Which Actor/Actress Has Had The Biggest Fall From Grace Since Burt Reynolds?

Cena's Little Helper

Mid-Card Championship Winner
I've had this idea for quite some time but I've had no clue how to title it or whom should be included. Many people nowadays think of Burt Reynolds as a veteran actor who earned an Academy Award nomination for Boogie Nights, but this is only half of the story. It can quite easily be argued that Burt Reynolds was the biggest movie star of the 1970s. He had major hits with Deliverance and Smokey and the Bandit and was also offered the part of Han Solo in Star Wars. We don't think of Burt Reynolds as a star today because of how disastrous the 80s were for him (look at his imdb or wiki page to see all of the craptastic films he made during that decade).

Burt Reynolds was once the poster child for status decline in Hollywood but, over the past 10 or so years, there have been a handful of actors and actresses that could give Reynolds a run for his money. I'm going to go over a few here but please feel free to chime in on those whom you feel I have left out.

Harrison Ford: In my opinion, Harrison Ford has had a fall from grace that is even bigger than the one suffered by Burt Reynolds. Ranked in 1997 by Empire Magazine as the biggest film star of all time, Ford has since starred in 12 films. Of those 12 films, only 3 have made over $100 million domestically (and Cowboys and Aliens shouldn't even count since it barely made it over this threshold and couldn't recoup its $163 million budget through domestic receipts alone). Once thought immune to empty-box office syndrome, Ford can now be seen in 42, a trite, tiresome, and by-the-book biopic of Jackie Robinson whose screenplay he would have scoffed at only ten years ago.

Tom Cruise: Internationally there's probably no star bigger than Tom Cruise. That being said, he's nowhere near the American box-office draw he was through the mid-80s up until 2005's War of the Worlds. I only include him here because of his recent fall-off but he's still a bankable star and may totally redeem his career if Oblivion does well domestically.

Mel Gibson: I'm loathe to put Mel Gibson on here because, a) I like him, and b) poor personal choices rather than poor business choices have ruined his career. Without wishing for his wife to get fucked by a pack of you-know-whats, I think Gibson would still be a major player in Hollywood.

Russell Crowe: Another man ruined by poor personal choices, except I've always hated Russell Crowe as an actor. No one seemed to be on the rise to super-stardom faster than this man in the early 00s, but his attitude fucked that all up for him.

Arnold Schwarzenegger: His successful gubernatorial campaign saved him from irrelevancy but it looks like he'll be headed there after his next one or two films inevitably flop like The Last Stand did.

John Travolta: One of the biggest movie stars of the late 70s/early 80s who floundered and then became the biggest movie star of the mid- to late-90s. Travolta ain't nowhere near the draw he once was, but if he pulls off another renaissance, don't be surprised.

Kevin Costner: It's hard to believe that this everyman was once a huge movie star. Too bad he fucked up his career with Waterworld and The Postman.

Nicolas Cage: How can a man star in like 10 movies a year but still go bankrupt? More than anything else, Cage ruined his career through overexposure.

Jim Carrey: A man who once earned $20 million per movie. He should've worried about evolving comedically rather than having aspirations to being a serious actor. Now people think he's a shitty actor AND a stale comedian.

Julia Roberts: Besides Eat, Pray, Love, this woman hasn't had a box-office hit in which she received top-billing since 2000.

Obviously, I choose Harrison Ford for the reasons I listed above. After him, I'd go with a tie between Jim Carrey and Kevin Costner.
 
I'd probably go with Eddie Murphy. He was the king with Beverly Hills Cop 1 and 2, 48 hours, Coming to America, Golden Child. I mean he's had success with the Nutty Professor films and Shrek was a decent franchise but after the 1st 2 movies was the series as good ? Honestly ? WTF happened to this giant of Hollywood ?

Pluto Nash, Another 48 hours, Beverly Hills Cop 3, Distingusihed Gentleman, Daddy Day Care, those films sucked the life out of theatre goers and owners.

He makes films that are for kids that just aren't that interesting to watch for any one- kids included. Come on Murphy, go back to the adult theme films that people love you for.
 
Halle Berry- Personally, I've never been a fan of Berry's career. I honestly can't stand any of her shitty comedies from the 90's, and her more serious efforts weren't anything to remember (i.e. The Rich Man's Wife). BUT you could never deny Berry's popularity and her status as a sex symbol.

Then everyone fell in love with the overrated and bland Monster's Ball, and of course Berry won the Oscar for Best Actress. Die Another Day is probably the worst Bond film I've ever seen, she was lucky enough to still be apart of the cast for X2, I actually thought Gothika was decent enough.....and then she starred in Catwoman. Everything was down hill after that (including the lukewarm reception for X3, but I guess you can blame that on Brett Ratner). Of course, Berry almost bounced back with one of the more noteworthy characters and performances in Cloud Atlas, but she fucked up that momentum with a part in Movie 43. Plus, Berry's troubles as a psychopathic and bitter ex in real life put a big dent in her overall reputation.

