Junkyard Dog: Worthy or Not?

Does Junkyard Dog belong IN the Hall of Fame?

  • Yes. T.H.U.M.P. baby!

  • No. He didn't do anything.


Results are only viewable after voting.

TheOneBigWill

[This Space for Rent]
Junkyard%20Dog.jpg

Sylvester Ritter (December 13, 1952 – June 2, 1998) was an American professional wrestler and professional football player, best known for his work in Mid-South Wrestling and the World Wrestling Federation as The Junkyard Dog (or JYD for short). Entering the ring with his trademark chain attached to a dog collar, to the music of Queen's "Another One Bites the Dust," JYD was considered by some to be one of the most electrifying and charismatic wrestlers in the country, particularly during his peak in the early 1980s. He was one of the most popular athletes of any kind in Louisiana and other parts of the south during the 1980s, having regularly headlined cards that sold out The Louisiana Superdome and other major venues. JYD was most known for his head butt and upper-body strength, the latter of which saw him regularly body slam such large wrestlers as the One Man Gang, Kamala, and King Kong Bundy. The word "thump," which referred to JYD's power slam, was prominently displayed on his wrestling trunks.

Ritter debuted in the Tennessee territory, working for promoter Jerry Jarrett, before moving to Nick Gulas's company and using the ring name Leroy Rochester. From there he moved to Stu Hart's Stampede Wrestling as Big Daddy Ritter, where he captured the North American Heavyweight Championship twice.

In the early 1980s Ritter moved to Mid-South Wrestling, where booker "Cowboy" Bill Watts gave him the name and gimmick Junkyard Dog, as he would wear a long chain attached to a dog collar, and white boots. He originally came to the ring pushing a cart filled with junk called the "junk wagon" and lost most of his early matches before his character caught on and became the top face in the company. While on top he feuded with some of the top heels in the company, including a now infamous angle with the Fabulous Freebirds where they blinded him with hair cream. At the peak of the feud JYD's wife gave birth to their first child, and since JYD now couldn't see his new daughter it increased the heat on the Freebirds to the point where they needed police escorts in and out of arenas. The feud ended with (the still blind) JYD and Freebird "leader" Michael "P.S." Hayes wrestling in a dog collar match.

Other notable feuds involved Ted DiBiase, Kamala, King Kong Bundy, and Hacksaw Butch Reed. The feud with DiBiase was particularly notable as DiBiase, once JYD's friend and tag-team partner, turned heel and subsequently won a loser-leave-town match against JYD with the help of the loaded glove, which was a DiBiase calling card, forcing JYD to leave town for an extended period of time. A masked man physically resembling JYD, known as Stagger Lee, subsequently appeared in the region and began to defeat the competition, one by one, including DiBiase. Though DiBiase and the other heels strongly suspected that Stagger Lee was in fact JYD, they were unable to unmask him to prove their suspicions. Stagger Lee disappeared once the loser-leave-town clause in the JYD-DiBiase match had expired, and JYD returned and reclaimed the North American Heavyweight Championship. The feud with Reed was notable in that Reed, a protégé of JYD, had turned heel. The two had a series of matches, many of which were bouts for the prized North American Heavyweight Championship. These matches were also notable for their brutality, which included "ghetto street fights," "dog-collar matches," two-out-of-three pin-fall matches and steel-cage matches. JYD was lured to the WWF at the peak of the feud with Reed.

Late in 1984, Ritter left Mid-South for the World Wrestling Federation, where he was still an over face. While in the WWF, JYD made a habit of interacting with the growing number of young people in attendance, often bringing them into the ring after matches and dancing with them. Ritter won The Wrestling Classic tournament, often cited as the first-ever WWF pay-per-view and his most notable feuds in the company came against King Harley Race, the Funk Brothers, Adrian Adonis, Greg "The Hammer" Valentine and "Outlaw" Ron Bass before he left the company late in 1988.

In 1990 he had a brief run in World Championship Wrestling while it was still under the National Wrestling Alliance banner, where he feuded with Ric Flair over the NWA World Heavyweight Championship and won the Six-Man Tag Team Championship with Ricky Morton and Tommy Rich.

Ritter died on June 2, 1998, in a single-car accident on Interstate 20 near Forest, Mississippi, as he was returning home from his daughter Latoya's high school graduation in Wadesboro, North Carolina. The apparent cause was falling asleep at the wheel. Ritter's body was laid in an unmarked grave in Wallful, North Carolina.

Ritter had stayed active in professional wrestling until the time of his death, appearing at Extreme Championship Wrestling's 1998 Wrestlepalooza event, just one month prior. He was the founder of the Dog Pound stable in independent Mid-South promotion, based in southern Louisiana. Among Ritter's last contributions to professional wrestling was the training of former WWF wrestlers Rodney Mack and Jazz.

In 2004, his daughter, LaToya Ritter, represented her father as he was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame at a ceremony held on March 13, 2004, the day before WrestleMania XX. His list of accomplishments and Championships (according to Wiki) are as follows:

Mid-South Wrestling Association
Mid-South Louisiana Championship (3 times)
Mid-South North American Heavyweight Championship (4 times)
Mid-South Tag Tean Championship (8 times) - with Buck Robley (1), Terry Orndorff (1), Killer Karl Kox (1), Dick Murdoch (3), Mike George (1), and Jerry Stubbs (1)

NWA Mid-America
NWA Mid-America Tag Team Championship (1 time) - with Gypsy Joe

Pro Wrestling Illustrated
PWI Most Inspirational Wrestler of the Year (1980)
PWI ranked him # 51 of the 500 best singles wrestlers of the "PWI Years" in 2003.

