A Look Back: Saw

Mitch Henessey

Deploy the cow-catcher......
Staff member
Moderator
I’ve been watching the entire Saw film series over the past couple of weeks, and I watched Saw 7/3D in theaters not too long ago. Saw 7/3D is supposed to be the last film in the Saw series, and I’ve always wanted to share my thoughts on this fairly popular horror franchise:

Saw (2004) 5/10-
The first Saw film delivers pretty well. The acting was solid, and Jigsaw only had three victims for his games in this one. It was kind of disturbing to watch Cary Elwes saw a hunk of his own leg off. They didn’t let you see this gruesome moment, and I think this was a good thing, because it let your imagination run wild. Just thinking about someone sawing through their own leg with a rusty blade is just sickening. Although, this film has always had this lackluster feel for me. I’ve tried over the years, but I can never get into it.

Saw 2 (2005) 8/10-
This is my favorite Saw film. The verbal dueling between Donnie Wahlberg and Tobin Bell was just priceless. Also, the whole “you don’t deserve life, if you don’t appreciate life” ideology was still fresh in this film. There were more victims in this film, and the deaths were a lot more gruesome. And we got to see the rise of Amanda Young, as she was revealed to be Jigsaw’s apprentice in this film.

Saw 3 (2006) 6/10- I LOVED Shawnee Smith as Amanda Young in this film. She was easily the highlight of Saw 3. She did such a good job at playing this psychotic apprentice. She was funny, dark, and creepy. The traps become even more elaborate in this one, and the deaths are a lot more painful to watch. I loved Smith in this film, but she really is the only highlight in Saw 3. This Saw film doesn’t bring anything new to the table. They just crank things up a little bit when it comes to the torture and violence. Jigsaw is on his death bed, and the ending to this film will make your head spin. They throw sooooo much stuff at you in the final few minutes. It will give you a headache.

Saw 4 (2007) 1/10-
I hated this movie. Again, they really don’t change the formula too much here. The gore and violence is a lot more intense, Hoffman is revealed as another one of Jigsaw’s apprentices, we get too learn more about Jill Tuck(Jigsaw’s wife) and Jigsaw’s traps continue to pick off more people from the previous films. This film just didn’t do it for me, and I think this is where the Saw franchise started to go on a downward spiral. Also, there were some Jigsaw flashbacks here.

Saw 5 (2008) 4/10- Saw 5 was okay. Here we see more flashbacks of Jigsaw while he was still alive, and we also see what drove Hoffman to the dark side. I enjoyed watching Strahm follow the trail of Hoffman, but again, this film follows the same formula as the previous Saw films, and by now it’s starting to get tiresome.

Saw 6 (2009) 3/10- Yeah, I still couldn’t get into Hoffman as Jigsaw’s replacement. He just doesn’t have the presence that Jigsaw had, and the character is just so plain and bland. We’re in the SIXTH film now, and they still stick to the same formula of kidnapping a bunch of people, and forcing them into situations where they will have to kill another person. The best part about this film is when Jigsaw is shown having a conversation with the health insurance executive during a flashback.

Saw 7/3D (2010) 2/10- Saw 4 really angered me, but this film truly pissed me off. Yeah, the 3D effects were cool, but they threw the same shit at us again. This was supposed to be the final chapter, but Saw 7 just seemed like all of the other Saw films. I was expecting Saw to go out with a bang, but I should’ve known better. And again, a Jigsaw flashback is the best part about this movie. This film was just recently released, and a lot of you might not have seen it, so I’ll add some more thoughts in spoiler tags.

THEY KILLED OFF JILL TUCK!!!!!!! I really enjoyed her in the Saw films. Betsy Russell did a good job with this character, and I hated to see her go.

Dr.Gordon leaves Hoffman for dead, and he is the one who will carry on Jigsaw’s legacy? Really? And who were the other two people in the pig masks?

Saw 7 had a very cool movie poster. That’s the only other good thing I can say about this film:

1494-450x666.jpg

Jigsaw was a different type of horror villain. He was a cancer(and suicide) survivor who wanted to teach people how to value their lives. Then there were the apprentices. Shawnee Smith did an amazing job with the Amanda Young character. You could truly believe she was a brainwashed psycho. I wasn’t too crazy about Hoffman. The character just seemed so bland to me. I know he was supposed to be cold and calculating, but I never felt that. Art Blank( the lawyer in the fourth film) was another person who helped Jigsaw with his dirty work, but he only appeared in one Saw film. Zep(Michael Emerson) was just a victim in the first Saw film, and we didn’t get to see that much of him either. The acting in the first three films was pretty solid, but as more characters were killed off, the quality of the acting went down. Betsy Russell(Jill Tuck) was the only one who was able to deliver some noteworthy performances as the series started to wind down.

