The "Old or New" Game.

[Johnny Scumm]

I was doing this with my friends last week, just in discussion, so I've turned it into a game thing for here. I'll give you an option between the old and new of ______, then you pick your favourite, then give us a new one to pick between.

Example:
Old Metallica or New Metallica?

So here's my first one;

Old Batman Movies or New Nolan-ised Batman Movies?

 

[JWGunslinger]

Old Batman FTW.

Old Jennifer Aniston or New Jennifer Aniston?

 

[Paralyzer Z]

Nolan's by far. And you can thank Batman and Robin (1997) for that.

 

[Alex]

Nolan's by far. And you can thank Batman and Robin (1997) for that.

Batman is better than The Dark Knight

 

[Chardee Macdennis]

New Jennifer Anniston.

Old NFL (run game, defense oriented) or New NFL (Emphasis on QB's and WR's, less Defense)?

 

[Johnny Scumm]

New Jennifer Anniston.

Old NFL (run game, defense oriented) or New NFL (Emphasis on QB's and WR's, less Defense)?

New NFL (For the sole reason I'd never seen old)

New Maroon 5 (Moves Like Jagger) or Old Maroon 5 (This Love/She Will Be Loved)

 

[The Champ]

Old by a fucking million miles. Moves Like Jagger sucks.

 

[Johnny Scumm]

Old by a fucking million miles. Moves Like Jagger sucks.

You need to give us one to answer.

 

[The Champ]

Um, new Kanye (808s and onward) or old Kanye (first three albums).

 

[The Dewbliners]

Um, new Kanye (808s and onward) or old Kanye (first three albums).

Forced to choose, I'd go with old. But, neither one is my double of bourbon.

Old Pearl Jam (Pre-Riot Act) or New Pearl Jam (RA and after)?

 

[Alex]

Old Pearl Jam only because I've only heard the first two albums.

Old Red Hot Chili Peppers (pre Blood Sugar Sex Magik) New Red Hot Chili Peppers (post BSSM)

 

[The 1-2-3 Killam]

I'm going to say old, but the new album is pretty damn solid too....

Old America (killing all the indians, driving out Mexicans, enslaving all the ******s, Western expansion, crazy-ass wigs and wooden teeth) or New America (gambling indians, too many Mexicans, annoying ******s, middle-eastern expansion, crazy-ass hair and big tits)?

 

[Mr. Artistic guy]

Old. I LOVE Red Dead Redemption.

Old hair, which is any of the last 5 or so decades v. New and current conservative hairdo's.

 

[Alex]

Old hair by a mile

This

Pwns this

(Even though I love 30STM)

Old clothing style (70s-90s pick a decade) compared to new (2000s-present

 

[LilacFray]

I love mullets!

70's vintage clothing.

Old Nicki Minaj or New Nicki Minaj?

 

[The 1-2-3 Killam]

If by "old" Nicki Minaj you mean when she wasn't a "musician" and I had never heard of her, than yes. That. Every bit of THAT.

"old" 90's comedy shows (Friends, Home Improvement, Sienfeld, Dharma & Greg, etc.) or new comedy shows (The Office, Big Bang Theory, Community, etc.)

 

[Johnny Scumm]

Old one's for sure. Friends/Home Improvement/Seinfeld are some of my favourite. Chuck Frasier in there as well.

Old WWE PPVs or New WWE PPVs?

 

[The Champ]

New. With the notable exception of the terrible Royal Rumble, almost all recent PPVs have been quality. Certainly with more good wrestling on them than those of the Attitude Era.

Old Stephanie (say, 1999-April 2002) or New Stephanie (SmackDown GM, blonde, Raw GM)?

 

[Goliath Uterus]

old stephanie. that rack was ferocious, and she didn't look like her husband.

old milk or new?

 

[Alex]

New.

Old Girl With The Dragon Tattoo (Swedish) or New (American)

 

[Johnny Scumm]

New GWTDT (Not seen the original)

Old Muse (Origins Of Symmetry etc) or New Muse (Black Holes & Revelations/The Resistance)?

 

[nightmare]

Old Muse by a mile. Newer stuff kinda sounds like space disco at a jr high school dance.



Old TMNT (comics\original series\movies) vs New TMNT (movies\animated series)

 

[Alex]

Overall Old (thats probably my nostalgia talking)

Old Clash Of The Titans or New Clash Of The Titans

 

[The Dewbliners]

Overall Old (thats probably my nostalgia talking)

Old Clash Of The Titans or New Clash Of The Titans

Old. Those shitty effects were amazingly shitty and awesome at the same time.

Old MLP (Gen 3 or before) or new (FiM)?

 

[Johnny Scumm]

Old MLP. (Yeah, bringing this back)

Old TNA (6-Sides) or New Impact Wrestling?