TNA is not half bad to be honest, an hour into the show and they have had more wrestling time than RAW has had in the past two weeks. They should move outside this shitty Impact zone ASAP, they can sell out arenas in the 3000-5000 range easily.
Obviously, their house show attendances is quite low, but house show sales are different to television tapings, they sold about 3000 the last few times they went on the road with Impact and their marketing is abysmal to say the least, by all accounts.
Last September when I was at the US, New England to be exact, whenever there was RAW on air, they would remind you about the tickets available for the November 15th show at the TD Garden, TNA had a show in the next town to where I stayed, and I could swear, I didn't see one advertisement telling me there was a show next town, not on TV, not on Radio, nothing.
A live show would sell and open newer markets to them, I am not saying that they will sell out MSG, but arenas on college campuses are mostly about 6000-8000 which if you take the space occupied by the set and the production team would make its capacity about half of this which I think with some advertising can be sold out, especially as I mentioned, the show will be live and on television.
Obviously, there are portions of the show I don't like, portraying the backstage segments as reality television while good in principle could be done a whole lot better, they need to work on their production and making three title matches after such a huge PPV is a mistake. On the other side, there is a lot of action in the show and the storytelling is good, they improved massively since the last time I saw them and obviously no Vince Russo helped but they need to focus more on building towards the PPVs (which I think they should decrease the number of the PPVs they do to just 6 and better if four) and less on focusing on the ratings as I feel they are so Television oriented. Production as I said needs improving, but then again, RAW's production compared to Nitro's was shit but since RAW was a much better show, no one cared about the production '98 & '99.
The live factor is good, but they also need to advertise more, Roode, Storm, Styles, Daniels, they need to make them feel like stars, put them with Hulk, Angle, Sting on talk shows, radio appearances, etc, a lot of people don't even know what is even TNA because they rarely advertise their shows or their stars.