I saw the first Saw film on DVD years ago, and I didn’t think too much of it. The Saw series had some potential, and the first three films aren‘t bad, but this series took a dive after the third film. You can only torture and kill people in so many different ways. It becomes stale after a while. Flashbacks of Jigsaw being the highlight of a Saw movie can‘t be looked at as a good sign. The Saw films can be hit and miss, but if you want something to watch around Halloween time, then the Saw films could be what you’re looking for. Now as far as money goes, the Saw films were low budget, but they always managed to rake in a good amount of cash at the box office. Although, a decline in box office profits are reportedly the reason why there was no Saw 8. I don’t think Saw will be mentioned in the same breath as other famous horror franchises as time goes on. There are just too many bad films in this series, and the Saw franchise never did have that one great or very good film.

What do you think about the Saw franchise?
 
I love the Saw franchise. I looked foward to every movie coming out as they all entertained me to the max.

I loved the first Saw and kept wanting more after i saw it. Saw 2 came out and the twist at the end of that movie was great. Saw 3 was pretty good as well, but Saw 4 was kind of a let down. I liked it but didn't really live up to the standards i had hoped. I actually enjoyed Saw 5 unlike most people, i thought the ending was really clever and the overall story wasn't bad.

Saw 6 may have been my favorite out of the series. I LOVED the story, how it actually tied in to what was going on in the world with the healthcare debate and everything. The traps were really clever and the twist was awesome. Saw 7 was a bit of a letdown though. I don't know why i loved the movie, but i felt something was missing after it all, don't know what it is though.

All in all though, i love the Saw franchise as a whole.
 
This is worst Horror franchise of all time. I saw your ratings above, Mitch and the only one I actually ended up watching was the second film so I'm sure I'd hate the rest at least just as much. I am huge Horror buff and I can't condone films that fall under "Action-Horror" (like the last few Halloween movies) and "Gore" which is exactly what Saw was.

The series has a real thought out storyline, but I can't get over the fact when people hear that I'm a Horror fan they think I want to talk about my favorite traps in these movies. When I tell them I watch REAL Horror movies they ask what do I mean... Then when I start talking about a good film in this genre they lose interest when I'd rather talk about a scary, thought provoking chase scene in a good Slasher instead of some over the top bloodbath that was the Saw films that remind of a horrific spotfest in Wrestling.

I can rant and rave about this all day... I am going to stop for now though. I'm sure somebody will respond to this defending it to the bitter end.
 
I agree with your ratings a lot. After the 3rd one it just became overkill. These movies are only there so that people have something to go see on halloween. I hope they are over soon, I think they are running out of ways to kill people. Its not even gross or horror anymore, its just same old shit time and time again. Its pretty much impossible to make a good horror flick nowadays though. I just feel they stretched this franchise far too long.
 
As far as I'm concerned this is the order of Saw films from best to worst:

Saw
Saw II
Saw III
Saw 4
Saw 7 (3D)
Saw 6
Saw 5

Five and six are really the only ones in the franchise I'd consider utter shit. Everything else ranged from mediocre but enjoyable, to brilliant in the case of the first two films.

No one can deny the genius of the first film, it's one of the best horror films of the last decade and easily the best film in the franchise. Forget for a second how we've been pummeled into the ground with a new Saw film every October, each seemingly declining in quality. Forget about the endless rip-offs and the entire torture-porn subgenre that's emerged from Saw's influence, and just judge the film by itself solely on it's own merits, and it's one of the most original horror films in years. I feel honored to have seen the film on the film festival circuit before it even got picked up for national release and became a sleeper box-office smash that no one saw coming. In hindsight people shit on it, but it's importance and creativity cannot be questioned.

Saw 5 is definitely the worst. Even by the low standards of the later sequels in the franchise, this is by far the worst of them all.

I actually thought the latest film wasn't bad though, the 3D one. More convoluted backstory and terrible acting, sure, but the traps were actually creative for the first time in several films and featured some of the best kills in the history of the franchise.

