Greatest Music Decade

Favoruite Decade

  • 50's

  • 60's

  • 70's

  • 80's

  • 90's

  • 00's


Results are only viewable after voting.

Jane

Getting Noticed By Management
I know I'm gonna probably get ripped apart for this post by guys like xfear and stuff who know so much more about music then me, but this is just my view on each decade. I did use Wikipedia for a lot of it but I used my opinion a lot as well. And my opinion is only 14 years old. So don't kill me:)

In the last 60 years music has developed at a rapid pace as new instruments are invented and new trends are set. This thread asks the question- what decade was the greatest? We're nearing the 2010's where I'm sure a new type of music will emerge, and now we can look back at the last 6 decades and decide which was the best.

50's-We have such acts as Buddy Holly, Elvis, Chuck Berry, Roy Orbison and Fats Domino in the fast rising rock and roll scene in the decade that really changed music in the biggest way, with the introduction of electric instruments and amplification. Cello and violin were replaced by jazzy guitar licks and upbeat drum tracks. Artists began recording songs on a greater level with increased quality. Music became a part of pop culture and a huge influence on the youth of the day. It was around this time that music went from being at social gatherings and at rich homes to being listened to by teens and in high demand from society. It became a big part of life for kids, which really set the tone for the music-obsessed 60’s. This era is what started music in pop-culture.

60's-This is the decade of the British Invasion with big rock bands like The Rolling Stones, The Who, The Beatles, The Doors and Led Zeppelin, as well as artists like Jimi Hendrix and Janis Joplin. The decade started off with 50's blues influences but as we moved on we had early punk rock from The Who, acid rock from Jimi Hendrix and pop from The Beatles. Bands became differentiating themselves from eachother with more options to follow, and music became like a religion to the 60's generation. The decade was capped off with the incredible Woodstock, where Jimi Hendrix, Santana, Janis Joplin, Mountain, Grateful Dead, CCR, The Who, The Band, Jefferson Airplane and more showed the world what the psychedelic era was all about as they performed in front of 400 000 fans. This era completely changed the face of music.

70's-The 1970's had a huge variety of music, with Queen, Pink Floyd, Led Zeppelin, AC/DC, Aerosmith, Kiss and Van Halen leading the way. Dance became a big part of music with genres like funk and disco becoming popular. Punk rock, glam metal and hard rock became popular with the rebellious youth as The Ramones, Blondie, The Sex Pistols and The Clash emerged on the scene. Country became more popular with the mainstream audience with Willie Nelson and Kenny Rogers achieving popularity. Near the end of the decade reggae made its way into pop culture with Bob Marley and the Wailers at the forefront. And of course rock continued strong with bands like Led Zeppelin and AC/DC satisfying all tastes. This was really the decade of variety of music and with many of the bands from then still playing today it’s influence lives on.

80’s-Though this decade mostly continued on with the many acts of the 70’s, the 1980’s were really defined by their hard rock, with bands like Metallica, Guns n Roses, Iron Maiden and Motley Crue. This was around the time the older generation of rock left to make way for the newer bands, with Led Zeppelin broken up, The Who on hiatus for most of the decade, Lynyrd Skynyrd gone after the plane crash that took most of its members lives and Pink Floyd leaving the spot light. Pop music became far more popular with Michael Jackson, Prince and Madonna, and racial barriers in music were pretty much broken down in the music world with the release of Thriller in 1982. New soft rock bands like Journey and Bon Jovi became popular, with Aerosmith and ZZ Top continuing their streak. New wave groups like U2 and R.E.M become hugely popular with youth. Hip-hop began with acts like Run-DMC and The Beastie Boys. This was the decade of hard rock in a way, but it really had everything that someone could want.

90’s-The 90’s were the decade that replaced rock for the first time. This era had pop as its main source of entertainment, as the Spice Girls, Backstreet Boys and New Kids On the Block become huge with teens. Singers such as Mariah Carey, Whitney Houston and Bryan Adams become popular. It wasn’t all pop though. Alternative rock was on the rise with the Red Hot Chili Peppers, Nine Inch Nails, Smashing Pumpkins and Counting Crows finding success. Pop rock bands like Green Day, Blink 182 and Weezer became popular. Guns n Roses, Metallica, U2, Aerosmith and many more carried on their success from the 80’s. Probably the biggest genre of the early 90’s, however, was grunge, with Pearl Jam, Nirvana and Stone Temple Pilots taking over the youth of the time. Hip hop gains popularity with MC Hammer and Vanilla Ice emerging and rap is introduced with Dr. Dre, Snoop Dogg and Tupac. Other popular genres included ska, Britpop, Indie Rock and Skater Punk emerge. Blues are completely gone at this point after the death of Stevie Ray Vaugn and classic rock is essentially dead. This is the genre that essentially turned music into what it is today and was really the final step away from 50’s rock and roll.

