I definitely do remember this happening, I'm of the mind that it was more or less a hiptoss, but with a guy the body structure of Yokozuna, I think even the most powerful folks like a Lex Luger would have a hard time performing the technique to body slam someone whose build is unorthodox to say the least. I think even Crush would have had some issues doing the same thing, and I'm sure it's possible that Crush was told to mind his own strength and not get carried away so that they could get Luger in there at the end to work that "WOW" moment in. Again who really knows?
But I would like to touch on something else, this angle right here is my justification for why I always counter back to fellow members of the IWC, when they present their argument that SummerSlam 1993 was originally slated to be Hogan vs Bret for the World Heavyweight Championship. That's not to say they weren't considering a match between the two...but the Body Slam Challenge on the Intrepid in my view shows that Vince wanted to make Hogan's latest World Title win look like a fluke, and give Yokozuna back the championship so he could have his monster heel run with it.
This event, and the turning of Luger to a face gives credibility to the idea that Hogan vs Bret for the World Title was not a big consideration for SummerSlam that year. Onto the event itself though, I do indeed remember WWF Superstar and professional athlete alike trying to do the impossible in bodyslamming Yokozuna. It was a memorable time for me as a wrestling fan and to be honest I wanted that Bret Hart rematch with Yokozuna a lot sooner than when we actually got it. However, WrestleMania X was such a good rematch between Yoko and Bret, and it played off a lot better in the long run to do it that way, that in all honesty I can't really complain too much now. But Luger, I was never truly behind as the replacement for Hulk Hogan. Nothing against Hogan at that time but in the WWF, it ran its course, while I admit I was still a fan of his, I was starting to take notice to the incredible performances that Bret Hart put on in the WWF as the World Champion. So Hogan stepping away from the title scene and leaving the WWF was a welcome thing, and in the long run it worked out better since Hogan went to WCW and helped reinvent wrestling once again (we all know the story there, lol).
Anyway, Yokozuna's feud with Luger was lackluster, following this bodyslam challenge we saw Luger only get a moral victory in that he beat Yokozuna by countout, and he did not receive the World Title. Later on at the same WrestleMania that Bret and Yoko had their rematch, Luger once again unsuccessfully challenged for the World Title, this time via a DQ loss to Yoko. All in all, a disappointment, now there has always been speculation that Luger blabbed the ending to his WM match with Yoko and therefore they punished him by not giving him the belt. In my opinion that is a possibility but not a certainty.
Whatever the case may be, I was glad to see Bret Hart back with the World title as opposed to Luger, I was more sold on Bret's style, and despite Luger having the better physique than Hogan, he had a tall order to follow. Bret Hart I think was the better choice to be World Champion.
But in retrospect, I was entertained by the Intrepid angle and all the other stuff that happened before and after it. Good post, and thanks for the walk down memory lane.