Original Vs. Cover: F*ck Tha Police

Status
Not open for further replies.

Ty Burna

Getting Noticed By Management
I know this is TM's thing he's got going on, but I figured we could spice it up with a hip hop song. The song I chose for this is Fuck Tha Police by NWA, the cover by Rage Against the Machine, and finally the cover by Bone Thugs-n-Harmony:

NWA
[youtube]0ntZJVLYaDc[/youtube]

Rage Against The Machine
[youtube]Sj_mPVfiFPg[/youtube]

Bone Thugs-n-Harmony
[youtube]svPOdl97eBo[/youtube]

As far as my choice goes, I love all three, but I enjoy Bone's version the most, but I think NWA's is the best of the three as the original. Any hip hop fan worth a shit can recite the lyrics word for word for the NWA version, Bone and RATM kept fairly true to the lyrics but of course they threw in their own little twists to the song. By far this is one of my favorite songs of all time by NWA, and for Bone, well I think they're the only hip hop group that was worthy enough to cover this song. RATM meanwhile was politically conscious enough to be able to cover the song as well.

So what do y'all think? Which of the three versions of Fuck Tha Police is the best?
 
The NWA version, and it's not even remotely close. I've never been big on the RATM cover, probably because I'm not a big fan of the overwhelming majority of rap-rock. What the fuck do Tom Morello and Zack de la Rocha know about being targeted by the police for being black? Nothing, that's what.

The Bone Thugs version is good, I've always enjoyed it. But the thing is Ty, when Bone Thugs did that cover...it was played out. Good song, don't get me wrong, but gangsta rap had been beaten to death by that point and had already become pretty stale. When NWA did it, it was fucking revolutionary. Sure guys like KRS One had rapped about guns and "gangsta" topics before NWA, but NWA were the ones that brought it into every single home in America. White kids in the suburbs were shouting "Fuck tha police!" when that album came out. NWA could pretty much be seen as The Beatles of hip-hop. They weren't the first, but they changed the genre forever and every artist since has been influenced by them.

So, at the end of the day, I have to go with the original NWA version. I enjoy the Bone Thugs version, but it simply doesn't compare to how groundbreaking and amazing of a single that was when NWA released it. Plus (and no offense Ty, I know you love your Bone Thugs) Ice Cube alone is a better rapper than every member of Bone Thugs combined in my opinion. Don't kill me bro!
 
The NWA version, and it's not even remotely close. I've never been big on the RATM cover, probably because I'm not a big fan of the overwhelming majority of rap-rock. What the fuck do Tom Morello and Zack de la Rocha know about being targeted by the police for being black? Nothing, that's what.

The Bone Thugs version is good, I've always enjoyed it. But the thing is Ty, when Bone Thugs did that cover...it was played out. Good song, don't get me wrong, but gangsta rap had been beaten to death by that point and had already become pretty stale. When NWA did it, it was fucking revolutionary. Sure guys like KRS One had rapped about guns and "gangsta" topics before NWA, but NWA were the ones that brought it into every single home in America. White kids in the suburbs were shouting "Fuck tha police!" when that album came out. NWA could pretty much be seen as The Beatles of hip-hop. They weren't the first, but they changed the genre forever and every artist since has been influenced by them.

So, at the end of the day, I have to go with the original NWA version. I enjoy the Bone Thugs version, but it simply doesn't compare to how groundbreaking and amazing of a single that was when NWA released it. Plus (and no offense Ty, I know you love your Bone Thugs) Ice Cube alone is a better rapper than every member of Bone Thugs combined in my opinion. Don't kill me bro!

The whole point of the cover that Bone did was to honor Eazy E and the NWA legacy, not to make a hit out of it. Not only this but they were still part of Ruthless at this time, you know, the label Eazy created for NWA. So I don't see why you gotta go and say it was played out and all that shit when it wasn't ever meant to be a hit single like NWA's was.