00’s-The decade of hip-hop, with a huge number of artists and groups like Beyoncé, Black Eyed Peas, Akon, Chris Brown, Destiny’s Child, T-Pain and many more gaining popularity. Rap becomes a huge genre with Eminem, Lil’ Wayne, 50 Cent, Kanye West and others rising up. Post-grunge and alternative rock remains steady with Nickelback, Seether, 3 Doors Down and Hinder becoming popular. Pop punk is going strong with Green Day and Blink-182, and metalcore emerges with groups like Lamb of God, Avenged Sevenfold, Bullet For My Valentine and Killswitch Engage. Emo music becomes popular with the (idiot) youth, with groups like Fall Out Boy, Panic at the Disco and My Chemical Romance being labeled in this genre. Coldplay continues success following in the footsteps of bands like U2, and many older bands like The Eagles, The Rolling Stones, Bon Jovi and AC/DC continuing their hits. Indie rock is popular with bands like Kings of Leon, The White Stripes and The Arctic Monkeys. Boy bands like N’ Sync and the Backstreet Boys remain popular at the start of the decade and The Jonas Brothers find success today. “Children’s music” goes strong with High School Musical and Miley Cyrus somehow entertaining them. Country music takes a more pop feel as Taylor Swift, Carry Underwood and Kenny Chesney emerge. This decade is almost the opposite of the rockin’ 50’s, and I can hardly imagine what we see come the 10’s.

So that’s my overview of each decade. Reading it over I have to go with the 60’s. The majority of my favourite bands come from this decade, The Who, The Rolling Stones, Led Zeppelin and, of course, The Beatles. This band wasn’t as “dull” as the 50’s but still had that classic rock feel that was slightly diminished in the 70’s and on. It was rock but there was something more to it. The 60’s had passion in their music, and I wish I was around then to feel the way they do. The 50’s were the decade of rock, the 70’s of variety, the 80’s of hard rock, the 90’s of change and the 2000’s of hip-hop, but I think the 60’s were the decade of just pure music, and that’s why it gets my vote. Share your opinions here and make sure you vote.

Edit:IC is right, I didn't clarify if I wanted your favourite or the best. The poll says favourite but I actually want the one that in your opinion was the greatest, but say what one was your favourite as well. I think most of the time they're the same anyway. If a mod could change it from favourite to greatest it would be appreciated. My spelling failed anyway. And could you maybe make the poll public?
 
Now keep this in mind that I don't have much knowledge on the music from the 50's through the 70's, but I do got a bit of knowledge of 80's music & most of my knowledge on music comes from the 90's & 00's.

Now with that bein said, I picked the 90's & the reason why I picked that decade is listed below.

Now granted my favorite genre of music hip hop was takin off in the 80's, but once we hit the 90's, everything happened. The 90's in my mind & i'm pretty sure in other true hip hop fans opinion was the decade that hip hop truly shined(not sayin that the 80's hip hop was garbage as I love 80's hip hop as well) with the whole east coast/west coast rivalry, the rise of Snoop Dogg, the 2Pac/Biggie feud, Nas startin out his career by droppin the classic album known as Illmatic, Wu-Tang doin their thing by creatin great music & just a ton of great creative material that came from that decade. Now unfortunately we did have a couple of tragedy's along the way as both Pac & Biggie were murdered & of course Eazy-E passin away as well & of course with all 3 of them passin away, that started the decine of hip hop that is well turned the mainstream hip hop into a joke today.

I apologize for the little rant I did, but I had alot on my mind & alot to share as to why I chose the 90's as the greatest music decade.
 
Okay, now here's an issue. This is a terrific thread idea, but the thread title says "greatest music decade" and the poll says "favorite." I know my favorite, but I am damn sure it's not the best. So, on the poll, I voted for my favorite, but I'll answer both questions.

The greatest musical decade is the 70's. The 70's saw the greatest variety of popular music, and in my opinion, the embryonic stages of some very important movements. The 70's also saw the biggest involvement to date of technology in music, and in my opinion, the best combination of that technology into the music. The 80's overused technology, and 60's didn't see enough of it. The 70's hit the nail on the head.

