Haven't played FIFA since 15.
I have WWE 2K17, it's my first WWE game since WWE 13. It's not horrible, I enjoy it I guess. I've heard that it's a step down from last year in the sense that there's a lot more room for error and glitches seem to be happening all the time. I haven't run into a major glitch yet but right now my save file is apparently corrupted and I'm not entirely sure how to fix it.
I really wish they'd re-introduce a story mode though. My Career is cool but it doesn't really cut it for me, at least make it like NBA 2K's My Career where you actually have cut scenes and storylines. It seems asinine that they'd have that for a basketball game and not a wrestling game. I get that 2K kind of has that now but there's really no fluid story. Also, I have no idea how commentary has gotten so much worse. I remember back in SVR 09 where the commentators would actually talk about the storyline that was happening in Road to WrestleMania, and that was almost a decade ago. It's laughably bad.