I have this game on All-American and passing is so much more difficult then running. I usually have 8 minute quarters and if I don't have run/pass ratio of 60/40 I'm usually not doing too good.
Doesn't help that I started off with a shit school (Western Kentucky) and that I'm now on a team that's only B overall (Arizona St.). But my god some of these QB's throws are awful. I'll tap the button and he'll lead them 10 yards when I need him to throw it at them (which results in a pick 1/2 the time).
Very frustrating game. I'll either have to adopt the option soon (which owns if the QB has even decent speed + acceleration) or just start with a team that's good and be the HC (I'm the OC and my defense has allowed 27, 52, and 59 points to Troy, #2 Wisconsin, and UCLA respectively).
Oh well, it'll probably collect some dust once I get Madden.