Furthermore, in the 70's, rock bands truly took on larger than life personas and performances. There was a greatest inclusion of theatre in music in the 70's as opposed to the 50's or 60's. Sure, Elvis and the Stones were showmen, but in the 70's bands like Queen, Kiss, and Alice Cooper turned their music into an experience - a stage show, if you will.

The 70's saw the biggest explosion of alternative music genres, and as a result, more counter- and sub-cultural movements. Sure, the 60's and the hippie movement is best known for the biggest counter-culture, but in the 70's you saw the Hard Rock and Metal genre explode (Van Halen I and II were released, Kiss blew up, Zeppelin and AC/DC got huge), the punk scene made people stop and notice (Ramones, Sex Pistols, the start of Bad Religion), and as Jane mentioned, dance and country became more popular and main stream. Several people hold disco against the 70's in this discussion, which is both naive and dismissive. Let us also not forget Southern Rock such as .38 Special and Lynrd Skynrd. Or my personal fave - Arena / Corporate Rock - such as Queen, Yes, REO Speedwagon, etc., and the arrival of true progressive metal.

But my favorite? The 80's. Such gloriously shit music. Hair metal forever!
 
The greatest musical decade is the 70's. The 70's saw the greatest variety of popular music, and in my opinion, the embryonic stages of some very important movements.

See, but technically the "embryonic" stages of the genres of hard rock, metal, and punk that you mentioned were all started in the 60s. Hard rock was already established by the late 60s with Zeppelin, Blue Cheer began tinkering with what would later be called metal, and groups like the MC5 and The Stooges had already begun laying the seeds for punk rock.

That said, all of those genres really hit their stride in the 70s, so I can't argue with you that they really came to fruition in that decade.

One other minor little thing I wanted to address from your post IC was that Bad Religion started in the 70s, which isn't true. They formed the band in 1980 and released their first album How Could Hell Be Any Worse? (a masterpiece of hardcore punk) in 1982. Very minor thing that I thought I'd bring up though.

For me, it has to be the 60s. It's hard to argue the quality of music that came from that decade. Rock and roll was still fresh and new, and open to all kinds of exploration. Artists like The Beatles, The Doors, Bob Dylan, The Rolling Stones, The Who, Cream, Jimi Hendrix, Jefferson Airplane, The Byrds, I mean come on look at all those names! That right there is like the top of the top of the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, and that's only touching upon the great music of the decade. I could list off 100 more amazing bands from that decade that changed the landscape of rock and roll forever.

Every decade has amazing music though. I came very close to choosing the 80s because of the explosion of hardcore punk and new wave and synthpop. But in the end, the only logical choice is the 1960s. The amazing quality of music that was produced during that decade has never been rivaled, atleast not as of yet. It's unlikely it ever will be.
 
One other minor little thing I wanted to address from your post IC was that Bad Religion started in the 70s, which isn't true. They formed the band in 1980 and released their first album How Could Hell Be Any Worse? (a masterpiece of hardcore punk) in 1982. Very minor thing that I thought I'd bring up though.

Not minor to me. I fashion myself a big Bad Religion fan, and for some reason I thought they launched in 1978. Face, meet egg. Thanks for correcting me, though, X.

I am one of the few who felt the 60's are often over rated by some people. Maybe it's a good thing, because without the 60's, music would be nowhere. And I cannot discount the influence. I just feel the 70's did the 60's justice - the 70's basically said "wow, great music, let's make it better..."

And they succeeded.

Of course, X, in case of a tie, the tiebreaker goes to the 70's, since a 70's band won the Rock Tournament last year.

Queen FTW.
 
Not minor to me. I fashion myself a big Bad Religion fan, and for some reason I thought they launched in 1978. Face, meet egg. Thanks for correcting me, though, X.

No problem I'm a huge Bad Religion fan as well, Greg Graffin is one of the most insanely talented writers to ever grace the medium of music, and I mean that one hundred percent. No man has ever made me resort to a dictionary as much as Graffin, and that's a rare and damn impressive accomplishment in music. Add to the fact that they produced some of the best punk rock of the last nearly 30 years, and I've got tons of love for Bad Religion. "I Want to Conquer the World" ranks high in my personal favorite songs ever.

I am one of the few who felt the 60's are often over rated by some people. Maybe it's a good thing, because without the 60's, music would be nowhere. And I cannot discount the influence.

Well first off I'm interested to know why you feel the 60s were overrated? It's hard to overrate the legends, the 60s was like the 80s of Pro Wrestling, all-time legends left and right that set the bar for everything that would come after them.

I just feel the 70's did the 60's justice - the 70's basically said "wow, great music, let's make it better..."

