The entire ending sequence to NXT Season 2 was just such a train wreck that it may have stopped several careers in their tracks. It started off with Kaval winning, which was about the only thing that went well here. After the announcement was made, runner-up Michael McGullicutty was handed the mic, and he cut a very narmy promo where trips over his lines. In that promo, he basically promises a Genesis of the career of Michael McGullicutty. Then he leaves the ring. Kaval tries to cut a celebration promo, but is cut off when the rookies eliminated in the previous weeks come in and attack him. The WWE Pros try to intervene, and we get what ends up being the very anti-thesis of what made The Nexus work. During the NXT Riot, everyone involved scored their own Crowning Moment Of Awesome. During the Genesis of McGullicutty, each rookie earns their own Dethroning Moment Of Suck.
- For starters, even the people in the nosebleeds could have heard the spots being called and the refs yelling instructions to the angry rookies.
- Titus O'Neill (who placed 8th for a reason) accidentally no-sells MVP Yakuza Kick in the corner, making everyone wonder why he was on NXT to begin with.
- Eli Cottonwood, who was already a joke after his "Mustache" promo, ends up going back to his home planet and is not standing tall in the ring when NXT goes off the air. Worse yet, at one point, Michael Cole ends up referring to him as "Aloisia". Aloisia is the 6'9 rookie who was slated to be on the Divas-only Season 3 of NXT.
- Lucky Cannon really could have Taken A Level In Bad Ass here, but the fact that he got most of the offense in this segment ended up bringing it down even further.
- Husky Harris did not look too bad in here (at least in comparison to everyone else), but there was one point in the brawl where he executed a Uranage on Kaval, while the WWE Pros who were supposed to be the Big Damn Heroes in this brawl were just watching, even though they could have stopped him. This made the Pros look completely incompetent.
- Speaking of the Pros, they just kind of left off-screen shortly after that, leaving Kaval to get decimated. The only ones that were seen on camera after that were Laycool, who at least look liked they cared as they watched Kaval get destroyed.
- Now we come to Percy Watson and Alex Riley. Riley and McGullicutty, the rookies that were eliminated that night, would eventually join in on the brawl. At one point, Riley would attack Watson and plant him with a Michinoku Driver, EVEN THOUGH THEY WERE ON THE SAME SIDE! It was at this point that this moment went from Wall Banger territory to So Bad It's Horrible. As the show was closing, Percy Watson would yell his OH YEAH! Catchphrase, which might as well have poured more Nightmare ******ant on the Genesis stable.
- Finally, we have the Genesis of Michael McGillicutty himself. Let's examine the last couple sentences of the promo that started this whole thing.
>>"See, I am the future of this company. I am going to be a big time player in this machine called WWE. I am the Next Big Thing. I am the Next Generation. And starting this moment...from now...from this moment on...this will be the moment...starting now...of the Genesis of MCGILLICUTTY."<<