OK now it really is time for Little Big Planet to fuck off.
It wrongly got past Mario Kart
It wrongly got past Bomberman
It must not get past Metal Gear Solid 3.
This is a game that has only been out for all of 6 months, that is nowhere near long enough for a reasoned judgement on it and it sure as fuck does not deserve to beat
3 classic games. I would be happy to vote against it purely for that but instead I'm also going to give you reasons to vote for the best Metal Gear in the series.
The Story
The story is infact deceptively brilliant, looking at the idea of a soldier's indentity being wrapped up in the idealogy of right and wrong and the lost disillusioned generation of soldiers who would lead to the story of MGS4, mercenaries and the war economy. Snake Eater is the genesis of the story and actually requires you to control original Snake/the soon to be Big Boss and villain of future games.
The Gameplay
The thing about early Metal Gear games is they're about precision and timing, in Snake Eater the jungle setting makes that so much more difficult to plot a course or find proper cover when all you can see infront of you is greens and browns, made even worse by enemy soldiers who are also camoflaged. It's a very organic enviroment that requires ultimate stealth and quick thinking if you fuck it up, there's no technology to save you here. It's you Vs an army.
The Bosses
If the story is great and the setting is revolutionary, it's the bosses that are truly the games greatest asset. The Fear is probably one of the most underrated villains in gaming history, always forgotten behind The End. His perfect camoflage, combined with his speed and the fact that his poisoned crossbow bolts are hallucinagenic make him near invisible amongst the tree-branches. He is really just a warmup though, the battle with The End is a classic gaming moment and even better than the fight with Sniper Wolf in Metal Gear Sold. The old man hides high up amongst the rocks with his sniper rifle while his parrot works as a spotter and he simply waits for you to make a mistake as you try to work out where the fuck he'd hiding. Even if you're successful first time out, this is a boss fight that will take at least 30 minutes and can go on for hours as you hide behind a log, low health wondering whether you'll be shot in the head with your next move.
Vote Metal Gear Sold: Snake Eater, because it's the better game and it deserves to be here.
And I've just read that a HD release will be coming to the PS3.