It was a tough call for me. As a movie, it wasn't that great. The pacing was off, it didn't have much story to it. It was just rushed dialogue to get to the next fight scene...
As a movie made for a FF7 fan, however, (of which I am a HUGE one) this movie was just one long orgasm. They threw in so much stuff to make this movie kick ass, every thing from the characters, to mentioning certain things.....to even the guys ringtone on his cell....just...great movie for the fans. My then-fiance watched it, and hated it cause she played the game, but never got into it as much as I did.
The movie critic side of me says 1.5 our of 5 stars. The FF7 fan in me says 6 out of 5 stars. Take that for what its worth...