And they succeeded.


And I can't agree with you either. So of course, since I'm a dick, I'll debate you ;).

I'm assuming you're talking about the mainstream rock and roll of the 70s when you say that they did the 60s justice. I've always felt the exact opposite. Most of the great rock bands of the 70s had either started in the 60s or had their roots there.

And a lot of popular music of the 70s were completely bastardized, commercialized version of the music from the 60s. Stuff like Three Dog Night took what was so great about that 60s music, and pissed on it pretty much (except for "Shambala"...that's a good damn song).

I mean, you stack up one-by-one the great bands of the 70s against their 60s counterparts, and the 60s really show their dominance. What's the best the 70s have to offer? The Eagles? The 60s had The Beatles.

Of course, X, in case of a tie, the tiebreaker goes to the 70's, since a 70's band won the Rock Tournament last year.

Queen FTW.

Which was and is bullshit. You want to talk overrated, let's talk about Queen and how they are praised by the people on this board. Queen was a great rock band, yes, but they don't even crack the top ten greatest rock bands, let alone the greatest band ever. Total blasphemy.

Newsflash everyone: Queen is not the greatest band ever. Not even close.
 
<removes the kid gloves, realizes he's dealing with X here and he can still learn something>

1. Bad Religion FTW. We can agree there. "I Wanna Conquer the World" was a classic. Though believe it or not, I prefered BR's newer stuff like "Stranger Than Fiction" and "The Gray Race."

2. I have trouble putting my feelings about the 60's into perspective. Let's put it this way - I'd never try to convince somebody who loves the music of the 60's that they are wrong. It comes down to personal preference, really. I love all music too much to tell someone "no, you're wrong" here.

3. Sure, great 70's bands had their roots in the 60's. Many great 60's bands had roots in the 50's. Van Halen blew up in 1980, but I consider them a 70's band since that was the true arrival. If you had to place a band into a particular decade based on when they "arrived" to status, I'd take the bands of the 70's. Van Halen. Pink Floyd. Queen. Ac/DC. Aerosmith.

4. Queen is the greatest rock band in history. And I have the 350+ band tournament to prove it. Don't believe / agree with me? Next time don't disappear during the tournament you so graciously helped me launch. I rank your late round vanishing act as the great disappointment of last year on the boards. Though, since Queen won the finals by a single vote, I'm not complaining. :)
 
<removes the kid gloves, realizes he's dealing with X here and he can still learn something>

1. Bad Religion FTW. We can agree there. "I Wanna Conquer the World" was a classic. Though believe it or not, I prefered BR's newer stuff like "Stranger Than Fiction" and "The Gray Race."

Their new stuff is great as well, still making great punk all these years later. Sometimes I prefer their early hardcore work before they mellowed out, but every era is fantastic with a band this good.

2. I have trouble putting my feelings about the 60's into perspective. Let's put it this way - I'd never try to convince somebody who loves the music of the 60's that they are wrong. It comes down to personal preference, really. I love all music too much to tell someone "no, you're wrong" here.

And I can't reasonably expect to change your mind on your own personal preferences either, but we can atleast debate the merits of our respective sides in this argument.

3. Sure, great 70's bands had their roots in the 60's. Many great 60's bands had roots in the 50's. Van Halen blew up in 1980, but I consider them a 70's band since that was the true arrival. If you had to place a band into a particular decade based on when they "arrived" to status, I'd take the bands of the 70's. Van Halen. Pink Floyd. Queen. Ac/DC. Aerosmith.

Van Halen - Overrated. Two good albums hardly puts them in the league of the Beatles or the Doors.

Pink Floyd - Honestly, I know you won't agree with me, but I could make the argument that they were just as good in the 60s as they were in the 70s. The Piper At the Gates of Dawn is probably equally as good as Dark Side of the Moon. Amazing 70s band though obviously, but the argument could be made they were technically a 60s band. They started and excelled initially in the 60s.

Queen - Overrated. Great, great band. Not on the level of the 60s groups like the Beatles, Doors, Who, Stones, etc, etc.

AC/DC - Great hard rock, but musically, lyrically, and artistically they do not match up to even their rock peers of the time like Pink Floyd. I love AC/DC, don't get me wrong, but the simple blues rock they played haven't had the impact or appeal of the earlier groups I mentioned. Great band though.

Aerosmith - Another great band, but also another band that doesn't even hold a candle to the 60s groups I've mentioned. Even the lesser groups of the 60s like the Kinks or the Yardbirds make Aerosmith look like amateurs.