As far as Ice Cube better than Bone? Please, that's like comparing apples to oranges in my opinion. Bone and Cube have always been rap legends that don't get the respect they deserve. Cube helped put the West Coast on the map, Bone put the Midwest on the map. Why is it necessary to say which is better? NWA broke up in 1991, Bone made it big in 1994, you act as if Cube was around for 20 years before Bone came around. Bone got popular during the rise of gangsta rap, and brought a style unheard of before in hip hop. Cube and Bone Thugs are both pioneers, so let's leave it at that and enjoy the original, and the version to honor Eazy and NWA.
 
The whole point of the cover that Bone did was to honor Eazy E and the NWA legacy, not to make a hit out of it. Not only this but they were still part of Ruthless at this time, you know, the label Eazy created for NWA. So I don't see why you gotta go and say it was played out and all that shit when it wasn't ever meant to be a hit single like NWA's was.

You're missing my point Ty. I never claimed they were trying to make a hit out of it, all I'm saying is that by the time they released that song, gangsta rap ITSELF as a genre was already old news. When NWA did it, it was groundbreaking and revolutionary.

As far as Ice Cube better than Bone? Please, that's like comparing apples to oranges in my opinion.

Well ya know I love ya Ty, but I totally disagree with you. Cube is far and away superior to every single member of Bone Thugs in my opinion. Sorry man, that's just how I see things. AmeriKKKa's Most Wanted alone is superior to any album Bone Thugs has ever dropped in my book.

Bone and Cube have always been rap legends that don't get the respect they deserve. Cube helped put the West Coast on the map, Bone put the Midwest on the map. Why is it necessary to say which is better?

...Because that's the question of this thread, isn't it Ty? Which version of the song is better? Obviously I'm going to need to compare the artists to do that now aren't I?
 
You're missing my point Ty. I never claimed they were trying to make a hit out of it, all I'm saying is that by the time they released that song, gangsta rap ITSELF as a genre was already old news. When NWA did it, it was groundbreaking and revolutionary.

I'll give you this point, it was revolutionary. I don't have much else to say against this.


Well ya know I love ya Ty, but I totally disagree with you. Cube is far and away superior to every single member of Bone Thugs in my opinion. Sorry man, that's just how I see things. AmeriKKKa's Most Wanted alone is superior to any album Bone Thugs has ever dropped in my book.

Really then? Why are artists lining up at Krayzie's door to do music with him and not Cube? Maybe because Cube has fallen off and Krayzie's finally getting the recognition he deserves as a solo artist? Let's also take a look at record sales, I know don't mean shit but let's use it as a comparison. Cube has sold 12 million records not including Kill At Will EP, so let's give him 17-20 million records in the US. Bone Thugs meanwhile has sold over 30 million records and to this day their album E1999 still pops up on the Billboard charts now and again. Do you see AmeriKKKa's Most Wanted doing that? I don't think so. E1999 is a better classic album than AmeriKKKa's Most Wanted, the record sales show it, and I believe that as well.


...Because that's the question of this thread, isn't it Ty? Which version of the song is better? Obviously I'm going to need to compare the artists to do that now aren't I?

Not necessarily, You can make the case that artist A is better than artist B, but artist B's song is better than artist A's version of the same song. Or any song in general.

As far as Cube selling out, yeah I believe so. How can you go make a kid's movie and then turn around and release two more gangsta rap centered albums after that? Come on either you're a gangsta rapper or you're a kids actor, it's kinda hard to take anything he raps about seriously after his kids movies unless it has something to do with social issues. Sorry, but that's how I feel. Cube's fanbase has fallen off, shit you remember that episode of Boondocks where Riley was asked if he knew Ice Cube and responded: The dude that makes kid's movies? Yeah, even those that remember and enjoy his music like the Boondocks creator has to talk shit about Cube like that. Meanwhile Bone Thugs still has a thriving and rabid fanbase. You ever seen an Ice Cube fan that is as dedicated as a Bone Thug's fan? I think not. I can't post links here but trust me when I say that there are at least 2 forums out there that are larger than our forum here, just dedicated to Bone Thugs. Sorry dude, like I said I love Ice Cube, he's up there on my list, but he can't top Bone in my opinion.

