First things first, right out of the gate, I want to wish the best to my opponent this week, Thunderball. He's been making quite a name for himself debating here the last 2 weeks, and it'll be fun to be face to face with him. Plus, I know I'll need to be on my "A" game, as he will not let me rest a moment until next week.
I fear, however, that his decision making isn't quite at 100% though. He was given the chance to select the topic of this week's debate, and rather than make the right choice, he gave the right choice to me. Maybe he just wants a challenge, which is fine by me. But the fact is,
Paul Wight, a.k.a. The Big Show, was significantly more in WCW than he was in WWE.
Sadly, we live in a world where younger fans and revisionist historians will over-weight Show's WWF/E career because of its recency and longevity, if you want to call an inconsistent career "longevitous." So despite being on the side of the debate that is obviously correct, I still face an uphill battle as I attempt the recreate how impressive Wight's WCW career was, and compare it to the virtual ski slope of ups and downs, bumps and valleys, that has marred his "decade of decency" in WWF.
Why Show's WCW Career was Remarkable
WCW knew the type of physical specimen they had with Wight. The men went through WCW's Power Plant and even hit moonsaults on a regular basis. He was a towering figure with the athleticism to do it all in the ring. Remarkably, he was also a great talker, capable of acting like the monster his size would denote.
So what happened with him? He was billed as the son of Andre the Giant and placed in a feud with some local kid by the same of Hulk Hogan. Say what you will about the sort of odd Monster Truck contest (and no, I am not going to attempt to win this debate by arguing that in WCW Wight was able to survive a fall off of a building - sillyness), Wight became the first man in wrestling history to actually win the World Heavyweight Championship in his in-ring debut. If a guy did that today, the fans would riot. The reason Wight could pull it off, however, was because people believed HE had Hogan's number. Despite winning the title via DQ, the belt was held up a week later, so he was 1-0, a former World Champion who had never lost the belt.
In the coming weeks, Wight and Flair beat Hogan and Savage in a tag team match before Wight took his first loss, at the hands of Hogan, which is nothing to be ashamed of.
Wight's 2nd World Title came after he beat another local guy named Richard Flair. Maybe it was Ric for short, I forget. Wait, wait...
Paul Wight's first two world title wins came against Hulk Hogan and Ric Flair!? Hmmm....
After some tussles with Hogan (Wight was always good enough to get in Hogan's way), Wight became one of the first men to truly challenge the nWo, along side Luger and Sting. He worked as a face just as effectively as he did a heel. Wight then feuded with Kevin Nash, who f'ed up a powerbomb and injured Wight. Wight wasn't injury prone in WCW, he just got stuck with idiots in the ring. He allowed his contract in WCW to expire shortly thereafter.
So, let's recap. Wight is a two-time WCW World Champion in less than 4 years with the company. His major feuds were with Hulk Hogan, Kevin Nash, and Goldberg. He won the WCW World Title in his debut match. He beat Hogan and Flair for his two world titles. He was among the great physical specimens in wrestling history for 4 years.
Why Show's WWF/E Career has been Lackluster at best...
Wight was given a strong start in WWF as well, debuting in a major Austin vs McMahon match (though costing McMahon the match itself) and acting as the McMahon stable bodyguard. He was a part of one of the most shortlived and least successful stables in wrestling history, The Union, before being chokeslammed through the mat by The Undertaker.
Eventually, Wight won his first WWF Title in a triple threat match he wasn't even originally in. He took Steve Austin's spot and took advantage of the HHH vs Rock feud to win the belt. During that title run, his ONE defense was defeating...wait for it...The Big Boss Man? Yes, folks, though Thunderball may try (unsuccessfully) to convince you otherwise, Wight's first WWF Title reign was possibly the most worthless in WWF History. Yokozuna's 128 second title reign at Wrestlemania 9 meant more. So did Khali's reign. Show's multi-faceted two months of crying a beating up on Ray Trailor still sits in a clearance bin at the gift shop at The International House of Suck. That's located in Decatur, for those who aren't familiar.
After Wight dropped this now disgraced title to Triple H, Wight was given a spot in the main event of Wrestlemania 2000. In this fatal four way elimination match, Wight was the first man eliminated. Shock. And how did he react to the loss? Refocused? Angry? Nope, he was fine with it, and went on a stretch where he embarassed himself by mimicking the gimmicks of other men who were bigger stars than he was.
The downward spiral continues. Wight's next big feud was with...Shane McMahon. The attitude era was moving on without him, and after another heel turn, Wight AGAIN became Undertaker's bitch, this time chokeslammed through a table and forced to OVW to lose weight and get in shape. The dominant athlete WCW had once made a cornerstone of their biggest run in history was now fat, out of shape, and in the minor leagues.
Show came back, and got tossed out of the Royal Rumble by The Rock. Nobody cared, so Show went for the Hardcore title, losing a match to Kane and Raven. He lost a Last Man Standing match to Shane McMahon and with Ric Flair as his partner (the same team that defeated Hogan and Savage in WCW), they lost to Austin in a handicap match. At this time, it was hard to tell if he was a heel or a face, though it's safe to say this was his 4th or 5th turn.
In Wight's most impressive WWF moment, Wight aligned with Paul Heyman to take the WWF Title off of Brock Lesnar. THAT reign lasted a grand total of 1 month before Show lost to Angle.
SO that's two WWF Title reigns, and two bits of worthless, transitional crap. He was the guy who Lesnar and Angle beat on to draw steam for their showdown at Wrestlemania. He subsequently went winless against Lesnar and was relegated to the US Title picture.
Wight was forced out for another 6 months during a feud with Kurt Angle, who helped Wight's fall from grace by downing him with a tranq gun and shaving his head. To make matters worse, Wight's Wrestlemania that year was a sumo match against Akebono, which he lost. Ouch.
His next two rivals were Carlito and Gene Snitsky. I won't elaborate as their is no need.
Rather than take you through the next year or so of ho-hum matches and useless feuds, as we all know, Wight wound up winning the WWE's third-tier promotion title, the ECW title, defeating Rob van Dam with Heyman's alignment AGAIN. Been done before, no? After a couple months with some decent matches, the now injury prone and again overweight Paul Wight was again sidelined for months on end. 2 years, really.
Wight returned, 150 pounds lighter, to an attack on Rey Mysterio that went nowhere. Show was eventually tagged to feud with...Floyd Mayweather. Really? Big Show AGAIN lost to a non-wrestler, AGAIN at Wrestlemania. Way to be, Paul. Yeah, the WWF stint was MUCH Better than being a dominant WCW figure in feuds with men like Hogan, Flair, Nash, and Goldberg. I'd rather fight non-wrestlers and guys like Gene Snitsky. [/sarcasm]
Wight's WWF/E run has been marred by an incomprehensible number of face and heel turns, impersonations of Rikishi, worthless title runs, and 2 hiatuses to lose weight. And THIS is the Big Show who was better than WCW's The Giant?
If you take ALL of Wight's best WWF moments (that's 10 years worth), it STILL doesn't hold a candle to what he did in less than 4 years with WCW.
And before you even say it...
"But Big Show is the first man to ever win the WWF, WCW, and ECW titles!"
His WWF runs were slop. At least his short initial run in WCW was significant. And his ECW title run was at a time when ECW was Vince's third tier promotion and he wanted the belt OFF of the ECW original. It was just a way to get the belt on Lashley.