George 'The Animal' Steele: Worthy or Not?

Does George 'The Animal' Steele deserve to be IN the Hall of Fame?

  • Yes. He's earned his spot.

  • No. Unless you want to accept Eugene as well.


Results are only viewable after voting.

TheOneBigWill

[This Space for Rent]
118ww1.jpg

William James Myers (born April 16, 1937 in Detroit, Michigan), better known by his ring name George "The Animal" Steele is a former American professional wrestler and actor. Steele's career lasted from 1967 until 1989, though he made occasional wrestling appearances into the 1990s and 2000s.

After gaining a bachelor of science degree from Michigan State University and a master's degree from Central Michigan University,[1] Myers became a teacher and amateur wrestling coach at Madison High School in Madison Heights, Michigan. There he would eventually become a member of the Michigan Coaches Hall of Fame.

Looking to supplement his income, he got into the world of Detroit-area professional wrestling, but in order to protect his privacy, he wrestled under a mask using the name The Student. Scouted by World Wide Wrestling Federation champion Bruno Sammartino, he began working in Pittsburgh in 1967 on the popular Studio Wrestling TV show broadcast on WIIC-TV Channel 11. There he dropped the mask, but still looking to hide his real name, adopted the name "George Steele". Using the last name Steele was suggested by the popular Jumping Johnny DeFazio. The name Steele was derived from Pittsburgh's nickname of the "Steel City" and the first name George was suggested by another wrestler.

Working well with Sammartino, he was invited for a full run in the WWF. He told WWF TV commentator Ray Morgan that he was the nephew of Ray Steele (kayfabe) and had an extensive amateur background. He sold the story by using an array of armlocks on opponents, weakening them for his finisher, the Flying Hammerlock (Steele would lift his opponents off the mat by a hammerlocked arm). He also revealed his teaching background to interviewers that made his in-ring Neanderthal image all the more incongruous. He wrestled Sammartino to an hour-long draw at Madison Square Garden but lost the rematch. He was then relegated to a feud with Chief Jay Strongbow, and lost to Edouard Carpentier at the Garden before taking a brief hiatus to reinvent his wildman character.

Now his gimmick was fully established. A true crazy heel, he acted like a wild man in the ring, tearing up the turnbuckle with his teeth and using the stuffing as a weapon as well as sticking out his green tongue (an effect accomplished by eating green Clorets breath mints). The Animal had a stooped posture and a hairless head, but a thick mat of fur on his back; wrestling broadcasters often speculated that The Animal was indeed "the missing link." At best The Animal could occasionally manage to utter a word or two during interviews with one them usually being "Duh-da-dahh."

As Steele recalled in a later shoot interview, his infamous "Duh-dahh" interview style happened by accident. Throughout his career, Steele prided himself on being able to cut eloquent and effective promos, and ranked his mic skills with the best in the business. At a WWF TV taping in the early '80s, he was cutting one of these promos when Vince McMahon cut him off, and reminded Steele that his gimmick was the "Animal", and for an animal he was "making too much sense". Incensed, Steele did a second take of nothing but garbled and incoherent syllables ("Duhh-dahh"). Steele did this deliberately, and out of pure frustration, thinking that McMahon would acquiesce and allow Steele to cut his normal, eloquent promos. Much to Steele's shock, McMahon replied, "That's exactly what I want!", and this would remain Steele's interview style for the rest of his WWF run.

Steele eventually became one of the more beloved wrestlers of the early "WrestleMania" era of the mid-1980s. He turned face during Saturday Night's Main Event when his partners in a six-man match, Nikolai Volkoff and the Iron Sheik, abandoned him to their opponents, Ricky Steamboat and the U.S. Express (Barry Windham and Mike Rotunda), leading to Steele being taken under the wing of the Express' manager, Capt. Lou Albano. His most famous feud was in 1986 against "Macho Man" Randy Savage, after Steele developed a crush on Savage's valet, Miss Elizabeth. The feud was meant to last only a couple of months (and end with Steele being disappointed), but it proved so popular with fans that it continued well into 1987. In 1988, Steele began carrying a hand puppet named "Mine" to the ring. Late in 1989 Steele retired due to Crohn's disease. Though he left the WWF without any WWF championships behind him, he left a fan favorite. A decade later Steele came out of retirement briefly (see below).

