- If I want to read an RP, it HAS to be formated. A non formated RP can still be readable, but I massivly hate them. Most people here do this anyways, but to he few that don't, please start lol.
For purpose sake, I'm going to take some of the things people have said, and go from there. I will add my own opinions at the end as well, but for now a lot of people have already touched on things I agree and disagree with. So then..
For this specific quote, I can't agree more. What's the point of RPing if you aren't even going to take the small amount of time to add a bit of color and formatting to it? All black text blurs long RPs together as one big mess.
While formatting is not (to my knowledge) a requirement, I personally think it should be. It's not hard to do, and if it is, then how you got into being in an e-fed is beyond me.
- This is a big one, and it don't even apply here, but I'll post it anyways, justin ase it does someday. But in my other feds, people give their charecters "girlfriends" and shit, and never make them do anything other then perform sexual acts in the middle of an RP, or are literally just their to reply with "I love you" to their man. It sickens me. I guess the point I'm making, is if your going to have a managar, girlfriend, what-have-you, give them a charecter as well, in stead of just being there to make you look better.
I generally agree and disagree with this. If you add a girlfriend/manager throughout several of your Rps, then yes.. make then a fucking character profile. Just notify a staff member to add it on. (ie. Gus had Heidi, D.C. had Lindsey. It's not hard to create a small profile for them)
However, if you're merely using them in a one-off/spin-off (ie. My Rp for Redemption, involving my Wife.) She isn't a regular character I'll be using at this time, so no need for a profile.
The bottomline, if you're going to be using a character in more than one, or better yet several, of your Rps.
IT MUST have a character profile.
- Attacking non charecters. We write RPs to determine how tough we are, and how we will do in a match. When you write your RP to include you attacking someone, just for the sake of lookin tough, it don't make you look tough, it makes you seem like your trying to hard. Try to keep this one to a minimum.
Again, I half and half (agree and disagree) with this post.
While it's actually against
this e-fed's rules to violently beat-up one of our character-mods (ie. Other Wrestlers, the Announcers, Interviewers, GMs, etc.) unless you have permission from a staff member.
It's not completely out of the question to add it in. Attitude in some cases is the key to RPing. If your character is a heel, then you'll naturally be aggressive, prick-like, and even possibly attempting at being violent toward those in your Rp.
It's not needed to beat up on them. It doesn't win you anything, and in some cases it's very much overkill. The objective of an Rp should be to define your own character. By definition, you likely don't wanna just be seen as a bully who gets off by beating up defenseless interviewers, right?
- Using your opponents RP to your advantage. This came up a few weeks ago here with my feedback for someone else. It's not a matter of waiting till the last day, or RPing after your opponent. It's waiting till after your opponnt so that you can use what they say against them. Example, a few weeks ago when I was against Manzo, my first RP had me leaving the arena, and Iscy used that in hi RP for his own advantage. Thats an example. I think the most fair RPs are ones you can think of entirely withut using the RP thats ment to beat you as leverage.
I greatly disagree to this post. While I don't believe I've actually ever had to use my opponent's RP against them. It's not out of line to do. Low and dishonorable, sure. But in violation of rules or policy, no.
While I WOULD say don't be a dick and wait until the absolute last minute because you think it gives you an advantage, some people have but no choice. (ie. I doubt Everest waits last minute intentionally)
Just like acting tough, using an opponent's RP against them is NOT going to win you anything. It's all in how you write your own RPs. I'm not going to give someone credit, for more or less "piggy-backing" someone else's material. Yet if that's what you feel you need to do, to get a point across.. then so be it.
- Writing last minute RPs. It simply bugs me. Wether it's literally whipping something up last second, or having it done and not posting it till near the deadline, although there is nothing actually wrong with it, it just bugs me.
While this is a personal issue with Derf.. I don't care about it in general. You have a deadline. As far as I'm concerned, whether you post the instant the board is up, or 1 second until the deadline expires.. it's your decision.
The
ONLY issue seperate yet connected to this that I'd have, is too many people carelessly slap stuff together just because they allowed time to get away from them. I won't name names, but a couple current e-fed members do this on a regular basis because they want to be here, yet they don't apparently feel they need to put any effort into trying.
- RP Length. I don't think an RP can be to long, as long as it's got enoughto make it a good RP in it. Short RPs can also be very good, but when as RP is so short that the entire thing fits on my moniter at one time, thats when it's to short, and it needs to definatly be worked on.
This is the biggest issue I have. Length is a prime issue in RPing, regardless of the size. Too big and you risk losing the attention of the reader. Too small and you risk not giving enough information and leave people wanting more, yet never getting it.
While Derf may not agree that an RP that fits the monitor is doable.. I disagree with that, and believe that if the damn thing is merely 1-2 paragraphs long, as long as it's effective enough.. it's workable.
Meanwhile, longer Rps actually annoy me more.
lmao: Pot/Kettle much?) Especially because it's my unofficial "job" to read them all and judge. I can't tell you how many times I've gotten bored off my ass not even mid-way through, and lost interest with some.