4. Queen is the greatest rock band in history. And I have the 350+ band tournament to prove it. Don't believe / agree with me? Next time don't disappear during the tournament you so graciously helped me launch. I rank your late round vanishing act as the great disappointment of last year on the boards. Though, since Queen won the finals by a single vote, I'm not complaining. :)

Sorry man I got into a bit of shit for a little while there, lots of bad luck. No place to live, couldn't afford the internet obviously. Than I got a job, became busy with work, and just became lazy. Got a finally and now am on it all the time. I'm addicted to this bastardly easy internet access.

Can't wait for the new music tournament, I will be just as vocal as I was last time, even more so this time in my backing of The Doors for greatest rock band of all time.
 
Their new stuff is great as well, still making great punk all these years later. Sometimes I prefer their early hardcore work before they mellowed out, but every era is fantastic with a band this good.

Agreed.

And I can't reasonably expect to change your mind on your own personal preferences either, but we can atleast debate the merits of our respective sides in this argument.

Fair enough. I am game. 70's > 60's, but it's close. And yet 80's is my favorite, and I identify with the music of the 90's the closest. Weird.

Van Halen - Overrated. Two good albums hardly puts them in the league of the Beatles or the Doors.

You on crack!? Two good albums? These guys put out great music for 2+ decades. Fair Warning was gritty long before grunge, 5150 was beautiful in its own right, For Unlawful Carnal Knowledge was such a great, sexually charged theme album, and I'd even argue that Balance was the best of the Hagar era.

Pink Floyd - Honestly, I know you won't agree with me, but I could make the argument that they were just as good in the 60s as they were in the 70s. The Piper At the Gates of Dawn is probably equally as good as Dark Side of the Moon. Amazing 70s band though obviously, but the argument could be made they were technically a 60s band. They started and excelled initially in the 60s.

Actually, I have Shine on your Crazy Diamond #1 and Animals #2.

Queen - Overrated. Great, great band. Not on the level of the 60s groups like the Beatles, Doors, Who, Stones, etc, etc.

Well, I guess the only thing the greatest band of all time can be IS over rated. The #1 bestest in the worldest can't be "under rated" because they are the best.

Queen > Beatles. Did it better. Not first, but better.

Queen > Doors. See - Beatles.

Queen > Who. See - Doors.

Queen > Stones. But it's CLOSE.

Queen > etc. etc. Obvious reasons.

AC/DC - Great hard rock, but musically, lyrically, and artistically they do not match up to even their rock peers of the time like Pink Floyd. I love AC/DC, don't get me wrong, but the simple blues rock they played haven't had the impact or appeal of the earlier groups I mentioned. Great band though.

Agreed. And I even prefered Brian Johnson over Bon Scott.

Aerosmith - Another great band, but also another band that doesn't even hold a candle to the 60s groups I've mentioned. Even the lesser groups of the 60s like the Kinks or the Yardbirds make Aerosmith look like amateurs.

Oh god no. Aerosmith had longevity and creativity that the Kinks and Yardbirds didn't. I couldn't stand the Kinks. Yardbirds I liked, but not to the level I like Aerosmith. Tyler and co. took blues-rock to a whole new level, and I'll even go on the limb and say that Honkin on Bobo is one of their 3 best albums of all time, along with Toys in the Attic.

Sorry man I got into a bit of shit for a little while there, lots of bad luck. No place to live, couldn't afford the internet obviously. Than I got a job, became busy with work, and just became lazy. Got a finally and now am on it all the time. I'm addicted to this bastardly easy internet access.

Oh it's cool, but don't complain about the President if you didn't vote, that's all I am saying.

Can't wait for the new music tournament, I will be just as vocal as I was last time, even more so this time in my backing of The Doors for greatest rock band of all time.

Wasn't gonna do another, but I can be persuaded.
 
OK, it's my turn now to answer. Hope I don't get dissected and slapped around like a beyotch!

Favorite Era: 90's
Why? Well, because it's what I call "the decade of the double-edged sword". You can't deny Green Day, Blink and Weezer's rise to fame in this decade. And you damn sure can't deny that Nirvana was THE band of the early 90's! On the other side of the blade, however, is teen pop...the precursor to hannah montana.

Greatest Decade: 60's
Why? It's the decade that took Rock 'n' Roll, and distorted it. Acid Rock, Psychadelic, Beatles, Stones...the decade in which I feel, some of the greatest innovators had ever lived on. The events that revolved around it just fueled the fire.

But you got to aknowledge the other eras as well. I mena, they all had their pros, some more than others, of course.