In 1999 during the WWF's "Attitude Era", George Steele returned as part of The Oddities. On January 10, 2000, George Steele appeared on an episode of WCW Monday Nitro as one of three legends Jeff Jarrett had to face that night. On June 8, 2008, Steele made an appearance at TNA Slammiversary as a groomsman in the wedding for "Black Machismo" Jay Lethal and So Cal Val, along with Koko B. Ware, Kamala, and Jake "The Snake" Roberts. His list of accomplishments and Championships (according to Wiki) are as follows:


Cauliflower Alley Club
Other honoree (2004)

Georgia Wrestling Alliance
GWA Heavyweight Championship (1 time)

National Wrestling Alliance
Regional
NWA World Tag Team Championship (Detroit version) (1 time) - with Frankie Laine
Professional Wrestling Hall of Fame
Class of 2005

Pro Wrestling Illustrated
PWI ranked him # 267 of the 500 best singles wrestlers during the "PWI Years" in 2003.

World Wrestling Federation
WWF Hall of Fame (Class of 1995)
Slammy Award for Best Performance by an Animal (1987)

Wrestling Observer Newsletter awards
Most Embarrassing Wrestler (1987, 1988)
Worst Feud of the Year (1987) vs. Danny Davis
Worst Tag Team (1986) with the Junkyard Dog

George 'The Animal' Steele: With the exception of the jobber, and the celebs, George 'The Animal' Steele is a flat-out embarassment to the Hall of Fame. He did next to nothing, not just within the W.W.F., but throughout most of his career. The only reason he's even slightly rememberable is because of eating turnbuckles and having a green tongue. Not to mention his character resembled that of an 80's version of Eugene, let me guess, Eugene is likely going on this year's Hall of Fame ballot?

I don't recall much of 'The Animal' and not because I choose not to, but rather because that of what I've seen, I'd much rather just forget. I'm at a loss for why he even got inducted to begin with, and I'm sure I'm not alone. If anyone disputes why George 'The Animal' Steele is undeserving of being in the Hall of Fame, please do, because I'm wanting to find at least one person who thinks he should be. What are your thoughts and opinions on George 'The Animal' Steele being in the Hall of Fame? Worthy or Not?
 
Absolutely not. He was a jobber, and a comedy jobber. He won one big match in his career that I recall: beating Hulk Hogan via count out at a taped house show. Other than that's he's famous for eating turnbuckles and being the guy that helped Steamboat beat Savage at WM 3. He was one of those guys that was inducted 15 years ago when the Hall of Fame somehow meant less than it does now. No way does he belong in the HOF.
 
I never got the appeal of George. He wasn't that good in the ring, wasn't charismatic, and never accomplished anything. But he ate turnbuckles, so I guess it all balances out.
 
Definitely no, what really did he accomplish? He had next to no major feuds, he didnt win any championships, outside of the Savage storyline was he part of any major one? I really like the Eugene comparison, actually Eugene might have actually accomplished more than George did. Just a side note about him he was my Dad's gym teacher in high school.lol
 
I'll lump him with JYD and say NO.

I loved him as a kid. He almost seemed like a ******ed older brother. I loved watching him in the ring, and I enjoyed the feud with Savage. His most memorable moment of his career, came in a match that he wasn't even in (Steamboat v. Savage).

In the end, he was a decent comedy gimmick, and he was over with the fans, but he has no track record to even have an argument for the Hall of Fame.
 
No. Granted, I maybe too young to remember "the greatness" in which George the Animal Steeles career existed, but the guy was just incredibly dull. Randy Savage, Randy Fucking Macho Man Savage, couldn't get a good match out of the guy, that speaks beyond volumes. The guy is a clown, nothing more, nothing less. He's known for his green tongue and eating the turnbuckle, yup, not exactly Hall of Fame credentials in my opinion. In fact, I'm convinced he's only in because apparantely Stephanie like him as a child.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
174,840
Messages
3,300,777
Members
21,726
Latest member
chrisxenforo
Back
Top