Seriously? You're going to trash this game because it has a cartoon like atmosphere? Well, golly, let's call Japan and tell them that one of their primary art styles is actually a terrible idea.
I will not claim that Virtua Fighter 4 is a bad game. In fact, at its time in 2002, it probably represented one of the best fighting games in years. It's AI and its controls were huge improvements - it was a damn good fighting game.
But Disgaea: Hour of Darkness, is a seminal classic that goes so often unappreciated. It is one of the best strategy games ever put out, ever. Period. IGN recognizes it as one of the best unappreciated titles around, and as Best Strategy Game of the year. GameSpy recognized it as a top 10 PS2 game and also Strategy Game of the Year. It's one of the most creative and innovate titles to hit strategy in a long time, and its presence is still felt today in the line of Disgaea hits that continue to rock the strategy genre. It's got a great, though admittedly Japanese-appealing, story to it. It's a fantastic game.
Do the right thing and vote Disgaea.