Couldn't disagree with you more. Loved the openinig match between Ziggler and Cesaro. They were able to keep that match between 15-20 minutes of non stop action. Also love that they let the winner win 2-0 and not have it go to the last fall which is typical was a nice twist.
All other matches on the under card did what I felt they should have with the exception of the Rusev/Show match. I felt like the build for that match warranted something more than what we got.
Then I felt the two cage matches both hit. The RKO out of the AA spot alone made the Cena/Orton match and I really liked all aspects of the Rollins/Ambrose match including the re-debut of Bray.
I generally agree. I enjoyed last night's show
MUCH more than I was expected. They even managed to deliver a couple of surprises, some minor some not so minor. For instance, I expected Ziggler to lose last night and I certainly didn't expect him to win 2 straight falls. Now we can only hope that WWE's done jobbing him out in non-title matches. I gave that match 3.5 stars and I was surprised that it was only about 14 minutes or so. Would've been epic if they'd have gotten another 20 minutes.
The WWE Tag Team Championship match was another solid outing, though I did feel less interested because we've seen so much from these teams before. Still, I thought it was a fun match and I thought it was about 2.75 stars.
Brie vs. Nikki was a surprise, a pleasant one. I'd have to say it was the best I've ever seen them look. Brie worked her ass off in the match and while Nikki isn't as strong in the ring, she's world's away from what she once was. There were parts in the match where I felt Brie would win, namely when she kicked out Nikki's finisher. I thought it was a good 2.75 star bout. Might be a little too high in some people's opinions, but I thought they put forth a strong effort that told a decent story.
I was very happy when I saw that Cena vs. Orton wouldn't be closing the show and while I wasn't all that excited for this match, it was still a great one. For all the complaints about how tired we are of seeing Cena vs. Orton, justifiably in my opinion, you have to admit that they knock it out of the park almost every single time. Some great near falls, though I do think this match didn't make good enough use of the HIAC structure itself. Cena coming out as the winner was no big surprise, though it was probably the right one as I just don't see a lot of money in Orton vs. Lesnar. I gave the match 3.75 stars.
Sheamus vs. Miz went about how I figured it would. It was an okay match, but it wasn't a great one. Mizdow's antics were hilarious in my opinion, especially the post match stuff. Sheamus retained, so I figured it was about 2.25 stars.
The Big Show vs. Rusev, in all honesty, I thought it was pretty solid. I wasn't expecting a classic, but I got more than what I was expecting. Decent storytelling and I thought both big men worked hard. The surprise I was expecting here was Mark Henry turning heel and costing Big Show the match, but it didn't happen. Instead, Rusev scores a clean submission win via the Accolade. I thought it was a 2.5-2.75 star match.
AJ vs. Paige was the best match they've had of their series. This whole feud had such potential, but Vince either has no idea how to book a women's feud without the women being "crazy" or the typical "female problems" or he just has no interest in it. Still, a strong effort from the ladies. I gave it 3 stars.
Ambrose vs. Rollins was a great, wild brawl that featured some great spots. Ambrose looked like a genuine star last night and had the fans eating out of the palm of his hand. For a match like HIAC, I have to agree that a little blood is the only think that was missing here. Both men worked hard and delivered a stronf 4+ star bout. Bray Wyatt popping up the way he did kinda irked me just a little, because people ain't supposed to be able to get inside the Cell. People interfering from the outside negates the effectiveness and part of the purpose of a steel cage, it's just a pet peeve of mine, but it was nice to see him back.
All in all, I thought HIAC did what most of the best WWE shows this year have done: the matches that we expected to deliver did so with solid to strong undercard matches that delivered more than I was expecting. I thought the Dallas crowd was also a strong one last night in the sense that they were there to be entertained. I dunno if there just weren't a ton of smarks last night or if they themselves were in the mood to just enjoy themselves, but there were no "boring" chants or cat calls or any of the usual bullshit for matches they're just not into.