The fact is that NJPW right at the current moment has the best pro wrestling product in the entire world(yes, that includes WWE) by a considerably wide margin. And what people fail, or truthfully downright refuse, to realize is that there is a massive market in America right now for in-ring product-centric wrestling programming and no one to fill it. Further exposure of the "Sports Entertainment" approach has not brought in new viewers to wrestling in years. While a focus on stiff, high quality in ring action (like NJPW specializes in)is the one route that could still create a revival of mass interest in the industry.
I'm skeptical that NJPW will be able to find the marketing strategy necessary to make this a hit in North America, but if they somehow are able to, they will change the industry as we know it. It should be interesting to see how many viewers the American Wrestle Kingdom broadcast will bring in, and if the absolutely guaranteed universal praise that will follow will bring wide enough awareness to begin establishing a foothold for NJPWWorld in North America.
I am sincerely starting to think that Papa Pillman is the best damn poster on this boards.
You hit the nail in the head with your post, and I agree 100% with the first bold sentence. New Japan is just different wrestling, different psychology, different way of booking and it still works damn well, and they created major buzz for themselves, to a point, where they sold out Tokyo Dome weeks in advance and they've not done that since God knows how long. The next major step is and needs to be - English translation and Talent Developmental.
I'll be talking about the two topics, but first, I'll talk about the second bold sentence, and that one, was the thing that really made me think as far as business plan goes for New Japan. They'll make their debut on the North American PPV market, and remember, it's the first time, so they NEED to get good numbers, but, they just launched this NJPW Network - Worldwide (if not, pretty close), for $9.99. I mean,
who are the targets for the PPV business? It's the hardcore american fans, the guys that know what's happening in New Japan, so, those guys will sign with the Network instead of buying the PPV for 3x the price. So, why? Why on Earth would they debut on the American market's PPV business and launch a Worldwide Network? I don't know about you, but this will most likely be the reason for a possible "flop" and it's making me concerned. There's no name for the "general audience" to just buy the PPV, there's no marketing for them - it's just the hardcore wrestling fans. What I am saying is that I also agree with you about being skeptical about their success and that's really unfortunate.
Currently, New Japan, no doubt is the best wrestling promotion in the world, content wise. I would rather see a New Japan show then a WWE or ROH or TNA show and they absolutely NEED the English commentators, it's not a matter of special events, no, it's all the time, because if they want a new market, they have to make them care for their builds, or else, people will just give up. Wrestle Kingdom 9 will be one of the best shows this year and they have a real shot of getting the wrestling fan who's giving it a shot, because he read that this is the shit and what not, they'll get him, but how are they going to make him comeback, if he all of a sudden, just loses who's "who" and what not? For me to start watch it (4 years now?), I had to have TNA guys there, I had to do my research on guys on Wikipedia and I don't see a lot of people just doing that for Togi Makabe or whatever. It's a MUST! Jim Ross is an amazing name, but I don't see him being around that long, so, use wrestlers, use emigrants, but make that option viable.
But also, another major concern - they need to expand their roster - according to Meltzer, who's way more inside than anyone as far as being a journalist, New Japan doesn't have a lot of Young Lions ("Rookies"). Their current crop of talent is the equivalent of WWE's 2001/2002, and they need guys that will be able to hold it for the next ten years - Tanahashi is fucking 38 years old. Okada will fill his role as he's only 27 years, but the other card is filled with Ishii (39), Nakamura (34), Naito (32), Goto & Shibata (35). Those are guys that in the next ten years won't be around. They currently have only four "young lions" on the main roster and only two of them are in excursions (as they usually do) and those are Hiromu Takahashi (CMLL, 25 Years Old) and Takaaki Watanabe (USA/ROH, 27 Years Old). If they want to grow, they need to think about the future and they need to develop domestic stars, because Japanese culture is very different from American's view. Also, it's New Japan, not "New World".
Well, to cut a long story short: New Japan is the most interesting company in the world right now, and they are the only ones capable of actually shifting the market as of right now. WWE may have the best future, but "Sports-Entertainment" is running it's course for the current market and if they don't pick up on that, they'll be fucked in the ass by New Japan.