Something interesting started to happen as I read this forum. When I opened the thread, my gut reaction was to say The Hart Foundation hands-down. It seemed incredibly obvious to me, so much so I almost found it pointless to even browse the arguments before weighing in. Then, as I allowed myself to go through other people's posts, my mind started to shift ever-so-slightly.
Let's get Bret Hart out of the way first. He is unquestionably one of the greatest technical wrestlers around and he developed into one of the best SOLO grapplers of his generation or any other. Thinking of Bret as he was toward the latter part of his championship reigns in WWF truly does skew the decision-making.
However, I don't think this tournament is really based on his solo work. What I'm imagining this tournament asks us to do is take both teams at the height of their tag era successes and pair them off against one-another to determine who would win. By looking at it through those eyes, my initially decisive vote for The Hart Foundation is suddenly up for reconsideration.
In thinking about The Hardy Boyz, I can't help admit they were one of the most innovative and exciting teams of the last couple decades. They had some amazing rivalries with unbelievably talented teams such at The Dudley Boyz and Edge & Christian. To rack up their six WWF/WWE tag team championships and one WCW tag title, in addition to the already mentioned teams, the brothers beat The Acolytes, Right to Censor (Bull Buchanon & Goodfather), Booker T & Test (who they also beat for the WCW titles) and won a tag team battle royal. In doing so, they also put on the now-legendary TLC matches. Extremely impressive.
Still, during their tenure in the WWF, The Hart Foundation faced off against some heavyweights as well. Night in and night out, Hart & Neidhart faced The British Bulldogs, Demolition, The Brain Busters, The Fabulous Rougeaus and The Rockers. They did incredibly well for themselves, too, coming up with two solid reigns as WWF World Tag Team champs. Looking at the teams to which The Harts lost their tag titles, we come up with Strike Force (Tito Santana/Rick Martel, to whom Neidhardt actually submitted via Boston crab) and The Nasty Boys.
Seems we're in a dry heat here between these two teams, really. Both are undeniably great, landmark teams for the WWF. Both have etched their places in the annals of WWF history. And while I first thought the Hart Foundation would take this one easily, now I'm actually teetering in the opposite direction, thinking The Hardys might well pull this one out.
What I'm ultimately going to allow to determine the outcome is the teams' title histories. The Hardys have a combined seven World Tag Team title reigns compared to the Hart Foundation's two. But, really, it's not that simple. During the Hart Foundation's two title reigns, they held the belts for an approximately combined 14 months. The Hardys held the titles nowhere near that long, even in nearly 4x as many reigns.
Had this been a TLC match, I'd have given it to the Hardys, but it's not indicated as such. So, using my little back-and-forth calculation, I'm giving it to The Hart Foundation after all. I still think it's too close to call this an incredibly decisive win, though.
The winners, as the result of a count-out, Bret "The Hitman" Hart and Jim "The Anvil" Neidhart, The Hart Foundation!