Kaitlyn Sig

[Ultra Awesome]

I'm a bit torn about a sig that I made and I need help deciding which one is better.

First one:

Spoiler

^ This was my original final product.




Second one:

Spoiler

This one was [inderictly] inspired by Sam but it was Ferbian who said I should make it.



But the thing is, I can't decide which is better. So quick question to anyone that cares, which do you think is better?

 

[Merwin]

First one

 

[Ultra Awesome]

That's 1 to 0.

 

[Pay Per Ghost]

god damn!

 

[Next Jericho]

Hot damn she is hot!!!

I chose number 1 and well done Mister Awesome.

 

[Theo Mays]

I prefer the first one.

 

[Merwin]

Thing is i like Hate White Backrounds

 

[Ultra Awesome]

god damn!

Lol. So which did you choose?

Hot damn she is hot!!!

I chose number 1 and well done Mister Awesome.

2 - 0. Thanks for your opinion.

I prefer the first one.

3 - 0. Thanks Theo. I needed a sig maker's opinion also.

Thing is i like Hate White Backrounds

Yeah, I'm not a big fan of them either but they seem to be so popular right now, so yea...thanks for commenting.

 

[The Doctor]

If you clear out some of that dead space by maybe blending in a match picture or some more studios, or even some interesting brushes, then I'd say go with the first.

 

[Theo Mays]

If you clear out some of that dead space by maybe blending in a match picture or some more studios, or even some interesting brushes, then I'd say go with the first.

I actually like the empty space. It gives it a very background-ish look.

 

[Ultra Awesome]

If you clear out some of that dead space by maybe blending in a match picture or some more studios, or even some interesting brushes, then I'd say go with the first.

Yea, I was sort of thinking the same. I was planning on doing that, but I wasn't so sure which between the above two was better. Thanks for the comment, Doc.

 

[Ultra Awesome]

Then again, like Theo said, it looks rather complete like that, doesn;t it?

 

[The Doctor]

It depends on what you're using it for, I think. Right now it would make a good wallpaper, but not a good sig.

 

[Ultra Awesome]

Good point. I did plan on using it as a sig... Thanks again for commenting.

Alright so that makes 4 - 0. Lol. Well Ferbs, your loosing.

 

[Ferbian]

Well Ferbs, your loosing.

I never said it would be the better one. I said I liked it better personally, and that I figured you could make it look good with the white background if you made it like Sam and Dave's sigs, or Doc's RAW talent sigs for that sake.

 

[Ultra Awesome]

The NXT sign doesn't look as attractive as if it were to be covering the majority of the background. The difference with Sam's sig and Dave's sig is that their background is easily made to fit in the background because of the sign being horizontal. However, in my opinion, the nxt sign doesn't look so great like that.

Anyways, first one wins.