As far as the actual topic here, I agree the NWA version is the best version, all I'm saying is I enjoy the Bone Thug's version more. That's all.
 
Really then? Why are artists lining up at Krayzie's door to do music with him and not Cube?

That's a joke, right man? On Cube's last album alone he had Nas, Scarface, The Game, Young Jeezy, seriously Ty nobody wants to do music with Cube? Who the fuck is doing music with Krayzie Bone? A bunch of people no one has ever heard of? Not trying to sound hostile man, but Nas & Scarface don't count anymore or something? Both of those guys are miles above Bone Thugs and both of them were just on Cube's last album.

Maybe because Cube has fallen off and Krayzie's finally getting the recognition he deserves as a solo artist?

No shit Cube isn't the same rapper he was in 1991, people change and evolve. Do you know how hard it is to live up to an album like AmeriKKKa's Most Wanted? It's the same problem Nas has had; nothing can ever match up to Illmatic, no matter how good his new albums are. Doesn't take away from the artist.

Cube's early work man, Bone Thugs just can't compare. I'm sorry dude, I know you love Bone Thugs, but to me they're not even on the same level as the genius Cube showed during the late 80s and early 90s. Before Tupac and Biggie showed up he was known as the hottest rapper in the game man. Whereas if you asked most people about Bone Thugs, they probably couldn't name you a single member.

Let's also take a look at record sales, I know don't mean shit but let's use it as a comparison. Cube has sold 12 million records not including Kill At Will EP, so let's give him 17-20 million records in the US. Bone Thugs meanwhile has sold over 30 million records and to this day their album E1999 still pops up on the Billboard charts now and again. Do you see AmeriKKKa's Most Wanted doing that? I don't think so. E1999 is a better classic album than AmeriKKKa's Most Wanted, the record sales show it, and I believe that as well.

That's a TERRIBLE argument Ty. Record sales define quality now? I guess by that logic that means Soulja Boy is superior to Rakim, right? Record sales mean jack shit when it comes to quality man, and you know that.

AmeriKKKa's Most Wanted > Everything Bone Thugs has ever done, and I stand by that Ty. I don't see why we're arguing this though; you'll claim E1999 is better, I'll claim AmeriKKKa's Most Wanted is better, and this conversation will go nowhere. I'm just telling you my opinion man, and most critics would agree with me.

As far as Cube selling out, yeah I believe so. How can you go make a kid's movie and then turn around and release two more gangsta rap centered albums after that? Come on either you're a gangsta rapper or you're a kids actor, it's kinda hard to take anything he raps about seriously after his kids movies unless it has something to do with social issues. Sorry, but that's how I feel. Cube's fanbase has fallen off, shit you remember that episode of Boondocks where Riley was asked if he knew Ice Cube and responded: The dude that makes kid's movies? Yeah, even those that remember and enjoy his music like the Boondocks creator has to talk shit about Cube like that. Meanwhile Bone Thugs still has a thriving and rabid fanbase. You ever seen an Ice Cube fan that is as dedicated as a Bone Thug's fan? I think not. I can't post links here but trust me when I say that there are at least 2 forums out there that are larger than our forum here, just dedicated to Bone Thugs. Sorry dude, like I said I love Ice Cube, he's up there on my list, but he can't top Bone in my opinion.

A) It's RAP MUSIC we're talking about here Ty. You really think every gangsta rapper that rhymes about selling drugs and shooting people actually does those things? Come on man, by that logic Dre is a HUGE fuckin sellout because he was never a gansta in his entire life yet rapped about it. Seriously man, 99% of "gangsta rappers" are complete bullshitters. I highly doubt Krayzie is going around doin' the shit he claims either. It's irrelevant man, because Cube's rhyming skills and lyric skills are superior to Bone's in my opinion.

