Wyatt needs to start backing up that talk, whatever he does. I think the thing that hurt Wyatt the most facing Undertaker was the lack of confrontation prior to the fight. Wyatt sold the feud by himself, with a little help from Taker's pyro and vfx, but so far his big victories are Kane, Jericho, Ambrose, and an impressive Royal Rumble marred by a ho-hum elimination courtesy of two of the stalest main eventers in the company.
You're not scary if you're some creepy dude who arrives and loses after talking a lot of smack. He couldn't get one win over Cena in three PPV matches? Also, what's a cult leader without cultists? At least give him Rowan back, he's going no where in a big red hurry. What about other guys with nothing to do? Slater is directionless now that PTP are back together. What about an NXT call up? Not saying Dempsey is ready, but he looks like he should be in the Wyatt family. The way I see things, the family dissolution was more a desire to see big Luke Harper go solo than anything else.
Wyatt needs to start winning, beating a big brute like Ryback is a good start. I see bright things for Wyatt. I believe he's a future champion, the mid card titles don't fit his character but the World title would. One of the things that really made the Wyatt character work in NXT was the family. Give him back the family. His characters'scharisma screams leader and a leader needs guys to lead. Harper can stay solo, just give Bray some followers.