I'm a moderate fan, but still a big fan of "old school" wrestling). If I had to pin it down to one thing, I would say it was "the characters."
Every wrestler was larger than life and interesting to watch in that era. Even the wrestlers that weren't the big names or didn't have amazing mic skills. Most of those guys (take a guy like the Warlord for example) still had something interesting about them. Either their size or physique, or a manager to talk for them, or just a really distinctive costume or something. Every wrestler was distinctive and unique and could draw you in to watch. Forget the Simpsons or Full House or Family Matters or Law and Order or Seinfeld, or whatever shows were on in the early 90s. The most interesting characters on TV for me were Hulk Hogan, the Ultimate Warrior, Randy Savage, Jake the Snake Roberts, Ric Flair, the Undertaker, Rowdy Roddy Piper, Mr. Perfect, Bret Hart, Bobby Heenan, Jimmy Hart, Miss Elizabeth, Mean Gene Okerlund, etc.
Professional wrestling to me was just a larger than life, outlandish movie. Just as I was drawn into cheering for Batman to take out the Joker in the original Batman movie, I was drawn into wanting to see Randy Savage get his hands on Jake Roberts for what he had done to him and Miss Elizabeth. Just as I was scared to death of, yet fascinated by Freddy Kruger or the spiders in Arachnaphobia, I was scared to death of, yet in awe, of the Undertaker. Just as I would laugh at the antics of Wayne and Garth in Wayne's World, I would laugh at the pure ridiculousness of someone like the Repo Man (as I talked about in the guilty pleasure thread). Or I could just watch Bret Hart wrestle, and be inspired by his athleticism, and by his no-nonsense, work hard mentality. Wrestling had everything that could make you want to watch a movie or a TV show, or see in a play at a theater (although I didn't go see plays much as a kid).
It was larger than life and fascinating for a kid. I've never enjoyed reading more than watching something on TV. When I hear about a good book being made into a movie, I don't go out and get the book. I just wait for the movie to come out. I'm one of those people that would much rather SEE a story play out before my eyes, than for me to read a story play out. I guess I'm just not that imaginative. So while I collected the cards and the toys and would watch the cartoons on FOX of the Marvel and DC superheroes and villains, I never really read the comic books much (despite having plenty of access to them as my dad is a life-long hardcore comic book collector). In 1991 there was no visual outlet (being TV or films) really for larger than life superhero and supervillian like characters, with the exception of the Batman and Superman films (the X-Men and Spider Man cartoons on FOX didn't come out til around 1993 or 1994). But there was wrestling. I didn't like to read much. So I didn't have to sit through an X-Men or Spider Man comic and be bored. I could just watch Hulk Hogan on TV come back, draw in the energy of the "Hulkamaniacs" and beat his latest arch-nemesis and then pose in victory for the crowd at the end in a big celebration. I could just watch the Ultimate Warrior run down the ring like a maniac, shake the ropes, talk like a superhero on television and just act like a raging lunatic, which is something every 6 year old boy deep down wants to do. We're all little lunatics at that age, right?
Wrestling was just my visual outlet to larger than life characters that every young male seeks out and "needs." All young males in that era (late 1980's/early 1990's) had GI Joe or the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles or He-Man or Transformers or Marvel or DC Comics for the fictional heroic characters to look up to and admire. GI Joe, Transformers, and He-Man for some reason I didn't really click with much. I had no visual outet really for the Marvel and DC comic characters (except the Batman movies) (and because again, unlike most people, I didn't like to read so I wouldn't read the comics), so I didn't follow them much. I got into the Turtles, but wrestling was what really worked for me. Those wrestlers were the fictional superhero like characters that I followed and looked up to.
Of course as I got older and watched it longer, I understood it more, learned it was really a performance art and not a comic book come to life, etc. But in those early years, it was the characters, the larger than life heroes to cheer and villians to boo and hate that glued me in and made me watch and become a fan.