B) So because Bone Thugs have dedicated fans that makes them better than Cube? Right, so by that logic than I guess ICP are the greatest rap group of all time, right? No one is more dedicated than ICP fans; doesn't change the fact that the group they worship is total shit.

I'm really not trying to hate on Bone Thugs, I like them quite a bit and E1999 is a classic album. But they're just not on Cube's level, and never have been in my opinion. If you disagree, that's cool man, but you're not going to change my mind or anything.
 
Well I had never head the Ty special before, only listening to the original, and the Rage version. I am a fan of Rage myself, and I love this cover, and it is probably my most played version of them, but that is because I am a white boy. But as far as the version that is the better song, the NWA one is for me. I love the court room set up that the song offers, that really captures what the song is talking about.
 
That's a joke, right man? On Cube's last album alone he had Nas, Scarface, The Game, Young Jeezy, seriously Ty nobody wants to do music with Cube? Who the fuck is doing music with Krayzie Bone? A bunch of people no one has ever heard of? Not trying to sound hostile man, but Nas & Scarface don't count anymore or something? Both of those guys are miles above Bone Thugs and both of them were just on Cube's last album.

Ain't it great to have record labels go pay artists to work with you? I'm not saying that's what happened but there's a difference. Either Cube or his label asked Nas and Scarface to be on his album, you know needing legends to boost up your album. Krayzie meanwhile is putting down all the hot artists and working with the lesser known artists to help them come up. Big difference between asking for artists to be on your album, and getting asked to be on other artist's albums. Oh and even Ice Cube has asked Krayzie to be on a song, a single no less:

[youtube]s8eHfVBHY3Q[/youtube]

No shit Cube isn't the same rapper he was in 1991, people change and evolve. Do you know how hard it is to live up to an album like AmeriKKKa's Most Wanted? It's the same problem Nas has had; nothing can ever match up to Illmatic, no matter how good his new albums are. Doesn't take away from the artist.

Cube's early work man, Bone Thugs just can't compare. I'm sorry dude, I know you love Bone Thugs, but to me they're not even on the same level as the genius Cube showed during the late 80s and early 90s. Before Tupac and Biggie showed up he was known as the hottest rapper in the game man. Whereas if you asked most people about Bone Thugs, they probably couldn't name you a single member.

And I think Bone's better than Cube, and I bet you could ask most people to name an old Ice Cube album, they couldn't name one. Moot point and irrelevant, why? Because Cube and Bone haven't been mainstream in quite some time. Oh and as far as the hottest rappers in the game, they were asking Bone to be on their albums to reference to the response above, and that includes Ice Cube.

That's a TERRIBLE argument Ty. Record sales define quality now? I guess by that logic that means Soulja Boy is superior to Rakim, right? Record sales mean jack shit when it comes to quality man, and you know that.

I know this, it was just for fucking comparison's sake, it wasn't to prove something, I just wanted to point album sales so we can throw that out there right off the bat. They were both in the game at their peak when file sharing wasn't prevalent and there wasn't the bullshit hip hop that teeny boppers are listening to.

AmeriKKKa's Most Wanted > Everything Bone Thugs has ever done, and I stand by that Ty. I don't see why we're arguing this though; you'll claim E1999 is better, I'll claim AmeriKKKa's Most Wanted is better, and this conversation will go nowhere. I'm just telling you my opinion man, and most critics would agree with me.

Man the critics don't mean a fucking thing as far as I'm concerned, it's what the fans think, the average person thinks of each respective person. And since we got only two arguing this point right now, it's a moot point again. I claim E1999 Eternal is the better album, you think AmeriKKKa's Most Wanted is better. Both classics, so let's agree both are an essential part of a true hip hop collection.

A) It's RAP MUSIC we're talking about here Ty. You really think every gangsta rapper that rhymes about selling drugs and shooting people actually does those things? Come on man, by that logic Dre is a HUGE fuckin sellout because he was never a gansta in his entire life yet rapped about it. Seriously man, 99% of "gangsta rappers" are complete bullshitters. I highly doubt Krayzie is going around doin' the shit he claims either. It's irrelevant man, because Cube's rhyming skills and lyric skills are superior to Bone's in my opinion.