There is a major difference to a long RP that's effective and leaves you on the edge of your seat.. compared to an Rp that's just long because the person was over-anal about too much attention to detail. (ie. surroundings, what people are wearing, how they're moving, acting, etc.)
Also I think that the RP should at least relate to the match in someway, for example if you're fighting Milenko, but are involved in a storyline with Ben Legend, talk about Legend if you want, but keep it on track to the fact that you're facing Milenko.
Fully agree. If you're RPing about eating at a restaurant, or blowing up a limo, or screwing some chic.. what the fuck?! Where's the storyline that's important in any of that?
If you're involved in a storyline with "Superstar A" yet you have a match with "Superstar B", then be sure to keep your feud going with "A" yet not to ignore the importance of the up-coming situation with "B". (ie. My feud w/ Rios, and the 6-man tag I had. I did two seperate Rps specifically to focus solely ON Rios, then a 2nd to focus on my seperate opponents)
The big no no is in ring RP's, we never get them here as I am sure it's against the rules, but do a backstage interview.
I'm going to say "in-ring" promos should actually be against the rules. I mean, the "timeline" in an RP needs to somewhat be realistic. And 9/10 times, your Rp would likely take place between Meltdown's. (ie. Weekly basis)
The only hard issue with trying to keep a realistic timeline is when cutting an RP for a Meltdown after a PPV, as your timeline is drastically cut short.
However, as it's been mentioned in the past.. not EVERY wrestler (known or not) gets in-ring promo time. If you were designed to get an in-ring promo, we'd PM you seperately and ask you to write one regarding whatever.
Backstage interviews are perfectly fine, and generally the solid backbone of an original RP. Parking lot interviews, lockerroom interviews, stuff like that is fine. But in-ring promos aren't. Mainly because YOU are giving yourself a misrepresentation of what you WANT the fans to think of you.. and that may not always be the case. (ie. I'm sure Cena doesn't
want boos in real life, but it happens)
And my last pet hate is this; NOT EVERYONE HAS THEIR OWN DRESSING ROOM FOR GOODNESS SAKE!!!
Fuck you, Mr. Super-Hero of an imaginary City. I have my own lockerroom, bitch! I'm the highest paid Superstar in W.Z.C.W.. I can afford it. Go re-read my original Profile application. Says so in it.
I used to find that I would prefer reading role-plays that were different. I never thought a lot of effort went into a roleplay where one person just talked about how they were going to beat up their opponent and then walked out, no matter the length.
I prefer when there's a story going on in the roleplay and it's not just someone saying something and then pacing up and down. Use of surroundings is also good. Think of it as if you were watching an actual monologue. Would you find it entertaining if it was someone just standing there saying things?
The roleplay should also be a mixture between building the character and their upcoming match. There's no rule saying it has to be about one or the other. Too many people (as I remember) just focused on saying things about their opponent, and gave little insight into their character.
Overall, individuality makes a good RP.
I love Spiral, and I'm not afraid to say it.
He tops off an amazing point.
While most RPs will take place in a backstage interview, or a common ground "interview setting", they don't have to. You can be as wild, carefree, and open as you wish to be. Individuality is a great key to success in some situations.
Ricky is a PRIME example of this. When I joined this e-fed, he instantly became one of my absolute favorite RPers because his imagination for his character is beyond limitless. Infact, I selfishly take some credit in helping to save his e-fed career in this e-fed, because neither Sincade or Rios (at that time) understood Ricky's imagination to be a good thing, so much as just confusing. Thus, they didn't know what to do with him, or how to use him in storylines.
The fact is, I
WISH (without actually wishing, that is) I could have a fraction of Ricky's Rping skills. I don't feel confident enough that I could take my character and use him the same way Ricky does with his. My biggest leap in that direction would be the RP I used for Redemption, where I had a "coma RP".
But stuff like that is out of the norm, and catches people's attention. Maybe not always for the best, and maybe people won't understand how to get what the Rp is saying, but they're still amazing to have.. simply if for no other reason than they're "standing out from the norm".
Personal Opinions: Basically I think I've covered a lot in replying to other people's stuff, but my personal belief is this..
Don't try to copy someone. Be yourself. If yourself is writing a long RP, or a short Rp.. do it. If yourself is plain and original in having a backstage interview, or wild and open in having a huge imagination.. do it. Don't try to be something, or someone you aren't though. It won't work.
The best thing about this e-fed to me, is the people and their individuality. Every one of you have positives and negatives. But that's what makes you, you. If I wanted to read 20 Rps all more or less saying the exact same thing.. I'd have quit a long time ago, because that would get old.. quickly.
Constructive criticism is a great tool, yet a dangerous weapon. Unfortunately not everyone has "thick skin" and can easily get offended. My best advice is to never take anything negative about your work, in a personal manner. Everyone is here to have fun and just enjoy this hobby. The only criticism that happens, is someone trying to give their opinion on how to possibly help you through their eyes. Nothing more, nothing less. You don't have to do it. It's just someone's opinion. And opinion's are always great to at least hear out.