Stampede Wrestling
Stampede North American Heavyweight Championship (2 times)

United States Wrestling Association
USWA Unified World Heavyweight Championship (1 time)

World Championship Wrestling
WCW World Six-Man Tag Team Championship (1 time) - with Ricky Morton & Tommy Rich

World Wrestling Federation | World Wrestling Entertainment
WWE Hall of Fame (Class of 2004)
Wrestling Classic (1985)
Slammy Award for Best Single Performer (1986)

Wrestling Observer Newsletter awards
Feud of the Year (1982) vs. Ted DiBiase
Worst Feud of the Year (1990) vs. Ric Flair
Worst Tag Team (1986) with George Steele

NOTE: The Bunkhouse Stampede was originally held in Mid-Atlantic Championship Wrestling. However, in November 1988, Ted Turner purchased the promotion from Jim Crockett, Jr. and renamed it World Championship Wrestling. The Junkyard Dog's win came a little over one month after the promotion's purchase and renaming.

Junkyard Dog: I don't know how big J.Y.D.'s popularity is, but I'm not apart of it. I don't even fully realize why he was ever famous. Nothing about him sticks out, other than he's black, and that's not a racist comment so much as the blunt truth. I think his induction to the Hall of Fame may very well have been because he gained a slight fan popularity, and because of the color of his skin, so they figured they needed to add to the numbers of the minorities.

Junkyard Dog didn't accomplish anything within the company, other than a tournament victory that I'm willing to bet hardly ANYONE knows about. This is a similar issue to the case with George 'The Animal' Steele. If anyone disagrees with me, please feel free to step up and explain why he deserves to be IN the Hall of Fame, because I don't have any reason why he should be. What are your thoughts and opinions on Junkyard Dog being in the Hall of Fame? Worthy or Not?
 
Sure he beat Savage to win a tournament. He won it via count out if I remember correctly, when Savage was a rookie. I remember him at Wrestlemanias 3 and four in losing efforts, and that's about it. Other than that and a weird legends kind of thing in WCW, he did nothing at all. Why is this man in the HOF? He was a midcarder in the 80s. Look at some of the people in the HOF. They're in it for no more apparent reasons than that. They were names in the 80s. If this is the case, Charlies Haas will be inducted in about 15 years. JYD had a good song, that's about it though. Be gone JYD.
 
JYD didn't do anything of note to deserve his admission, be it in WWF or anywhere else. JYD was little more than charisma and an insulting moveset. Is it wrong to think that he was inducted because he was black and died, because I've never seen why he got in for any other reason
 
Before I give my answer, I think it must be noted that JYD being in the Hall of Fame raises an important question, this being on what criteria do we evaluate someone being considered for the Hall Of Fame? Do we just take into account their workrate and ability to cut promos? Do we take into account fan sentiment? Do we take into account all of the aforementioned? And, if we do account of all of the aforementioned, can a wrestler gain entry into the Hall of Fame by having exceptional marks for one criterion but poor marks for the other criteria?

Personally, I think that the way fans of wrestling feel about a certain wrestler can be an extremely important factor in deciding whether or not they should be in the Hall of Fame. And, it is for this reason that JYD deserves to be in the Hall Of Fame. Sure, he may not have been the best promo man and his wrestling skills may not have been up to par with the skills of other wrestlers, but fans deeply cared for this guy. And, what makes this care even more significant is the fact that this guy was a jobber to the heels that would, in turn, be jobbed to the likes of Hogan and Savage. Furthermore, his antics in the ring (especially his no-selling of head shots) are classic, and I have yet to see someone in a similar situation get as much love as he did (the Bushwhackers came close).
 
Nope, and nope squared. This is ignoring the "oh well if these others got in, then he deserves to be in" which is a terrible argument that I am throwing right out the window. Anyone he retorts me with this argument deserves to be slapped across the mouth. JYD did little to nothing of note, sans winning the first KOR. No titles, no feuds, not a whole lot. Sure he was a fun character, and pretty beloved, but we are looking at accolades, the best of the best. IMO, we should only induct 3 per year. JYD wouldnt be one of those three, any year.
 
I'm glad I read through his accomplishments, or lack thereof, before casting my vote. It's a resounding no.

As a kid, I loved JYD, and routinely rooted for him in any match he was in. I didn't realize he never won anything, until about 20 seconds ago. He doesn't deserve to be in. Being an over face doesn't mean anything, if you don't have the achievements to go along with it.
 
No. The guy is remembered mostly for his Thump, or whatever the hell it was. The guy was a grown man that acted like a dog, what wasn't appealing to anyone under the age of seven? That's it though, when you grow up, you realized the character was pretty lame, and the guy in the ring was marginal at best. His list of accomplishments surely aren't enough to permit this guy in the Hall.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
174,849
Messages
3,300,882
Members
21,726
Latest member
chrisxenforo
Back
Top