Dolph Ziggler or MVP as heel?

[cmedge]

I was wondering, when you tune into Smackdown and watch a full episode, you woulkd see Dolph Ziggler beat MVP like usual. Imagine if MVP was given a heel IC title run instead of Mr.Ziggles. Who is a better heel, who has better mic skills,who is better in the ring.

I really like both, but I think the veteran MVP is better.

 

[Disturbed]

WHy is this in the Raw Section? I think MVP has better mic skills as a heel and I also think he sucks at face but Ziggler would also suck at face. Some guys are borned to play the heel role and MVP and Ziggler both are born to do that but for some odd reason , Vince doesn't like MVP heel. I don't know if he is blind or what. As far as in ring ability I think Ziggler is a tad bit better but not by much. Ziggler is really with his technical style but so is MVP and I can't wait to see some of there matches.

 

[Mr. Artistic guy]

Ziggler is a better prospect, not just for the fact he is most probably as good overall as MVP (MVP wins mic skills whereas dolph wins ring skills), but because he is younger and a WWE made guy and that puts him in really good stead. And the area he is a bit weaker in but not by loads, is talking which is quite easy to develop if the potential is already there and I believe for mr ziggles as an arrogant style heel, the future looks brighter for him. Now as to whether this should make him heel of face over MVP, well some people look and sound better as heels and some look and sound better as faces and this is very often decided by a guys ability on the mic.

This stems from a perspective, well a fact, that heels get more mic time which is at the very least true in WWE anyway. So if, as I believe MVP is better right now charisma wise then dolph then he would make the better heel and I'd stick to this going on past performances. But the only problem with this being as I mentionned before that dolph looks and sounds better as a heel, he has been heel since day post-spirit squad debut and it would be a challenge to break that mold. It is easier to turn a face heel than vice versa because you have to believe in a guy's repentance to accept him as a face. So dolph would have a little trouble turning unless writing turns creative. But based on this fact it may be better to leave sleeping dogs to lie, ziggler is doing better and better each week, slowly but surely as a heel and MVP has got quite a wide face fan base. But you know what, that always makes for a good turn is someone has a good face following as history tells us.

So given the choice I'd turn MVP and no jokes, I'd turn cody because to me he comes accross as someone who would be able to pull off face really well, just to keep the balance there. But my question after this hypothetical scenario would have to be is why? They are both doing a fairly decent job as they are and there isn't any sort of heel/face imbalance on smackdown so since it aint broke, don't write a thread about it, especially not in the wrong section, I'd speak to a mod about that bro.

 

[AttitudeChild]

I would say MVP. Ziggler's a good wrestler but I don't think he's that good of a heel. I find his character to be very basic and generic. MVP on the other hand used to ooze charisma as a heel. Yes Dolph is a better in ring performer but MVP is pretty good too. I think MVP as a heel good be World CHamp.

 

[Y2JChrisJericho]

MVP to me by far, I thought his heel persona is good enough for a world title run. He is pretty good in the ring too but Ziggler is a joy to watch in the ring, so I give him the edge there. I remember MVP was US champion as a heel and he had a great run with the title, and I would love for him to do the same but with the IC title

 

[TheEraofAwesome]

I'm a fan of Ziggler, but when MVP was heel, I loved this guy. This man knows how to present himself and put life into his character, and knows how to cut a promo. Ziggler is still kind of bleh on the mic, but that's why he has Vickie to carry him on that department. My favorite time with MVP was when he was teamed with Matt Hardy. Even though they were rivals, and Hardy was playing the face, they worked well. My answer to this question is MVP.

 

[Ferbian]

I've never found MVP even remotely interesting. Not even back when he was a heel. Dolph Ziggler however is interesting, he's great in the ring, very improving on the microphone and he has more or less everything going for him in his young career. He has every potential to make it big, where as MVP never truly had anything major to offer.

MVP has been rather horrendous inside the ring for quite a while. He's mediocre over and he's never really anything else than a career mid-carder.

Dolph Ziggler is a guy with a big future ahead of him. He has still to really show his true potential, show his prime if you will. Something which MVP has long passed I'd like to believe. Dolph can offer something to WWE in terms of great matches and possibly even some great feuds. MVP on the other hand, face or heel couldn't really offer anything even remotely close to what Dolph has the potential to offer.

So, obviously Dolph is not only the better heel, cause he's actually worth watching. But he's also the better overall wrestler and superstar.

 

[Undertaker the 5th]

Dolph Ziggler over MVP.
I think Dolph's character may not be more interesting, but overall I think he is playing a better heel. You don't have to be so interesting sometimes. Heels for the most part are boring. Look at JBL, or to a certain extent and I know I might get heat for this Chris Jericho. Say what you want, but to me he was boring as hell. He gave almost the same speech every time. The "I'm the best in the world at what I do" thing was cool, but every damn Raw and Smackdown he was in he said it. Along with the same insults all the time to the crowd. He got more interesting towards the few weeks before he got punted. IMO.

 

[Dagger Dias]

MVP already had a heel US title run. That was when he was at his best. He's better than Ziggler, but I don't care for either one of them. MVP is better than Ziggler on the mic and Ziggler is better in the ring. I'd rather see MVP as a heel IC champ than Ziggler though because of how impressive MVP's US title run was when he was still a heel and still relevant, compared to Ziggler's boring current IC run. I don't care for either guy at the moment though but if I had to pick I'd pick MVP.

 

[Jacob]

I would like to see him as a heel. Right now, or at this point he was a lot more talented and interesting as a heel. Dolph would certainly look better as a heel but he his in a good position as a face where as MVP not so much.