Batista / Lesnar CAN NOT be in the WM30 Main Event!

[BaconBits]

I don't think the pop that Batista got last night will do him any favours, people just didn't really seem to care that he came back.

On some level, this is a completely unfair criticsm.

The E announced when and where his return would be, with vignettes and the whole nine. If none of that had happened and Batista would have just showed up and made his return at a different random RAW or the Rumble or Elimination Chamber, the reaction would have been far bigger. Wrasslin' afficianados love surprise returns.

The braintrust at the E knows this. If the arena in Vegas had never put him on their website and the dirtsheets never picked up on it, they never would have announced it was happening and he would have come out 30th at the Rumble and the place would have gone apeshit.

 

[L@RISANO]

If anything, the reaction for Batista should send a message to him, basically that for the Universe as a whole to care for him, he has to work for their affection again. Put on great matches.
If a Brock-Batista match is planned,then for it to be sold based on what I observed last night:
1.) Brock vs Big Show has to be a Great Match. Something the crowd comes out happy with. Brock has generally had great matches since he came back, so hopefully, the two Big guys put on a good showing.

2.) Batista has to look strong in the ring. Get some interest in his in-ring work somehow. Look as much as an Animal as he could.

Then, and only then, would a Batista - Brock Lesnar match get some interest. At this time, judging by the reaction last night. I don't see them pulling off a successful Main Event with just those two in it.
Note: Batista looks way,way less imposing than before, doesn't he? After RAW last night, I rewatched a clip of RR2008, and the difference in the size of Batista's body then to now, was incredible!

 

[Mitch Henessey]

Batista's return last night reminded me of Triple H's return at Summerslam 2007: everything felt too forced. When Triple H returned at Summerslam 2007, WWE ran a series of Six Million Dollar Man style promo videos. On the night of his return, WWE gave Triple H a grandiose entrance with pyro, and they ran another video promo. Triple H got a reaction from the live crowd, but it wasn't thunderous.

By the time he got to the ring, Triple H hit all four turnbuckles to do his signature pose, but the crowd didn't explode. When he reached the fourth turnbuckle, you could clearly see the fans really didn't care anymore, and Triple H had to stall and play around with the fans to force a reaction. The whole scenario was kind of awkward, because you could tell WWE wanted a 2002 at MSG moment, but it didn't happen.

Batista got a reaction last night, but he didn't get the earth-shattering reaction WWE was hoping for. When he hit the ring, Batista had to work with all of his posing to pull something out of the crowd. You can't force or manufacture moments like Triple H at MSG in 2002. Those moments have to come naturally for a variety of reasons. Maybe you can make an argument for a surprise Batista return receiving a better reaction with the help of shock value, but I'm not so sure. As far as big time returning stars go, Batista is not on The Rock or Brock Lesnar's level, his routine as the meathead is stale, and it's as simple as that.

So yeah, I don't think we have to worry about Lesnar VS Batista as the main event anymore. I'm sure both men will cross paths at some point (Summerslam), but I'm hoping it doesn't happen at Wrestlemania. Batista should be a front-runner to win the Rumble, because he needs the momentum. Then, WWE can go with Batista VS Orton for the WWE WHC, but that's not a main event worthy match.

 

[CM Wyatt]

I don't want it either of them because:They don't deserve it! Only 4 guys deserve it: Cena, Bryan, Orton, Punk, PERIOD!
In the other hand, neither for business! Brock was in last year, so if can be on the last before the main event, it wont kill him. And Batista is NOT The Rock!

 

[hatehabsforever]

Maybe this is splitting hairs a little, but I could definitely see a Brock Lesnar versus Dave Batista matchup at WM30, but certainly not as the main event. I'm not sure either of these part timers will be in the main event of the evening, and I'm also not certain that either of them should be. They will both be at the event, and they may face each other earlier in the night, but they won't lock up in the main event of the night for several reasons.

Of course, the rest of the card is very up in the air in my opinion, so the prominence of the match involving either of these guys will be determined by how the card shapes up. For example, if Cena beats Orton at the Rumble and is the champion, and Lesnar wins the Rumble match itself, I could easily see John Cena versus Brock Lesnar main event, although I don't anticipate this as the main event either. Likewise, a Lesnar versus Underaker match could close the evening as well, depending on where they choose to go with this. Personally, I cannot envision a scenario whereby Batista is in the main event.

It's clear to me what the main event should be: John Cena versus the Undertaker, doing the unthinkable.

 

[thebarber]

Batista will not be in the kainj event at Wrestlemania XXX. He isnt a draw to the level of carrying the biggest ppv in history after being off tv for nearly 4 years.
John Cena in some way shape or form will be in the Mania XXX main event, this is a given and thus why I expect him to head into Wrestlemania as WWE Heavyweight Champion. Orton is being soured on by The Authority, and possibly being phased out as champion. Dabiel Bryan is over huige and I certainly expect him to be a surprise entrant in, and winning the Royal Rumble match up.

 

[shanezam203]

Wow, I have to admit I was semi looking forward to Batista's return but like many on here I was never a huge Batista fan and I have to admit, I was NOT impressed with his return last night.

 

[$Mr. 100%]

Lesnar/batista is a must c match. W/that said 1 thing u said stands out 2 me alot:this year wm is 30 and u want someone who lives and breathes wwe n main event. I kinda feel da same way. Cena(altho i can't stand him)lives wwe so does hhh punk bran taker etc devoted superstars. Thats y batista/Lesnar should happen. Give 2 parttime badasses a match that would b decent but not da main event

 

[The_Natural24]

I do agree that a Batista vs. Lesner match would be a massive draw but not to 'Main Event' the 30 Year Anniversary of Wrestlemania! It could be one of 3 or 4 Main Events on the card though! The ideal match to finish the PPV off in my opinion is Cena to challange the Undertaker's streak.

But back to Lesnar and Batista...........
THE BADDEST MAN ON THE PLANET vs. THE BEAST

If we do get this match, lets just hope that Batista/Lesnar is a better fight than Brock vs. Goldberg 10 years ago - which was a complete disaster.
Wrestling fans including myself salivated over the possibility of seeing those two monsters go at it in the ring with SCSA as special ref but it just never got going! Im sure BL and Dave would both give it a real go so im not against it at all, but being (2/3 from last)