The 50's gave us Rock n' Roll, the 60's gave us The Beatles, The Stones, Hendrix, and Joplin, the 70's gave us more sub-genres, 80's were all hair metal IMO, and the 90's....well, you might know. As for the 00's, well it's shaping up to be the decade of Indies, alternatives, and children's pop.

But most importantly, and I damn sure agree with most of the people that say this...We got to be grateful to the blues, since it's the one genre that gave way to it all.
 
OK, it's my turn now to answer. Hope I don't get dissected and slapped around like a beyotch!

So you're saying "IC25, please don't treat me like XFear?" Okay, no sweat.

Favorite Era: 90's
Why? Well, because it's what I call "the decade of the double-edged sword". You can't deny Green Day, Blink and Weezer's rise to fame in this decade. And you damn sure can't deny that Nirvana was THE band of the early 90's! On the other side of the blade, however, is teen pop...the precursor to hannah montana.

Every decade as "the other edge of the sword." The 70's was disco, the 80's was power ballads. For the 90's, boy bands and rock-rap are arguably the black eyes in an otherwise deep and meaningful decade of music. I grew up in the 90's, went through puberty with the sounds of Sublime in the background (my best friend lost his virginity to "Caress Me Down." Yep, the one song) and let Alice in Chains surround my high school days.

Greatest Decade: 60's
Why? It's the decade that took Rock 'n' Roll, and distorted it. Acid Rock, Psychadelic, Beatles, Stones...the decade in which I feel, some of the greatest innovators had ever lived on. The events that revolved around it just fueled the fire.

I feel like we should disqualify the 60's for performance enhancing drugs.

I still feel that the arrival of technology and theatre to music in the 70's makes it the stronger decade. No 70's music theatre means no 80's music television.
[/QUOTE]
 
You on crack!? Two good albums? These guys put out great music for 2+ decades. Fair Warning was gritty long before grunge, 5150 was beautiful in its own right, For Unlawful Carnal Knowledge was such a great, sexually charged theme album, and I'd even argue that Balance was the best of the Hagar era.

See, I completely disagree. I've never been a big Van Halen fan, aside from their first album and 1984, I don't see their appeal. They're good, Eddie Van Halen is an amazing guitarist obviously, but they only had a few good years with David Lee Roth, and then they were awful. Sammy Hagar is pure shit IMO. That band started to sound like the kind of music that stupid rednecks listen to while beating up gay people.

Well, I guess the only thing the greatest band of all time can be IS over rated. The #1 bestest in the worldest can't be "under rated" because they are the best.

Who says their the best? The Beatles have sold over a billion records worldwide, whereas Queen has only sold 300 million in comparison. I'd say the majority of people on the globe would agree with me, Beatles > Queen.

Queen > Beatles. Did it better. Not first, but better.

Absolutely ridiculous. One of the most ridiculous things you've ever said dude! There isn't a single aspect of Queen that is superior to the Beatles, not one. Queen has never produced an album anywhere near the quality of Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band, Revolver, or The White Album. Not even close man.

Queen > Doors. See - Beatles.

More ridiculous nonsense. Freddie Mercury wasn't half the frontman Morrison was even on his best day. The Doors as well are superior to Queen in every way imaginable, from music to lyrics to importance and legacy.

Queen > Who. See - Doors.

Queen > Stones. But it's CLOSE.

Queen > etc. etc. Obvious reasons.

No, and no. Come on dude you're losing my respect by the minute! The Who and the Stones both make Queen look like shit.

Agreed. And I even prefered Brian Johnson over Bon Scott.

I'm a Bon Scott man myself. The only thing Johnson has ever done is attempt to mimic Scott. Back in Black is a great album obviously though, their Live album is as well.

Oh god no. Aerosmith had longevity and creativity that the Kinks and Yardbirds didn't. I couldn't stand the Kinks. Yardbirds I liked, but not to the level I like Aerosmith. Tyler and co. took blues-rock to a whole new level, and I'll even go on the limb and say that Honkin on Bobo is one of their 3 best albums of all time, along with Toys in the Attic.

Aerosmith haven't been good since the early 80s. Their entire resurgence in t he late 80s into the 90s has been nothing but utter garbage that I'm surprised anyone with a semblance of taste can enjoy. I haven't heard Honkin' On Bobo though I've heard good things about it. I've heard it's similar to their early work, which is amazing. But from like 85 onwards they have been trash. The Kinks make Aeromsith's melodies look like tin pots hitting each other, and the Yardbirds are more blues than Aerosmith could ever hope and beg and pray to be. Any group involving Eric Clapton, Jimmy Page, and Jeff Beck just shits all over Aerosmith, sorry.

