Undertaker vs. Shawn Michaels is an excellent choice! It was by far one of my favorite matches of all time! Some other notable matches I think would really get a newcomer interested would be:
Hardys vs. Dudleys vs. Edge & Christian; Tables, Ladders, and Chairs
Just the pure excitement and high risks in this match would make even the biggest pro wrestling doubter put their hands to their face and say "what the hell!? that had to hurt!"
John Cena vs. Brock Lesnar, Extreme Rules 2012
I actually had some friends over, who are not big wrestling fans, during this PPV. The match was so brutal that one of my friends was convinced they were really fighting. All I had to do was encourage it by saying that Cena/Lesnar have real life heat and they thought for SURE that the match morphed into an MMA fight. Especially with Cena selling his injuries so well.
The Rock vs. John Cena, Wrestlemania
Just the pure excitement and notoriety both of these men have in modern day pop culture. This match did exactly what the WWE wanted it to - it got people interested in wrestling who otherwise didn't care. Several friends of mine who used to watch back in the day, started watching again just to see what happened after the Rock beat Cena. Of course, they lost interest because of some other poor storylines, but it got them hooked.
Shawn Michaels vs. Bret Hart, Ironman Match
From their entrances until the very last ring bell, this match was a pure spectacle. The in-ring athletics of both men, the story they told with each move, and the shocking finish. Even if the match wasn't enough to capture your heart, Shawn's emotional moment afterwards was incredible. Surely it'd inspire anyone.
Hardys vs. Dudleys vs. Edge & Christian; Tables, Ladders, and Chairs
Just the pure excitement and high risks in this match would make even the biggest pro wrestling doubter put their hands to their face and say "what the hell!? that had to hurt!"
John Cena vs. Brock Lesnar, Extreme Rules 2012
I actually had some friends over, who are not big wrestling fans, during this PPV. The match was so brutal that one of my friends was convinced they were really fighting. All I had to do was encourage it by saying that Cena/Lesnar have real life heat and they thought for SURE that the match morphed into an MMA fight. Especially with Cena selling his injuries so well.
The Rock vs. John Cena, Wrestlemania
Just the pure excitement and notoriety both of these men have in modern day pop culture. This match did exactly what the WWE wanted it to - it got people interested in wrestling who otherwise didn't care. Several friends of mine who used to watch back in the day, started watching again just to see what happened after the Rock beat Cena. Of course, they lost interest because of some other poor storylines, but it got them hooked.
Shawn Michaels vs. Bret Hart, Ironman Match
From their entrances until the very last ring bell, this match was a pure spectacle. The in-ring athletics of both men, the story they told with each move, and the shocking finish. Even if the match wasn't enough to capture your heart, Shawn's emotional moment afterwards was incredible. Surely it'd inspire anyone.