What the hell to say about England v Germany? I suppose aside from the god awful defending there were some issues that go back and can be applied to Englands whole campaign:
1) Predictable attacking. Use of wings when Rooney/Defoe wont really trouble defenders with crosses, Heskey would but never be in danger of scoring and the wingers were mostly either not on the wings (Gerrard) or not on their natural side to be able to hit a good 1st time ball. We had overlapping full backs, or attempts to overlap but that was so obvious that it was easy to defend against and also a clear weakness for counter attacks (re: Germanys 4th goal).
2) Rooneys lack of discipline was also a problem. It was well documented that Capello made Rooney play in the final third because that is where he can score from. This worked a treat and Rooney was banging them in and adopted this approach in his club games as well. However, due to lack of service for him he was dropping deep and going to the left side. This meant he was easily closed down and it was also easy to defend because he has to shift onto his right foot, which defenders made difficult for him to do, and then had to play it back and maybe try a crossfield pass to Milner. Today these didnt come off.
3) Players out of position. Gerrard on the left cant influence games the way he normally would when he is out on the left. He is too isolated, and the midfield battle is won in the middle. Gerrard comes in, meaning more work for Cole and a congested midfield.
4) We clearly did not have our best line up going into the competition, which is essential for any success. Sometimes you have to adapt to games/situations. Today i didnt feel like we had the set up to beat the Germans, we had the players and the talent but none of it showed.
5) The use of Gareth Barry as a holding midfielder does not work. At Liverpool, we had Mascherano and Alonso as holding midfielders. This can be seen as negative, but Mascherano was the tenacious ball winner, then he made a simple pass, mainly to Alonso who was a ball playing midfielder, and he would set up attacks. Barry has too much to do in trying to break up the attack, protect the back 4, win the ball and set up the attack. Against better opposition this gets exposed, and Ozil today did exactly that.
6) Gerrard is the focal point of the Liverpool team. Lampard is the focal point of the chelsea team. Rooney is the focal point of the United team. Even Barry is the guy who all of Citys play goes through. The problem we have is that they cant all be the focal point of the England team, but they all try to be. They are too individual. Lampard needs to be dropped so Gerrard can play in the middle, or even play Gerrard behind Rooney. The Spain side pick the best team, not best selection of individual talent.
Other points to be made are:
The German keeper came for balls with his eyes closed, it is unbelievable we did not attack this more and force errors.
The Lampard goal that was disallowed is something that FIFA need to address but is in no way an excuse for the ineptitude shown today. It would have made the score 2-2, but with the way we were defending it is likely that we would have conceded more. If they players couldnt move on from the fact that it was disallowed and felt that hard done by then they need their mental strength examining.
Our defending was abysmal. The players got pulled out of position so much. What happened to a rigid back 4, defending in a line and holding positions? There was no organisation in it. Upson was shaky and didnt seem up to it. Terry, Johnson and Cole seemed like they were scared of the German attack with its pace and incisiveness. They were always 3 steps behind. James should have attempted to organise them more. But there were some things, like Podolskis 2nd which i cant explain. Johnson came right across to defend the possible ball in to him, rather than hold his position, which had he done, Podolski would not have had such an easy goal. When defenders went forward nobody came to fill in for them either, this was exposed for the 4th.
The wrong subsitutions were made. We needed pace against the German defenders who couldnt handle being ran at, this meant Lennon, we also needed someone to give the goal keeper a hard time, meaning Crouch, who could also be a danger to score. Instead we had Heskey and Joe Cole.