And hell yes you should do another tournament man. Why not? I'm thinking of an idea for a tourament of my own.
 
I feel like we should disqualify the 60's for performance enhancing drugs.

And the 80's should be disqualified for hair-enhancing products along with it, the 70's for the tight pants, disco shoes and people that could not rock the afro, and the 00's for miley cyrus alone!

I still feel that the arrival of technology and theatre to music in the 70's makes it the stronger decade. No 70's music theatre means no 80's music television.

Got to agree with you there! But to me, the 70's were just a re-imagining of the 70's. Well, a different view from what the 60's did. And like the 60's before it, events fueled the fire even further.
 
And the 80's should be disqualified for hair-enhancing products along with it, the 70's for the tight pants, disco shoes and people that could not rock the afro, and the 00's for miley cyrus alone!

That's just ridiculous. EVERY decade has had awful music, you think teen pop started in the 90s? Teen pop has existed since the 50s, bubblegum pop was a big seller in the 60s and 70s.

And you are completely dismissing the 80s. More than hair metal happened in the 80s, punk rock and new wave and metal all exploded and expanded like never before.

Every decade has had great music, you can't "disqualify" any of them.
 
I chose the 70's, as that is the time that all of my favorite bands flourished. I am a huge fan of Queen, Led Zep, and Skynard. These bands were at their best in the 70's.

I know that the 70's were the decade of Disco, but the other genres excelled. First of all, if you look beyond Rock n Roll, the 70's were the prime of the Jackson 5. The first post-racial act from Motown defined R&B in the decade. Toward the end of the decade, Michael Jackson released his first solo album, laying the groundwork for half of the music of the 80's.

Led Zep released all but two of their albums in the 70's. They are generally defined as the greatest rock band of all time. Their greatest work was done in the 70's. Their work from the 60's realized it's full potential in the 70's as well. The band toured throughout the decade and made their legion of fans then.

Queen owned the 70's. This band's following still grows today. Their music caught the frustration of the decade, along with the happy times. The stories they told were epic, and they truly are the band we think of when we think 70's music. Plus, there is no better live performer than Freddie Mercury. Honestly, if you could pick any lead singer to lead your band, who would it be? Freddie!
 
Yeesh...this is tough a choice. I'm honestly a little torn because I understand the impact the 60's and 70's made, the 80's was the beginning of hip hop's exposure, while the 90's were where a great majority of my favorite rappers were big in. God damn it my head hurts. Let me break this down then.

Favorite Decade: 90's. For reasons said above, this is where I believe hip hop flourished the most, and it was the decade where some truly great legends came up from the underground. You had my all time favorite group Bone Thugs come around in '94, Dre, Eazy, 2pac, Biggie, Nas, DMX, and the list just goes on. I gotta go with the 90's for my favorite decade for this reason alone. And I haven't even touched some of the other genres either.

Greatest Decade: 70's. The 70's was the greatest decade however, many of the legendary bands we still listen to today hit their stride and released some amazing albums. From Led Zepplin, to Jim Morrison death, some important events in music happened in this decade, and it can't be stressed enough how important they were. Aside from the rock side of things, you also had the great Bob Marley releasing his message of peace through music primarily during the 70's when he was at his peak of popularity, Peter Tosh was around this era as well. Not only all this, but a lot of the foundation for the beginning of hip hop was started during this time frame. The culture was spreading within the New York urban community, the sound was being crafted, and DJ's were spinning and scratching by the end of the 70's. Truly a great decade, a very important decade.
 
Again, I understand the impact that musical acts made in the 60's and 70's. The pioneering bands, the original rock stars and so forth. But I myself have just never conencted with music from that era. I've always felt it lacks some sort of emotion. Alot of music from that era just seems kinda shallow to me.

It's the 90's for me. The best songwriting from this era is just magnificent. Pretty much all my favourite albums come from this era. Siamese Dream, Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness, Grace, The Bends, Ok Computer, The Blue Album, The Downward Spiral, the list goes on and on. So many classic albums from that decade.
And bands from the 90's changed the drug taking, partying rock star sterotype that was formed in the 70's and 80's. Kurt Cobain was addicted to drugs, but that wasn't his persona outside the music. Like Trent Reznor, and others. 90's was the era where rockstars did more than party. They had lives, and problems. And those problems in their personal lives translated into some great music. Truly the decade of the tortured genius, in my opinion.

