ROH or TNA--Who shoould Vince buy

[The HEEL JuiceLee]

My question to you is say Vince finaly gets his WWE network going & he want's a bout 15-20 new wrestlers so he can show more wrestling matches without showing all the same fueds.

What roster do you think would be better for Vinny Mac to bring to the WWE
TNA or ROH?
ALSO: tell me why 1 roster would benifit the "E" better than the other?
And what advances for the "E" Some of the new roster member's could bring to the "E"

 

[CelticCorey]

He should buy neither. Vince is the George Steinbrenner of pro wrestling. Done a lot for the business. Changed it forever; but has watered it down in a sense and has monopolized and bought his way to the top. I have been watching the E since 1999 but I like my alternative that I have in TNA and if I could get ROH on my TV, I would watch ROH. IMO NOTHING beats Japanese wrestling but I don't think I could get Japan on my TV either

 

[The HEEL JuiceLee]

YEAH but tell me you wouldn't like to see either of the two rosters help revive the
TAG-DIVISION.Or imagine A Colt Cabana vs CM PuNK fued on a WWE stage. oR A Word elite type stable with Sheamus,Drew McIntyre,Desmond Wolfe,Eric Young(as Sheamus comedy side kick),Magnus,DouG Williams,
Kozlov(EY & SanTiNo fighting over Kozlov services THAT's just comedy GOLD!!!),Eric Young(as Sheamus comedy side kick)& Rob Terry,Ezikel Jackson-god they could be a super dominate super heel group like no other!!

Robbie-E vs Zack Ryder

El genirico Vs Chavo Guerrero

I only wan't Vince to buy 1 of the company's.1 will still be out there to give u an alternative to the "E"

 

[Scuba 06]

Neither. We actually have two decent alternatives to the mediocre program that WWE has become and you want to get rid of them. Vince already destroyed any legacy left by ECW, using its name value to milk it for any penny he could. He left a ton of WCW talen unemployed within a year of signing with WWE and pretty much has down played any success WCW ever had. Anything Vince didnt create he wants to tarnish. I for one thinks the FCW program is crap and most of the dudes who have come out of it arent very good. The stars produced there are all bland or generic and follow the WWE system that dosent appreciate wrestling for the sport value like ROH does. ROH produces amonst the best talent. You want Vince to turn that place into a pg cookie cutter, storyline over sport, project tough enough 2.0. hell to the no.

 

[The_Reptile_]

Storytelling issues aside, ROH does have the best athletes in the American wrestling scene, not to mention the fact that they have logical booking behind helps a lot. They also seem to understand that they'll never really be able to go toe-to-toe with WWE and instead focuses on its own strength.

TNA... TNA is not an alternative. It's a cheap knockoff of WWE that's a shadow of whatever it was. It recycles storylines that WWE either did awhile ago, or are still doing, and often with the exact same guys, which another problem in of itself. There's no logical booking, the wrestling's either bad or way too short to get any enjoyment out of it, and the promo's are pathetic. It's really a rather sad miracle that despite all of the great talent TNA has, they're still unable to put on a good show.

 

[Richard]

I can see the logical standpoint in saying he should purchase TNA what with Bischoff, Hogan there even though TNA sucks, there is every chance in the world they create something that sticks and catches on like wild fire, we just haven't seen it yet.

Although I think Vince would purchase ROH as 1. Majority of people who watch pro wrestling, watch it on TV and would only know WWE and TNA mostly and we all know Vince doesn't really like to make superstars massive in WWE that come from a rival show which was big so I don't know if Vince hired anyone from TNA like AJ or MCMG after a buy out they'd be pushed to the moon and 2. Talent from ROH are virtually unknown to the mainstream wrestling audience, Vince would be able to 'make' them WWE superstars without any major affiliation with TNA at all in the mainstream fans eyes.

 

[SouthsideSam]

Definitely no point in him buying ROH as 90 percent of the WWE fans would have no idea who these guys were and he would just have a bunch of incredibly talented guys to waste away on Superstars. And the ROH fans would likely not follow their favorites to WWE as most of them hate everything about WWE.

TNA well most of their top guys are people who couldn't cut it in WWE. Other than Roode and Sting I do not see a single guy on TNAs roster that would benefit WWE. I love a lot of TNAs guys just most of them do not fit in the WWE scene.

If Vince ever buys either company it will be their tape library he buys and probably will not take their workers or keep their company alive. Besides i am pretty sure Vince could have any talent he wanted from these 2 companies other than Sting because lets face it he is really the only promoter in wrestling right now that can offer big money.

 

[The HEEL JuiceLee]

sOUTHERsIDEsAM if Vince purchesed ROH you don't think Vince could benifit from the unknown wrestlers.He would probably send 10 of them to FCW since NXT is clearing things.Then bring in 6 as a stable who could quickly make a name forthem self's ala NEXUS.Use there tag-team's to inject life into WWE's division.Just the impact the KiNG'S & THE BRISCOE BROTHERS,plus i would bring back The world's greaest tag-team.God WWE need's tag wrestling back!!!& Then take the top 4 in Vince's mind and debut them seperatly.that's the same time u could debut tyler black. a month later davey richards then kenny king then Colt Cabana and so on.It could be huge

and you are right about Robert Roode being able to go in the"E".Sting could prob go on an HBK schedule.But so could PoPe(Wouold love to see him fued with CM PUNK)Angle could def go,HBK schedule or not Angle can def do wrork in the "E".We got MrAnder$on((ANDERSON)).Alex Shelly,Samoa Joe,Daniels(suicide),Matt Morgan,THE WHOLE BRITISH INVASION,ESPICIALLY DouG WiLLiamS & Just imagine how Vince would push Rob Terry with his body.Plus we still got Eric young,Kazarian,James Storm,If Desmond Wolfe(would change name to Desmond McGuiness) can pass the physical i would love him anagnising Edge,Orton, Cena. Imagine Desmond & Barret Tag-Team.RVD win't go back to that schedule but he can def go and be a face WWE needs,AND EVEN jEFF jARRET COULD WRESTLE IN the "E" IF ViNNY MaC would have him.
Trust me 75% of the TNA roster couold wrestle in the WWE.

If Vince bought either roster he would be giving the "E" a shot in the arm.But i dont think he should do it unless

A:Start the WWE network
B:Raw & SmackDown do two 3 hour shows a month
C:Make super stars a legit show,and then run straight PG promos and matches for 2 hours every saturday morning

!JUST MY OPINIon!!