Please tell me what match up from the year of 2009 thus far has been better than 'Taker/HBK at WM 25. I don't consider it the best Mania match ever but it was certainly the best in the past few years and it was something to behold.
Well, it depends what you are looking for. If it was for the electricity in the arena when the match took place, it was the best one since Rock faced Hogan. That match was made to feel like the greatest match ever as it got you involved, like HBK 'Taker.
However, if you forget the crowd and the PPV, the best matches, for me, were easily the Mysterio/Jericho series. Those matches were non stop action with great chemistry. HBK.'Taker was move, rest, kip up to make the crowd pop, repeated over and over. It was a 40 odd minute match with about 20 minutes worth of action. Yes, they are old and need the rests, but they were overdone for some people.
Back on topic, no, they should not face off again. It was a special event at WrestleMania, but they only got away with the inactivity in the match because of who it was and where it was at.
They should both finish off their careers by putting over talent, not facing each other.