Is a comatose person still considered living? | WrestleZone Forums

Is a comatose person still considered living?

Dwayne_Jason

Do I have everybody's attention now
So is a comatose person still living according to you?

In my opinion, they really aren't. Unless they have a double digit hope of coming back to earth, in my opinion you just gotta pull the plug.


Discuss
 
Totally depending on how long they've been in the comatose state. After a long period of time from being in a coma, the brian starts to deteriorate. It is after this point, I would declare the body dead and the point where I pull the plug. After their brain is deteriorated enough, life won't likely go back to the way it was before the accident. Life support is needed then after a while they are declared brain dead. Sometimes, after a certain point, it's better to let them go then to let them continue through the pain. However, it's hard for me to say if I could ever let anyone I cared about go no matter how bad it looked. That's sorta a decision I'll have to make when I'm faced with it.
 
I wish you would have been specific in noting what you meant by a "comatose person." There's a difference between being in a coma, and being a vegetable, so to speak. In the first type of coma, the brain is still functioning although the body cannot respond to exterior stimuli, or make voluntary movements. Thats whats known as a supratentoral coma. This person in this case has the chance to wake up at some point, and may go on to live a normal life with minimal damage, although it will take time to recover.

When someone goes into a vegetable like state, its known as a infratentarol coma. In this case, the person has no chance of waking up. Their brain is still functioning, but there is such significant damage to it that the sleep cycle is disturbed so greatly that they'll never regain a proper one, making it impossible for them to wake up. These are people we commonly refer to as vegetables. They have no ability to feel pain, make voluntary movements, or respond to or understand others whatsoever. I think its important to distinguish between the two.

Look, Im no expert on the subject, but Ill weigh in with my opinion. Im going to assume for purposes of this thread that you were referring to a vegetable state, from which one will never recover. But even in this case, the person is still very much alive. Their heart is still beating, and their lungs are still breathing. At some point, those things will cease to occur as well as the person will inevitably become "brain dead", but until that point, they are very much alive. Pulling the plug is taking away the life of someone who hasn't given permission. I refuse to debate this with anyone, but unless that person has an advanced directive instructing what to do in such circumstance, then pulling the plug is taking human life, and is murder, in my opinion. Not only in medical terminology, but in my own humble one as well.
 
Being comatose is neither here nor there as it's really little more than a deep sleep. People can be comatose and brain dead in which case I'd say that yeah they're basically dead or they can simply be recovering while in a coma. The coma part is pretty irrelevant to be honest.
 
Being comatose is neither here nor there as it's really little more than a deep sleep. People can be comatose and brain dead in which case I'd say that yeah they're basically dead or they can simply be recovering while in a coma. The coma part is pretty irrelevant to be honest.

Thats your opinion, and youre entitled to it, but I wholeheartedly disagree. Its far more then a deep sleep, in fact, its the exact OPPOSITE of a deep sleep as your REM patterns are completely disabled. The type of coma wholly matters, especially when determining whether theyre truly beyond recovery, but until their heart stops, they're not basically dead, theyre still very much alive. Theyre just non-functioning human beings. Im not sure how that renders the coma irrelevant, especially since the person can quite recover and in the non-vegetable state, the coma generally doesnt last longer then a month.
 
I believe that a comatose person is still considered alive. They are not in a conscious state, but if they still have a pulse then they are still alive. Their heart is still beating, then they are still alive. It comes down to your personal and/or religious beliefs sometimes. I believe that if someone's in a coma but their spirit has not left their body (in other words, they have not fully died) then they are still alive. When you die completely, your spirit leaves your body and goes to the afterlife. If you are in a coma, you're not dead, your spirit is still in your body because your life in this world has not ended yet. You may or may not disagree with that, that's just what I believe. It's a very complicated topic, one that most people are not going to agree on.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
174,846
Messages
3,300,837
Members
21,727
Latest member
alvarosamaniego
Back
Top