ok ok first of all ECW was a developmental brand for the wwe and wcw way before it was braught back as a seperate entity, and those of you who said it wasnt think back to when the wwe and wcw where stealing all of the ecw's guys and what happened most of them couldnt cut it because all there flaws where hidden, and sometimes they took guys who couldnt get over in the wwe or wcw and made them into stars, so dont hate them for doing the same thing now!.
Whoa whoa whoa . Ecw wasn't a development territory ever until this reincarnation;it was (more or less) a major independent fed. The talent that jumped to wcw were stolen, as heyman would say,being that wcw never compensated ecw in any way shape or form.As for the talent that made the jump to wwf mcmahon put Heyman on the payroll as compensation for taking his better talent.It's arguable about whether or not ecw became a dev territory.The duddleys said in a shoot interview that ecw was a dev territory but heyman never says that and it wasnt public knowledge (if it was) that it was a dev territory like how its iwc common knowledge OVW, FCW and the former DSW were/are wwe dev territories.Also think about would two rival companies have the same Dev Territory?
the only thing thats changed is that we need to give the newer guys whove come up on the brand a chance, and as for john morrison he has alot of heart and ability and is strong on the mic, so if anyone thinks that he didnt deserve the title was wrong, the only reason he got held back on raw was because there was nothing left for him to do after recieving the mid card belt, and all the malena back stage crap didnt do him any favours.
IMO (and many other's) the new ecw title is just as meaningless as the IC title. Morrison is a future star no question as is CM Punk
but with the title they ve held/hold meaning as much as the IC title neither will gain 'instant' main event credibility when/if they get moved to a different show.Look at Lashley. Lashley wasnt a credible contender when he was feuding with Cena for the wwe title.He made too big of a transition in terms of card level.The crowd was only behind him because they wanted to see cena lose and nothing more.
ECW in my opinion is getting better, the whole hardcore all the time thing cant get over on national tv, simple as, you cant think that by doing hardcore all the time is going to hel pthe brand get over it isnt,
Ecw ,back in the day before everyone left,had the best pure wrestling (Guererro,Malenko,Benoit,Jericho)good lucha libre (psycosis ,rey mysterio)in addition to the hardcore wrestling. Ecw now is like raw-lite.WWE style wrestling nothing different.the same shit you would see on raw.Old ecw was an alternative to wcw and wwe it had different styles unlike the ecw of today.[/QUOTE]
i think the wwe needs to think more about seperating it from raw, smackdown and keeping it as its own entity, like when they first put the brand together,
If by brand you mean old ecw then yes i agree with ya.It needs to be made different from being raw-lite.Maybe more 'pure' wrestling or luchal libre.
the reason it tanked after december to dismember was because heyman didnt think about the card,
that line right there pisses me off soooo bad. Do you even know what you're talking about? Most of Heyman's ideas got vetoed by mcmahon and his ecw writing staff so if you wanna blame anyone that disaster it was mcmahon.Heyman was crying at the end of that ppv because he knew what a shitfest it was,and what his beloved ecw was turning into via mcmahon.Heyman had an argument with Vince about all of that and was sent home by mcmahon i believe the tuesday after that ppv.
you cant do a brand only ppv if you dont have the right amount of talent, and you hide most of the card from the public as well so when it comes time for people to watch and think its a three hour long episode of ecw on sci fi with crappy matches and adverts for smaackdown on the show, you going to feel ripped off,
Tell that to vince.He used his ideas and his ecw writing staff's not heyman's. I will agree about the amount of any sort of established talent not being enough but i ve got one question: Since when did development territories do ppvs?
so i dont believe hiring heyman back is the answer let the brand progress and bring in more talent more titles and keep it as its own entity,
Heyman probably wouldnt want to come back. ever...even giving him like a 49% interest in the company (as a whole and i mean WWE) probably wouldnt lure him back.He probably hates vince with every ounce of his being.You say keep ecw as its own entity and i say make it it's own entity as like i said i really consider ecw raw-lite.
at the moment its one of my top three shows out of all three brands
That doesnt make any sense to me. Out of the 3 brands that have 1 show each (correct me if i'm wrong i havent seen a 'b' show for any brand in a few years.I dont think they have them and if they do they are probably syndicated and stations around me dont carry them) 3 x 1= 3 shows how is it not gonna be in your top 3 wwe related shows?