Hilary Swank- Considering Swank's downfall, it pains me to watch Million Dollar Baby sometimes. Personally, I think Swank gave the better Oscar winning performance in Million Dollar Baby (the scene in the hospital, where she refuses to sign over all of her assets to her money grubbing mother and family, with the pen in her mouth....just amazing), but she's fantastic in Boys Don't Cry also. Anyway, after the second Oscar, wow. She just hit a tailspin. I didn't mind The Black Dahlia, but the critics panned the shit of it. She almost had a resurgence with Freedom Writers, but she hit more brick walls along the way, including The Resident. Initially, a VERY limited theatrical release for The Resident, and then it was buried with a straight-to-video release shortly after that. A two-time Oscar winner receiving a straight-to-video release. If that's not rock bottom, then I don't know what is. Oh, yeah, and she took a part in New Year's Eve, one of the sappiest and shittiest romantic comedies I've ever seen.

I'm tempted to throw Charlize Theron in here, but I'm not going to do it. She proved she's more than a one-trick-pony with North Country, and I guess I'm in the group of ten people, who actually liked Aeon Flux (being biased, I know). Theron hit a little rough patch (fucking Sleepwalking, ugh), BUT she bounced back recently. Her performance in Young Adult was Oscar worthy, you could make an argument for Theron delivering the best performance in Prometheus, and she made Snow White & The Huntsman watchable, saving the movie from Kristen Stewart's lifeless, dull, and talentless clutches.
 
I'm going to nominate someone who never reached great heights in terms of awards, but definitely popularity. And how far he's fallen is noteworthy. (Plus some of my other choices were taken)

Val Kilmer:

He came out of the gate fast with Top Gun. Then he became very popular in the early 90's (to include a great character in Doc Holliday). His popularity alone is the reason he was cast as Batman in Batman Forever. That's the same reason Jim Carrey was cast as The Riddler. Heat was another good movie. And from there he started to fall off. He was nominated for Razzies mostly beyond that point. Searching back on imdb, I had to go to the year 2000 (Red Planet) to find a movie I knew he was in. Pretty much for the last several years or so he's been making straight to DVD movies. Not to mention how awful he looks compared to his old days.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TLC
Erm, y'all afraid of mentioning the Sainted ones? Robert DeNiro and Al Pacino have been churning out shit movies for years now and it can't be just put down to there being no quality films out there - Jack Nicholson is still able to put in a good performance, Jeff Bridges is actually making going from strength to strength and Clint Eastwood gets glowing reviews on the now occasional occasions he steps in front of the camera. The debate used to be which of the two was the greatest ever; with each new bit of cinematic tosh they churn out now they lose more and more ground to the likes of Daniel Day Lewis and Sean Penn.
 
Jim Carrey: A man who once earned $20 million per movie. He should've worried about evolving comedically rather than having aspirations to being a serious actor. Now people think he's a shitty actor AND a stale comedian.

I thought about this thread, when I came across this article on Yahoo a while ago:

"Dumb and Dumber To" has been kicked to the curb, making for the latest blow to Jim Carrey's career.

Warner Bros.' decision to pass on the "Dumb and Dumber" sequel comes hot on the heels of the box office failure of "The Incredible Burt Wonderstone," a film that had a similar budget but grossed only $22 million domestically. Carrey received good reviews for his portrayal of a Criss Angel-like street magician but the film failed to connect with audiences.

Writer-directors Peter and Bobby Farrelly will have to look elsewhere in continuing the misadventures of Harry Dunne (Jeff Daniels) and Lloyd Christmas (Jim Carrey), as The Hollywood Reporter brings word that WB passed on giving the greenlight to "Dumb and Dumber To," the long in-development sequel to the 1994 hit comedy.

'Dumb and Dumber''Dumb and Dumber' (Photo: Everett)Warner Bros. apparently saw limited potential in the sequel (admittedly, it has been almost 20 years since the first film), even though the budget was pitched to be around $30 million. The writer-director sibling duo are shopping the project out to other studios, which finds Harry and Lloyd hitting the road in search of Harry's illegitimate daughter ... and completely ignores the much-reviled 2003 prequel, "Dumb & Dumberer: When Harry Met Lloyd."

Carrey, a box office powerhouse who could command $20 million per film back in the '90s and early '00s, has been having a rough time of it lately. His last starring vehicle was "Mr. Popper's Penguins," which was released two years ago this month and only earned $68 million domestic on a budget of $55 million. Despite the fact that he's always an engaging performer and also does well in edgier projects such as "I Love You Phillip Morris" (2008) and "Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind" (2004), Carrey just doesn't have the mainstream appeal that he used to.

The 51-year-old actor will next be seen in a supporting role as mobster turned vigilante Colonel Stars and Stripes in "Kick-Ass 2," opening August 16. He is also set to star alongside Owen Wilson in a yet-to-be-titled bank heist comedy.

Meanwhile, Carrey's "Dumb and Dumber" pal Jeff Daniels is gearing up for Season Two of "The Newsroom," which premieres on HBO on July 14.

http://movies.yahoo.com/blogs/movie...cked-shins-dumb-dumber-fumbles-164942151.html

Kind of sad how Jim Carrey is floundering around, having to lean on the hopes of a freakin' Dumb & Dumber sequel by the outdated and unfunny Farrelly brothers for a chance at a comeback. Damn shame The Incredible Burt Wonderstone had to be such a flop, but Carrey can't avoid the heat for that, because he was a major selling point in the trailers, TV spots, and other forms of advertisement.
 
