I just don't understand how christians now days feel that they can pick and choose what from the bible to follow and what not to follow. By refusing to do her job, she has effectively lied to God and broken an oath. Relevant parts of Oath of Ky clerk: "I, ....., do swear that I will well and truly discharge the duties of the office of .............. County Circuit Court clerk, ..........., and will faithfully execute the duties of my office without favor, affection or partiality, so help me God." Effective: January 2, 1978. Wouldn't violating an oath given on the value of one's faith weigh on the conscience of a person who professes a strong faith?
Although it is easy to be appalled by Ms. Davis's refusal to comply with a lawfully-rendered federal court order, I find myself equally appalled by the commenters who are gleeful that she is being jailed or are gleeful that she continues to refuse to comply or to resign her position. Like the people for whom she has refused to issue marriage licenses, Ms. Davis is a human being. While her view of how her faith requires her to do her job demonstrates that she 1) either does not understand basic American jurisprudence, or 2) believes her faith exempts her from the rules of that jurisprudence, or both, neither her behavior nor her jailing is anything to rejoice about. This stand-off will eventually be resolved in one way or another. Shouldn't people of good will hope to see it resolved in a way that does the least damage to the human beings caught up in the controversy? While Judge Bunning may believe that he had no choice but to use confinement as a lever to force compliance with the court's order, that is a very difficult position for a judge to have to take. I for one will hope that Ms. Davis's attorneys will advise her wisely, that she will be able to accept the truth that if the obligations of her faith mean that she cannot perform the duties of office she has pledged (perhaps on a Bible?) to perform, her duty is to respectfully resign her position and work politically to change the law she disagrees with.