I'll never like the 80's very much. Yes, Guns n Roses are superb. But there's far too much hair metal for my liking. The shallowest form of music, and shallowness in music is something I despise.

00's are a weird era. It seems to be the era where the less talent you have as a rock band, the more successful you become. How are youmeatsix one of the fastest rising young bands on the planet? I could write better music with just a pack of crisps and a toilet seat. Seriously.
But this decade is being held up by great bands that have emerged in the last 5-10 years. Bands like Muse, Queens of the Stone Age and The White Stripes. Here's hoping that more great bands can push the crap out of the way and put the focus onto good music again rather than image and such.
 
The 90s has all of my favorite bands and it had the Grunge movement, which was really the last time multiple great rock bands were the most popular music acts in the world. It had legendary bands like Alice in Chains, Pearl Jam, Stone Temple Pilots, Nirvana, Soundgarden, and Smashing Pumpkins. Just a great time for music, it's a shame heroin had to ruin the longevity of the 90s rock movement.
 
Favourite and best era's of music? In reality when looking at all the answers that people have posted they are both interconnected. So far everyone favourite decade seems to be the one following what they consider the best- the previous being the best as it helped form their decade :p

Anyways I find best very difficult to fully analyse as to do so I would have to try and consider the musical popularity and importance of a lot of bands I have never really listened to. So (to go with easy answers first) my favourite era is the present on- the 00's

I am what all you guys with your extensive musical knowledge will probably consider a musical newbie (or N00B- I think :) ). I like modern, new music, things which catch my attention, which move things forward. I know most of my bands have their source in the past but I tend to prefer them. Yes they may have stepped in the footsteps of others on their way forward, but they have stepped forward :p

Bands which stepped up inn the early 00's included Sigur Ros, leading the admittedly small Icelandic invasion, which included Bang Gang, Mum, Olafur Arnalds, Johann Johanasson. (I love this music sooo much. Aghh :blush: ) I also throw into this section the Chinese artist Dadawa- as she suits them in tone and style- an amazing powerful singer. If you want to be carried away by a wave of vocal power and energy- give Sister Drum a try. This leads nicely on to talking about other females.
Female artists built on some of their success in the 90's to move into increasingly different and new directions in the 00's. Artists like Bat for Lashes, Dresden Dolls, Alina Orlova, Blood Red Shoes, Cansei de ser Sexy, Lykke Li, and Yelle helped highlight that alternative female fronted music wasn't simple gothic metal or simple accoustic guitar compositions singing about ex boyfriends. (Though even when they did do it, it was done with humour and individuality- Try Soko- I'll Kill her- very over the top and emotional. Seriously warn any of you guys off a French girlfriend ;) )

Larger mainstream bands are also going from strength- Queens of the Stone Age, Radiohead (a tricky one as some would claim their best work was in the 90's but have produced more good albums in the 00's), At the Drive made its magnum opus, Relationship of Command and then split to form Mars Volta, a band constantly producing interesting and different music. Muse too hit their stride in the 00's, and for once pop music is sounding faintly bearable La Roux, Little Boots, Ladyhawke (seriously do they all reside in my L section. You guys are going to think I am going through the alphabet :) ) and Florence and the Machine, doing much to tempt me to maybe listen to a radio again.

But the real glory and importance of the 00's is down to the internet. Now artists are making more and more music away from the devilish hands of record companies. Thanks to sites like Last Fm and others you can listen to music from all around the world or be introudced to a bewildering variety of music. Everyone and his dog can now make music, and most of this is horrible, but there are jems to be found in the various smaller bands. Bands like Yindi Halda (British kinda orchestral- but with old instruments- post rock band), Patrick Wolf, Mujuice (Russian synth artist- really nice ambient sounds), Joy Formidible (welsh indie rock), Fanfarlo (Sweedish/British artist- kinda downbeat), La Luca della Centralle Ellectrica (Italian acoustic grunge) are just a couple I can think off the top of my head.

So yeah, the 00's have been a very exciting time for music, with lots of new opportunities and bands moving forward. Clearly its my favourite :)

(Sneakily I failed to answer what was the best era. Honestly I can't say. All of the previous generations influenced music- but none that I can say really brought it forward noticeably- from the 50's onwards things moved forward like nothing before. So yeah, sorry if you read all this to get that cop-out. But yeah- big hugs if you did read all of this- its fairly huge. Drop me a line if you like any of the bands I mentioned- bar Radiohead or Queens, Muse- I haven&#8217;t seen any of them mentioned here)
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
174,851
Messages
3,300,884
Members
21,726
Latest member
chrisxenforo
Back
Top