I maybe missing the point of the thread, and if I am I apologize, but with that said from the way I understand it I got to disagree completely. I attended 23 and even I have to admit that I thought it wasn't very good. And even the fact that I was attending it I wasn't looking forward to it that much leading up to it.
For one, it was lacking star power. HHH was injured, Mysterio was injured, Jericho was on hiatus, and Angle left the WWE earlier in the year. Flair was in a dark match and some of the remaining big name guys in the company were wasted in the MITB match. LIke Booker T, Edge(who only wrestled like half that match anyway), Orton and Jeff Hardy.
So besides that, I hated the match order. At that time MITB was still a big deal, and people looked forward to it. I thought they sucked the energy out of the air by having it lead off the show. The crowd was already hyped to begin with, so I felt that a match like Benoit and MVP would've been a better opener.
I did like the two championship matches, and I love the stage and entrance way but other than that I didn't like the card at all.