I sincerely hope they give the franchise a few years to rest though, they desperately need to because rushing each film into theaters every October has had an obvious effect on their quality.
 
The first one was awesome, i thought the 2nd one sucked balls, 3 was fine up until the last 15 minutes where it was just BAM new plot twist, BAM new plot twist, BAM new plot twist over and over again continuously. 4 was pretty much the same as 1, where the whole idea is to try and work out who Jigsaw's second accompliss is, without ever seeing the guy, to the point where they even invented Art Blank up as a substitiute for Zep, as the 'Red Herring' character.

Then 5 seemed to be a LOT like 2 again, where the majority of it consists of a group of people getting each other killed as a result of their own idiocy, except there was no classic dialogue between 'Jigsaw 2.0' and the 'Authority' figure like there was in 2.

These are examples of the stupidity of the 'vicitms' in 2 and 5

SAW II:

"The note says 'Don't use the key in the lock'
"Fuck that!"
Key turns in the lock, and BANG, dead.

SAW V:

"The tape said, 'Don't all run to the jars at once"
"Fuck that!"
So they all run at once and SLICE, chick gets decapitated.

And that's where i stopped watching. By that point i'd had enough. After watching Strahm follow the 'step by step guide to getting yourself killed in a SAW film' when he's supposed to be like, THE biggest threat to the whole operation, i lost all interest. I knew it'd become more random morons getting killed, Hoffman running around avoiding capture, and more flashbacks to justify Jill Tuck actually being a character.

And then i find out that the friggin' doctor from SAW I comes back and is in on the whole thing i was definitely not going to continue with this franchise.

I mean, how fucked up do you have to be to actually buy into Jigsaw's shpeal?

Amanda survives a 'test' and decides to join in on the action, while totally disregarding the point of it all.

Hoffman decided to emulate Jigsaw in order to avenge his sister, but then despite being a cop, decides to sign up to the whole endeavour of being juge, jury and executioner, JUST because he and Jigsaw have a conversation.

And now Lawrence Gordon signs up after having his family held at gun point, and having all of his dirty secrets exposed to anyone who happens to look, and then sawing his own leg off! What could Jigsaw have possibly have said to HIM, in order to convince him to join in?

I suppose in SAW 8, a little old granny will be the next apprentice, because Jigsaw helped her across the street once as he was coming out of the cancer ward or some shit.

Anyway, i thought that SAW I was a truly great film. I was sucked in from the start, impressed with how well it was produced on such a low budget, loved Billy the talking puppet (i have a weird thing about 'living dolls', probably stems from reading too much Batman), and was blown away by the corpse in the centre of the room getting up and being revealed as the villain!

But then, as so many of these franchises tend to, it just got progressively worse and worse. I went from seeing them in the cinema every year, to simply watching them online, to not giving a fuck anymore over the series 7 movie lifespan.
 
Yeah, I'm with you on the grandiose and macabre sense of humility this SAW first presented when we saw the first one. I was in the theater like :wtf: is this?! I was a mix of shock and awe. I was amazed by this. Then the 2nd one came around, and Donnie Wahlberg was amazing in his internal struggle against Jigsaw. Tobin Bell was the perfect person to play this villain. I mean, you almost were cheering for him, even though you knew these people were suffering horrible tests. But then, as each series chapter was presented, 3rd, 4th, then 5th...I was starting to get a little more "Huh...?" The plot would get even more jumpy, and seem to find the slightest loopholes and exploit that to the Nth degree, just to get as much juice and gore as possible. Then I broke down and finally checked out Saw 6 on dvd, I figured, it was in the 99 cent pile. It wasn't as bad as the previous ones, I liked the moral play behind it, the life insurance person, having to go through this moral maze, of life or death at each corner, realizing that he was a VERY integral part of many of the atrocities, and that everyone in life is an integral part of a grand plan whether they intend to be or not. I mean, sure it was gory, and that is the main plan, but I liked the deeper meaning underlying in the sub-plot. However, now I do still want to see the Saw 3D, I was a HUGE fan of the Cary Elwes character and how it was just left hanging after he supposedly sawed off his foot, we never knew what happened to his family? So I'm looking forward to finishing up this chapter.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
174,851
Messages
3,300,884
Members
21,726
Latest member
chrisxenforo
Back
Top