What I mean do you think he would stay in the mainevent or drop to upper mid card level and challenge for the united states chamionnship again. I think most definetly he would be at the lowest a 3 time world champion by now including the 1 he already had. So do you think he would be a upper mid carder with a few more united states championships to his name or do you think he would be a true main eventer with multiple world championioship to his name.
Touchy subject. Most people tend to turn this into a "CHRIS BENOIT IS A MONSTER" whenever they see legit discussion about him. But... back on topic.
Benoit, along with Malenko both hold warm spots in my heart because of their fantastic wrestling styles. Sure, neither men had the charisma, but they had the stones and the abilities.
From what I remember, Benoit was slated to win the ECW Championship the night the murders happened, so that was obviously in the books for him to be a champ there.
What I think is Benoit was being groomed to be an agent for the young guys in ECW and Smackdown roster, so eventually they would have turned him down quite a bit to phase him out and do that part time routine like Malenko used to before he took on the 100% Road Agent role.
In Today's WWE, the only guy Benoit would have a good feud with is Shawn Michaels and maybe Triple H Again. Maybe even possibly part of Orton's punting angle, but otherwise I couldn't have seen Benoit hold the title for anything longer than a night as a transitional champion to get over the next guy in line, or whoever he was feuding with that had the title.
However, if they kept him in the upper mid-card in the US Division, he could've brought some major credibility back to that belt (Yes, the titles are props and credibility is out the window, but who cares, we're fans, right?) and have it as well known of a name as the IC Belt has for over 30 years. Benoit would have done a great job in that; the US Belt lost all credibility when Cena turned it into a spinner and JBL "Blew it up" in the garbage can on Smackdown.
So to directly answer the question, MAYBE only one World/WWE Title run left that would have been transitional, and a solid run with the US Belt before being phased out.