So if you've watched TLC you'll know that Reigns returned at TLC to save Cena. I have always been one of Roman Reigns' detractors, I got very tired of his ~5 moves of doom and constantly winning matches, the superman treatment, if you will. However when he returned I simply could not help but mark out.
His return was handled very well (I almost think Big Show beat Rowan to make the return more effective) and he got a very very good reception (one of the loudest pops since perhaps Daniel Bryan). What I realised is that he most definitely has a special quality about him that makes him a unique superstar. His look is incredible and I must say he looked absolutely awesome storming through the crowd with that intense look in his eyes and his music in the background only complemented that. He has great "big" moves that can lift a crowd up at any moment and they're both moves that can be performed out of nowhere. It really did get me pumped after a lackluster PPV.
However with that being said, his return promo. I must say it was one of the worst I have ever seen. Okay he messed up on the "declare" bit (I cringed), but then when he stared at the camera it was almost as if he forgot his lines and that's when I couldn't bear it any longer and temporarily switched off (I watched it just now before making this thread and it isn't any better). I was recently defending his mic skills saying they were not that bad, but boy was I proved wrong. He lacks timing and emphasis, and most importantly of all he just needs to relax. His character is very intense so I somewhat understand what he's trying to do but it isn't working very well.
Now we clearly see that the WWE see him as the best thing since sliced bread and how reluctant the WWE universe are to accept this (even though casuals love him and even some smarks like myself could accept his push). My question is do you think he needs to be the Rock, Austin or Cena on the mic? Is it necessary for him to cut 20 minute promos every Monday night or could he simply be the champion that kicks ass and says few words? If he doesn't improve his mic skills is he doomed to fail? I personally think it's something you're natural at, you can improve how you cut promos but you certainly don't develop charisma.
I also think he can get by as a great main-event if he says few words and let his matches do the talking, there have been examples where this has been a recipe for success (Goldberg, Lesnar (albeit he has Heyman) and Ryback to an extent). You can certainly argue he has a much better look and character than all three of ones I mentioned. It worked for him fantastically well in the Shield where he was incredibly over and I think it could work for him as champion. There are many different types of champions. Three examples: there are champions who cut 20 minute promos with ease (CM Punk, John Cena, I'm sure you can think of more), and then you have the champions who you can fully believe would dominate the entire roster (Lesnar), and finally the ultimate underdog/someone you can really get behind in a big match (Cena, Bryan). I would place a WWE title holding Reigns in the last two categories, and that certainly isn't a recipe for disaster. Bryan in my opinion isn't the best on the mic or at cutting promos, yet he was told a story in the ring and was great at playing the underdog. Why is it difficult to believe Reigns could be a great champion despite the lack of mic skills? I don't find it too difficult to believe Reigns as a WWE World Heavyweight champion if he does it in his own way and I don't require him to behave like a Cena or a Punk for him to have a successful title reign.
I really want Reigns to succeed as I definitely see potential there, you must remember he is relatively young and has limited experience in the wrestling industry. I would hold off for the title run. I would have him enter a program with Rusev after the Royal Rumble (narrowly losing it to whoever else they have for Brock (which is another issue)). And then possibly a program with Rollins for the title leading up to Summerslam.
To summarise, I believe the conundrum is Reigns looks perfect for a superstar, has a great signature move set (move sets can always be developed), good intensity in the ring, but just sucks at cutting promos.
So now I've given my view, my questions to you are:
Do you think Reigns can make it right to the top despite the lack of charisma? (Keeping in mind he has other unique tools that other wrestlers would love to have.)
Is it vital for a WWE champion to have impeccable mic skills?
Who would you have Reigns enter the ring with at WM31?
Did his return do anything for you?
His return was handled very well (I almost think Big Show beat Rowan to make the return more effective) and he got a very very good reception (one of the loudest pops since perhaps Daniel Bryan). What I realised is that he most definitely has a special quality about him that makes him a unique superstar. His look is incredible and I must say he looked absolutely awesome storming through the crowd with that intense look in his eyes and his music in the background only complemented that. He has great "big" moves that can lift a crowd up at any moment and they're both moves that can be performed out of nowhere. It really did get me pumped after a lackluster PPV.
However with that being said, his return promo. I must say it was one of the worst I have ever seen. Okay he messed up on the "declare" bit (I cringed), but then when he stared at the camera it was almost as if he forgot his lines and that's when I couldn't bear it any longer and temporarily switched off (I watched it just now before making this thread and it isn't any better). I was recently defending his mic skills saying they were not that bad, but boy was I proved wrong. He lacks timing and emphasis, and most importantly of all he just needs to relax. His character is very intense so I somewhat understand what he's trying to do but it isn't working very well.
Now we clearly see that the WWE see him as the best thing since sliced bread and how reluctant the WWE universe are to accept this (even though casuals love him and even some smarks like myself could accept his push). My question is do you think he needs to be the Rock, Austin or Cena on the mic? Is it necessary for him to cut 20 minute promos every Monday night or could he simply be the champion that kicks ass and says few words? If he doesn't improve his mic skills is he doomed to fail? I personally think it's something you're natural at, you can improve how you cut promos but you certainly don't develop charisma.
I also think he can get by as a great main-event if he says few words and let his matches do the talking, there have been examples where this has been a recipe for success (Goldberg, Lesnar (albeit he has Heyman) and Ryback to an extent). You can certainly argue he has a much better look and character than all three of ones I mentioned. It worked for him fantastically well in the Shield where he was incredibly over and I think it could work for him as champion. There are many different types of champions. Three examples: there are champions who cut 20 minute promos with ease (CM Punk, John Cena, I'm sure you can think of more), and then you have the champions who you can fully believe would dominate the entire roster (Lesnar), and finally the ultimate underdog/someone you can really get behind in a big match (Cena, Bryan). I would place a WWE title holding Reigns in the last two categories, and that certainly isn't a recipe for disaster. Bryan in my opinion isn't the best on the mic or at cutting promos, yet he was told a story in the ring and was great at playing the underdog. Why is it difficult to believe Reigns could be a great champion despite the lack of mic skills? I don't find it too difficult to believe Reigns as a WWE World Heavyweight champion if he does it in his own way and I don't require him to behave like a Cena or a Punk for him to have a successful title reign.
I really want Reigns to succeed as I definitely see potential there, you must remember he is relatively young and has limited experience in the wrestling industry. I would hold off for the title run. I would have him enter a program with Rusev after the Royal Rumble (narrowly losing it to whoever else they have for Brock (which is another issue)). And then possibly a program with Rollins for the title leading up to Summerslam.
To summarise, I believe the conundrum is Reigns looks perfect for a superstar, has a great signature move set (move sets can always be developed), good intensity in the ring, but just sucks at cutting promos.
So now I've given my view, my questions to you are:
Do you think Reigns can make it right to the top despite the lack of charisma? (Keeping in mind he has other unique tools that other wrestlers would love to have.)
Is it vital for a WWE champion to have impeccable mic skills?
Who would you have Reigns enter the ring with at WM31?
Did his return do anything for you?