Live Impact - Picked the wrong week.

Gelgarin

Gentleman of the Old School
As I am given to understand, this Thursdays Impact is your typical pre taped affair. In contrast, the Bound for Glory go home show was presented live.

In my mind this is the incorrect way of doing things. It's been well established my now that TNA places greater importance on its TV ratings than it's PPV buys (different business model to WWE), but immaterial of what you're going after it makes seance to place the emphasis on the aftermath show over the go home one.

The go home show exists for only one reason, and that is to sell the PPV. With that in mind one might think it makes sense to place your emphasis there, but I would suggest that the go home show only sells the PPV to people who are already considering buying it, and those people are generated in the previous three weeks.

In addition, because of it's proximity to the PPV, the go home show is liable to have the least in the way of storyline development. The feuds have already been set out and it's just a case of reaffirming them. As such it matters much less if the go home show falls victim to internet spoilers.

Now in contrast lets look at the PPV aftermath show. The show directly following the PPV is far and away the one with the most selling it, usually with massive fallout from the Pay Per View. This means that if TNA want to generate a ratings spike (as live episodes have a tendency to do) then this is the week to do it.

In addition, the aftermath show (particularly in the case of this Thursday's) is the one that you absolutely do not want internet spoilers leaking out for. Right now the internet seems pretty divided on the subject of who "They" turned out to be, but in an absence of spoilers I suspect that almost everyone would turn in just the see the situation explained. Instead I imagine that a lot of the nay sayers will just read the general just of the promos in advance and make their minds up that is sucks.

People are going to queue up to say how TNA needs to just go live full time, to which I'll answer in advance that they almost certainly would if they could. TNA are clearly aware of the advantages to running live TV, and the fact that they're only doing it occasionally suggests that it's just too expensive to do on a regular basis.

That being said, my conclusion is that if TNA were going to run a live Impact to support Bound for Glory, they picked the wrong week.

Discuss. Or don't. Makes little difference really. I just didn't want to have to start doing the washing up.
 
Yeah and No, on the one hand the Live go home show drew more viewers than usual and possibly led to some extra buys, outside of the live effect, what reason was there to tune in to the go home show? None. So in that sense it was right, with the BFG fall out show live would be "better" so to speak but not nearly as damaging as I think you're seeing it, even accounting for spoilers a lot of people will want to "see" the fall out so the negative of loosing viewers to spoilers shouldn't be that large, in comparison if spoilers from the Live iMPACT last week had been posted I guarantee that 1.32 wouldn't have been that high.

50/50 imo.
 
I was just thinking about this a few hours ago. I think by the time the Impact before the PPV comes on most people have decided if they are going to buy it or not. But everyone wanting answers will read the spoilers and decide if they even want to watch this Thursday's show. I think it would be a good idea to run the go home show live, then the PPV then the show after live. Then tape the other shows they would need that Friday and Saturday. Then if need be on weird months Sunday or Monday depending on how many Thursdays are between the live go home show and that week.
Or maybe just wait and tape them Monday if they don't get a good turn out on the weekend. But yeah I would have rather had this upcoming show live and not the go home show.
 
I agree that Before The Glory should have been taped. You can still have the awesomeness of Flair/Foley intact even if it was taped. But like other people have said the point of the Go Home show is to reaffirm feuds and storylines going into the PPV. It usually never has that much shock value. In most cases, if one guy has been repeatedly getting the upper hand in the feud, the go home show is the place where the other guy proves that he doesn't completely have any chance of winning. But other than that there is not supposed to be a lot of value in the go home show.

Then again it was called Before the Glory and in my opinion, TNA hyped up this about as much as the actual PPV. I remember seeing the ad for it and I actually thought The Shore would instead be showing up at Bound for Glory.

The live Impact should be saved for this week's after the fallout from BFG. The reaction to Hardy becoming Champion and "They" finally being revealed is going to feel much more authentic than if it was taped. We'll actually know how much people in the Impact Zone dig the very much different landscape that TNA is now in instead of having the inserted crowd ambience. Then again it is the Impact Zone where pretty much anyone will cheer for anything.
 
They should have had live shows either side of BFG. There is no doubt that the live Before the Glory was a good idea, somewhat poorly executed.

Being honest, this stinks of TNA not trusting their own event. If they had confidence that BFG would draw for Impact (and Impact should match the 1.3 this week) then they would have scheduled this show to be live.

I think if Impact does draw well, they will realise it was a bit of a lost opportunity.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
174,847
Messages
3,300,827
Members
21,726
Latest member
chrisxenforo
Back
Top