B) So because Bone Thugs have dedicated fans that makes them better than Cube? Right, so by that logic than I guess ICP are the greatest rap group of all time, right? No one is more dedicated than ICP fans; doesn't change the fact that the group they worship is total shit.

Dre is a sellout, I'll say it all day everyday. Look at his fucking first solo album before he joined NWA, I don't gotta say anything else. I'll back off the selling out bit, but I still think he did, but I'll lay off that. Krayzie and Cube both lived the hard life, ain't no doubt about that, when they talk about it, they're talking about their past and where they came from, not that they're doing that now. I thought that would be common knowledge when it comes to talking about that shit. I think Bone's rhyming skills, the fast flow is better than Cube's West Coast style, both were using the G Funk style to start out with. Oh and mostly I'm arguing just for the shits and giggles of it, and what kind of fan would I be without defending my favorite artists?

As far as B is concerned, I was waiting for that to come up, and that was a poorly thought out argument on my end. So my bad on that.

I'm really not trying to hate on Bone Thugs, I like them quite a bit and E1999 is a classic album. But they're just not on Cube's level, and never have been in my opinion. If you disagree, that's cool man, but you're not going to change my mind or anything.

At the end of the day, let's just say it like it is X, we both love hip hop, we have our differences on who's better, but you know what, it don't matter as long as we got the music that we love to listen to. And just like you, I'm not trying to shit on Cube either, and for the last time, Cube is one of my favorites, not my top ten, but one of my favorites. I don't like to disrespect artists I like, so this hurts having to talk against Cube.

So with all that said, X, get the blunt, I'll get the 40's, let's cruise down the street in a 64 if we can jack one.
 
  • Like
Reactions: X
Uh oh, it's time to bring the south into this discussion! Haha... just kidding. While the song below verses are not very good (especially Webbie, who can downright be a fucking embarrassment to my city sometimes with his raps), I absolutely LOVE the chorus. There's nothing like riding with this on full blast. Take a listen for me:

[youtube]nof5tK6Mtqw[/youtube]​

Also, I know that's not technically a cover or remix, but I do consider it a modern day, southern version of the song.

As far as the other discussion going on, I have to give Bone Thugs-n-Harmony all the credit in the World for me being a fan of hip-hop/rap. I will always be indebted to them for that. With Ice Cube, well Ice Cube is just the fucking man. AmeriKKKa's Most Wanted is one of my favorite albums of all time. I also love The Predator as well. With Bone, there's E 1999 Eternal, which like AmeriKKKa's Most Wanted, is one of my favorite albums of all time. I also love Creepin on ah Come Up and The Art of War. And in both cases, I believe that their later work highly decreased in quality when compared to their earlier stuff (when talking about Bone, I'm NOT including the solo work of Krayzie, Bizzy, and especially L-Burna, as I loved everything I heard from them solo wise), but at the same time.... both have made some fantastic guest spots on other people's albums over the years. So, to me, really thinking about it, and I know it's a cop out, but it's a tie in my book. Both are awesome, and neither is better than the other. :)
 
I'm gonna take NWA's version here. I do enjoy Bone Thugs version, but nothing really compares to the NWA version for me, especially not RATM.

NWA's Fuck Tha Police was groundbreaking and revolutionary. Every self respecting hip hop fan knows this song through and through, whilst Bone Thugs covered this song very well, I don't think it touches NWA's version, considering the importance of NWA's.

Even if Cube has fallen off in the last few years, back when this was released his lyrics were controversial and really sparked the uprise in gangsta rap, with this song even causing outrage.

I wasn't really a fan of RATM's cover, mainly because I don't really like De La Rocha, but even for song quality and performance I prefer NWA's.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
174,846
Messages
3,300,834
Members
21,727
Latest member
alvarosamaniego
Back
Top