I thought about this thread, when I came across this article on Yahoo a while ago:

http://movies.yahoo.com/blogs/movie...cked-shins-dumb-dumber-fumbles-164942151.html

Kind of sad how Jim Carrey is floundering around, having to lean on the hopes of a freakin' Dumb & Dumber sequel by the outdated and unfunny Farrelly brothers for a chance at a comeback. Damn shame The Incredible Burt Wonderstone had to be such a flop, but Carrey can't avoid the heat for that, because he was a major selling point in the trailers, TV spots, and other forms of advertisement.

The thing is, Carrey has a major role in Kick Ass 2 which could very easily have him straight back to the top of the tree and D&D2 green lit in a flash... plus, there is a strong possibility that (as you've pointed out yourself) that the Farrelly brothers fall from grace is the real reason behind the current failing, especially if the plot that they've written sucks.

His last film may have flopped but the one prior to that (Mr Popper's Penguins) returned over 300% of it's cost - a major success in the eyes of 20th Century Fox, especially considering that it was going up against some pretty big hitters.

On top of Kick Ass 2, Carrey is also to appear in the much anticipated Anchorman 2 and has two other irons in the fire for 2014. Like him or loath him (I can do both, sometimes in the same movie) but I think Mr Carrey is still incredibly in the public consciousness.
 
The thing is, Carrey has a major role in Kick Ass 2 which could very easily have him straight back to the top of the tree and D&D2 green lit in a flash... plus, there is a strong possibility that (as you've pointed out yourself) that the Farrelly brothers fall from grace is the real reason behind the current failing, especially if the plot that they've written sucks.

His last film may have flopped but the one prior to that (Mr Popper's Penguins) returned over 300% of it's cost - a major success in the eyes of 20th Century Fox, especially considering that it was going up against some pretty big hitters.

On top of Kick Ass 2, Carrey is also to appear in the much anticipated Anchorman 2 and has two other irons in the fire for 2014. Like him or loath him (I can do both, sometimes in the same movie) but I think Mr Carrey is still incredibly in the public consciousness.

Forgot about Kick-Ass 2. From looking at the trailers, I guess it's possible Carrey could be the breakout star in that film. After all, Chloe Grace Moretz and Nicolas Cage were the highlights of the original film, not the leading man and title character. And I didn't know about Anchorman 2. I'm guessing it's going to be a cameo appearance, because I haven't heard anything about a major role for Carrey in the sequel. Still, cameo or not, Carrey could use the rub from a high profiled sequel like Anchorman 2.
 
Cuba Gooding Jr. is one that comes to mind. After winning the Oscar for his supporting role in Jerry McGuire he kind of went away for a while. He would occasionally make a movie, but it was nothing compared to what I expected form an Oscar winner. He still seems to make movies, but it is few and far between where that move gets any attention. He did Red Tails a year or two ago and I thought it was ok. He just never lived up to all the hype from Jerry McGuire.
 
I was a big fan of Cuba Gooding Jr., then he just started putting out so much trash year after year. There was that awful comedy with Roselyn Sanchez and his buddy sneaking aboard a cruise ship, and Gooding Jr. joined the Will Smith and Sean Penn ranks of shameful attempts to win an Oscar with Radio (comparing Radio to Smith starring in Seven Pounds and Penn doing I Am Sam). Although, It was kind predictable and corny most of the time, but I did enjoy Men Of Honor with Robert De Niro.
 
I think collectively there is a shout for the whole cast of Friends but Courtney Cox in particular went from A list with the Scream movies to recognised turd territory like 3000 Miles To Graceland (The final nail in Costner's career till he redeemed himself a bit as Jonathan Kent).

Wesley Snipes is a contender, arguably due to business choices, but he was doing DTV before he was doing time despite the Blade movies doing big.

The winner for me is Sean Connery, he went from being 007 to the go to "gritty" actor in the 70's and Triple A List/ Oscar winner in the 80's... Then he seemed to do some popcorn/thriller stuff before his Two turkeys ruined him... Avengers was bad but Leauge Of Extraordinary Gentlemen was painful... He's barely made a movie since and become a recluse and is the forgotten man now guys like Ian McKellen and Patrick Stewart have taken his place and even Daniel Craig is now THE Bond.
 
I am going to disagree about Harrison Ford, for the simple reason that his career isn't nearly over yet. He has a few potential blockbusters in the pipeline. Ender's Game has the ability to become a huge smash hit, and of course though it will be a smaller role, you do realize he is going to be Han Solo at least one more time, right? He may also play Indiana Jones for one more time. Yeah, Kingdom of the Crystal Skull was shit, but everyone went to see it anyway. If box office draw is the key, Ford isn't quite done yet.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
174,846
Messages
3,300,834
Members
21,727
Latest member
alvarosamaniego
Back
Top