With all due respect, the comparison being made here is quite comparable to saying an i-pod is a significant upgrade and a cassette player. Duh. Not that I didn't mind Adamle much as GM, but really almost anyone would've been a significant upgrade over him. Now with the Adamle out of the way, we have Shane and Stephanie McMahon. Now Stephanie is in no way shape or form the i-pod, more like a CD Player kinda upgrade, good but with its own faults. Keeping aside the mild attraction that i have for her, I find here annoying, generally quite awful on camera, and with no real focused character, she is often all over the place. She has improved from the early billionaire princess phase and showed she can do an admirable job as GM, and she has shown to be a strong, confident women and is in charge of just about everything behind the scenes in WWE, but I think the focus of this discussion should be on the other person leading RAW, Shane.
Shane has been kept in the background in the WWE for quite some time now. Rumors have been made about Steph and Shane's backstage attitudes when it comes to business and it sounds like Steph has been trying to make sure Shane is far below her on the company ladder and that she will always have more control then him. Shane I've noticed always gets loud reactions whenever he makes an appearance. He has a real strong connection with the fans, something Steph probably wishes she had more of. Shane's endured himself to the fans through his hardcore and brutal matches and by frequently stepping up against his father, possibly the biggest heel ever, Vince. Shane seems way more confident and relaxed on the mic or in front of the camera than his sis. I look to Shane to be the future figure head of the on-camera product and not whiny shrieking Stephanie, and if were going to praise Stephanie for being a significant upgrade over Adamle, then we should really give Shane his equal justice as well.
So in closing, Shane and Stephanie equally better than Adamle. Now is it Shane that's an upgrade over Stephanie, or is Stephanie a better choice than Shane. Well, that's an argument for a different day.